Israel and the Nations: The Bible, the Rabbis, and Jewish-Gentile Relations
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Korn Eugene
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 199
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 979-8-88719-006-8
Артикул: 872955.01.99
Israel and the Nations: The Bible, The Rabbis, and Jewish-Gentile Relations explores the Jewish theology and law (Halakhah) relating to non-Jews. It analyzes biblical, talmudic, medieval, and contemporary Jewish writings about gentiles and their religions.
The Bible challenges the Jewish people to be "a blessing for all the families of the earth.” Yet throughout history, Jewish experience with gentiles was complex. In the biblical and talmudic eras most gentiles were assumed to be idolators. In the Middle Ages most rabbis considered their Christian neighbors idolators, and Christian enmity sharpened the otherness Jews felt toward their Christian hosts. Muslims were monotheists, but Jewish-Muslim relations were sometimes positive and at other times difficult. With the advent secular tolerance in modernity, Jews found themselves in a new relationship with their gentile neighbors. How should Jews relate to gentiles today, and what are the bounds of Jewish tolerance and religious pluralism?
The book will interest both Jewish laypersons familiar with Jewish tradition as well as scholars of theology and interfaith relations.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
The Bible, the Rabbis, and Jewish-Gentile Relations Israel and the Nations
Emunot: Jewish Philosophy and Kabbalah Series Editor: Dov Schwartz (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Editorial Board: Ada Rapoport Albert, University College, London (d. 2020) Idit Dobbs-Weinstein, Vanderbilt University Gad Freudenthal, CNRS, Paris Gideon Freudenthal, Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv Moshe Idel, Hebrew University, Jerusalem Raphael Jospe, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan Ephraim Kanarfogel, Yeshiva University, New York Menachem Kellner, Haifa University, Haifa Daniel Lasker, Ben Gurion University, Beer Sheva
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 The Bible, the Rabbis, and Jewish-Gentile Relations Emunot: Jewish Philosophy and Kabbalah Israel and the Nations Eugene Korn
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Korn, Eugene, 1947- author. Title: Israel and the nations: the Bible, the rabbis, and Jewish-gentile relations / Eugene Korn. Description: Boston, MA: Academic Studies Press, [2023] | Series: Emunot: Jewish philosophy and Kabbalah | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2022027888 (print) | LCCN 2022027889 (ebook) | ISBN 9798887190051 (hardback) | ISBN 9798887190068 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9798887190075 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Gentiles in rabbinical literature. | Gentiles in the Bible. | Judaism--Relations--Christianity. | Christianity and other religions--Judaism. | Bible. Old Testament--Criticism, interpretation, etc. | Rabbinical literature-- History and criticism. Classification: LCC BM720.N6 K68 2022 (print) | LCC BM720.N6 (ebook) | DDC 220.8/3058--dc23/eng/20220709 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2022027888 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2022027889 Copyright © 2023 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN 9798887190051 (hardback) ISBN 9798887190068 (Adobe PDF) ISBN 9798887190075 (ePub) Book design by Kryon Publishing Services. Cover design by Ivan Grave. Published by Academic Studies Press. 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
וְנִבְ רְ כ֣ ּו בְ ָך֔ ּכֹ֖ ל מִ ׁשְ ּפְ חֹ֥ ת הָאֲדָמָֽ ה “And all the families of the earth shall bless themselves by you” Genesis 12:3
Contents Introduction: Reassessing Jewish-Gentile Relations Today Part One: Judaism, Jews, and Gentiles 7 1. The Covenant and Its Theology 9 2. Israel as Blessing: Theological Horizons 23 3. Extra Synagogam Nulla Salus? Judaism and the Religious Other 43 4. Revelation, Gentiles, and the World to Come 65 5. Idolatry Today 89 Part Two: Judaism, Jews, and Christianity 99 6. Rethinking Christianity: Rabbinic Positions and Possibilities 101 7. Esau Hates Jacob 132 8. The Man of Faith and Religious Dialogue 140 9. The People Israel, Christianity, and the Covenantal Responsibility to History 166 Bibliography 179 Index 190
Introduction Reassessing Jewish-Gentile Relations Today As the foundation of Jewish culture and identity, the Bible challenges the Jewish people in numerous ways to be “a blessing for all the families of the earth.” This implies that the Jewish people should engage with gentiles in some way. Yet in both the Bible and the living historical reality of the Jewish people, Jewish experience with gentiles has been complex and fraught with difficulties. In biblical times most gentiles were idolators whom Jews were prohibited from befriending. Yet this is not the entire story: there were exceptions whom the Talmudic rabbis termed benei Noah (those who follow the Noahide covenant) and resident strangers (gerei toshav) whom the Bible and rabbinic tradition directed Jews to respect and even protect. In the post-Talmudic era also, most gentiles were assumed to be idolators. Throughout the Middle Ages, most rabbis considered their Christian neighbors in Ashkenaz (Germany, France, England, Poland, Russia) to be idolators. Moreover, Jewish-Christian enmity sharpened the sense of otherness that Jews felt toward their Christian hosts. Because Muslims were pure monotheists, most rabbis did not consider them idolators, and relations between Jews and Muslims were sometimes positive and other times difficult. With the advent of the modern era and secular tolerance, Jews found themselves in a new relationship with their gentile neighbors. In addition, the last eighty years has transformed Jewish-gentile relations in an unprecedented way. Political Zionism and the establishment the Jewish State of Israel in the Middle East has given rise to increased adversarial relations with the Muslims—particularly Arab Muslims. And while Middle Eastern Christians remain largely supersessionist and hostile to the continued validity of Judaism, the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s caused a Copernican revolution in Christian theology about the Jewish people and Judaism among most Western Christians. The fruit of the revolution is continuing theological and empirical reconciliation between Christianity and the Jewish people. Lastly, because so much of modern life takes place in a shrinking global village, Jews
today frequently meet non-Abrahamic believers and come to learn about Asian religions to a degree unprecedented in Jewish history. What does Jewish thought and Jewish law (Halakhah) have to say about how Jews should understand, evaluate, and relate to Christians, Muslims, Asian believers, and secular gentiles in the past and today? And should Jewish-gentile relations change when Jews are a minority in the Diaspora and when Jews are the dominant majority in the State of Israel? What are the bounds of tolerance and Jewish religious pluralism? The essays in this book examine these issues. The opening essay, “The Covenant and Its Theology,” demonstrates that the central idea of covenant (berit) in Judaism requires theological principