The People, the Torah, the God: A Neo-Traditional Jewish Theology
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Gellman Jerome (Yehuda)
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 155
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 979-8-88719-194-2
Артикул: 872961.01.99
Continuing the author’s commitment to neo-traditional constructive Jewish theology, this book is a sequel to Gellman’s trilogy of constructive Jewish theology with Academic Studies Press. The book treats three topics which revise and clarify the author’s views in light of critics and further thought. The book includes a new concept of the Jews as God’s Chosen People for our times; a reply to an argument for the reliability of Torah history; and an approach, not a solution, to the problem of evil for troubled believers and want to be believers.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
THE PEOPLE, THE TORAH, THE GOD A N E O - T R A D I T I O N A L J E W I S H T H E O L O G Y
Emunot: Jewish Philosophy and Kabbalah Series Editor: Dov Schwartz (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Editorial Board: Ada Rapoport Albert, University College, London (d. 2020) Idit Dobbs-Weinstein, Vanderbilt University Gad Freudenthal, CNRS, Paris Gideon Freudenthal, Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv Moshe Idel, Hebrew University, Jerusalem Raphael Jospe, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan Ephraim Kanarfogel, Yeshiva University, New York Menachem Kellner, Haifa University, Haifa Daniel Lasker, Ben Gurion University, Beer Sheva
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 THE PEOPLE, THE TORAH, THE GOD A N E O - T R A D I T I O N A L J E W I S H T H E O L O G Y Jerome Yehuda G E L L M A N
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Gellman, Jerome I., author. Title: The people, the Torah, the God : a Neo-traditional Jewish theology / Jerome Yehuda Gellman. Description: Boston, MA : Academic Studies Press, 2023. | Series: Emunot: Jewish philosophy and kabbalah | Includes bibliographical references. Identifiers: LCCN 2023005154 (print) | LCCN 2023005155 (ebook) | ISBN 9798887191935 (hardback) | ISBN 9798887191942 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9798887191959 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Jews--Election, Doctrine of. | Bible--Evidences, authority, etc. | God ( Judaism) | Judaism--Doctrines. Classification: LCC BM613 .G46 2023 (print) | LCC BM613 (ebook) | DDC 296.3--dc23/ eng/20230213 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2023005154 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2023005155 Copyright © Academic Studies Press, 2023 ISBN 9798887191935 (hardback) ISBN 9798887191942 (adobe pdf) ISBN 9798887191959 (epub) Book design by Lapiz Digital Services Cover design by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Introduction vii Part 1: The People 1 1. A Designated People I: A Figurational View 3 2. A Designated People II: Figuration and Racism 18 3. A Designated People III: Michael Wyschogrod 32 Part 2: The Torah 43 4. A Critique of Torah History 45 5. On a Failed Argument for Torah History 54 6. Moderate Divine Providence 83 Part 3: The God 95 7. A Perfectly Good God 97 8. The Autobiographical Problem of Evil 104 9. A Conceivable, Partial, Soul-Making Theodicy for the Autobiographical Problem of Evil 109 Bibliography 134 Index 141
This book is “neo-traditional” in that, on the one hand, it preserves three doctrines found in traditional Judaism: that the Jews are God’s chosen people, that Torah is from Heaven, and that God is a perfectly good being. On the other hand, it is a book for our times because it provides a new concept of the Jews as God’s chosen people; gives a new way of thinking about the Torah being from Heaven, despite the undermining of Torah history, at least down to its details; and puts forward a conceivable way of squaring, God’s perfect goodness with a good deal of the evil in God’s world. No more than that. Hence, “neo-traditional.” This book is a new treatment of some of the main themes of the previous three books I have published with Academic Studies Press. In the first, And God’s Love Has Overwhelmed Us, I offered a revised conception of the Jews as God’s chosen people. The second, This Was from God, offered a theology acknowledging the undermining of confidence in the history of the Torah while maintaining the divine nature of the Torah. And the third, Perfect Goodness and the God of the Jews, was a theological discussion of God and evil. All three were attempts to demonstrate how to acknowledge the challenges of modernity and, at the same time, to retain a deeply felt faith in God and in God’s Torah. Each of the three themes in this book has undergone refinement, clarification, and correction, both because of critical replies to the earlier books and also Introduction
viii because my ideas have taken a different shape and their formulation has improved. The theses remain basically the same, however. Accordingly, the three parts of this book correspond, respectively, to the three earlier books. Part one, “The People,” is a tighter presentation of my defense, in the first book, of what I now call a “figurational view” of the Jews as God’s chosen people. It also contains an addition to the topic: a critique of Michael Wyschogrod’s view of God’s choice of the Jews. Part two, “The Torah,” includes an extensive revision of my reasons for rejecting the Kuzari Argument for the truth of Torah history, as well as corrections to other content. Part three, “The God,” deals with the problem of evil and the existence of God. I do not pretend for a moment to solve the problem for a believer or a would-be believer; I only want to suggest some ways in which one might be able to live with the problem until one sees a better day. This book is written by a traditional Jew who lives his religious life within the Orthodox community. And my primary audience is people who are traditionminded, as I am, or are attracted to tradition, and for whom the topics in this book are of importance. Others are invited to peek over our shoulders and hopefully gain something from what I have written. My method is to retain, religious belief as innocent until proven guilty, through solid reasons. Only then will I modify the belief, if possible, or, if not possible, I will simply abandon it or put it aside for now. In deference to the tradition, I make only the minimal changes needed to solve the problem in a satisfactory way. No more. And there are changes to be made. Accordingly, in this book, as in the previous three, I address the three basic principles of traditional Judaism: the Jews are God’s chosen people, the Torah is divine, and God is perfectly good. I defend the belief that in an important sense the Jews are God’s chosen; that in an important sense the Torah is divine; and that God is perfectly good and that we can still envision justification for at least a good measure of evil in the world. In each case, I depart from standard understandings of these three principles in order to meet contemporary challenges that cannot be ignored. There are several people to whom I am thankful for their help in various ways. Cass Fisher has been very encouraging and helpful. Tyron Goldschmidt and Samuel Lebens graciously corresponded with me on their views of the Kuzari Argument. I wish to thank Michael Harris for his published criticisms of my view of Jewish chosenness; they prompted me to reformulate my position more tightly. Andrew Gluck challenged my view straight on and prompted me to carefully weigh his critique. Steven Kepnes has been a moral support for me for some time. Alon Goshen-Gottstein has played an important part in my
I n t r o d u c t i o n ix theological development. Samuel Lebens has published critical comments on my rejection of the Kuzari Argument, which have caused me to restate my view in a better way. Jon Levenson wrote a review of This Was from God, as a result of which I augmented my argument.1 Jonathan Malino read several of the chapters in this book. His corrections and spot-on questions have improved my work immeasurably. Eliot Sacks read several chapters and offered keen comments and corrections, which helped me very much. David Shatz corresponded with me on my concept of a perfectly good being, which was very helpful. Tamar Ross has been a pioneer in several of the topics with which I have been engaged, and I remain indebted to her for her thought and wisdom. I thank the Van Leer Institute in Jerusalem and Bayla Pasikov and her staff for providing me with a library environment better than I could have imagined. It is there that I wrote this book. I am most thankful to my study partners— Eliot Sacks, Rabbi Levi Lauer, Rabbi Michael Graetz, Moshe Avraham, Yosef Mendelsohn, and Zev Wrotslavsky—who continue to enrich my religious life and have contributed to my ability and desire to write about these important topics. I wish to thank the staff of Academic Studies Press for their sterling work in preparing this volume. Kate Yanduganova did a marvelous job of editing which much improved what I had written. Kira Nemirovsky did a wonderful job with the production, and Alessandra Anzani, as always, was there to help whenever needed. I want to express my deepest gratitude and admiration for my teacher of philosophy, Alvin Plantinga, of the Christian Reformed Church. His teaching and personal example have been crucial in my life-long engagement with philosophy of religion and Jewish theology. I am greatly appreciative of Edie, without whom I would be wandering all alone by now, confused, in a dark forest, trying to find my way out, in pouring rain, and freezing cold. I owe so much to her. In so many ways this is our book. The Chapters Part one of the book is called “The People.” The first chapter presents a view of Jewish chosenness that is figurational, in the sense that God’s love of the 1 Jon Levenson, “Divine Revelation and Historical Criticism: A Review Essay,” review of This Was from God: A Contemporary Theology of Torah and History, by Jerome Yehuda Gellman, Modern Judaism 37 (2017): 392–402.
x Jews is a figure of God’s love for all of humanity. Because of the figurational view it would be clearer to say that the Jews have been “designated” by God rather than “chosen.” Chapter two presents a characterization of what it is for a person to hold a racist opinion and measures the figurational view against racist vulnerabilities. I then defend the figurational view from critiques by Michael Harris and Andrew Gluck, respectively. Chapter three examines the influential version of Jewish chosenness by the late Michael Wyschogrod. I argue that Wyschogrod’s reasoning for his view is non-convincing. So, I remain with my figurational view. Part two is on the Torah. Chapter four briefly surveys the reasons why the history of the Torah has been put into doubt by modern research. This requires a new faith-approach to the sense in which the Torah is from God. Chapter five examines the so-called “Kuzari Argument” for the truth of Torah history. I examine this argument because in recent times it has become popular in some Orthodox circles as a way of convincing Jews to become Orthodox. I am all in favor of people becoming some sort of Orthodox, but believe the argument fails, leaving us with the problem of history. While there is something right about the Kuzari Argument, on examination it proves to lack what it takes to reinstate Torah history in any serious way. Chapter six puts forward the thesis that a person of faith should think of God as being behind the historical process of bringing to light of the problems with Torah history, so as to lead us to a new reading of the stories of the Torah. So, when we fashion new approaches, we are not acting independently of God but as God’s servants. I recommend Hasidic literature as a prototype for a non-historical approach to the stories of the Torah. I introduce the concept of divine moderate providence to portray the Torah as God’s Torah, in consistency with modern findings. Part three is about God. This part follows the portion of my book Perfect Goodness and the God of the Jews that deals with the problems of evil and God’s perfect goodness. The seventh chapter lays out what I call “the autobiographical problem of evil.” This problem does not emerge from philosophical reflection about God and evil but due to a person’s inability or difficulty of accepting God in the face of the evil she knows. Chapter eight explicates what I propose we should mean by calling God “a perfectly good being,” a notion without which the autobiographical problem of evil might not start. The final chapter of the book provides what I call a possible, partial theodicy, a proposal for why God might allow much of the evil we find in this world. The purpose is to open the sufferer of the autobiographical problem to the possibility of being able to imagine a reason why God might allow much of the world’s evils. The theodicy is partial, for I am not prepared to advance it for some of the horrendous evils the world and the Jewish people are made to endure.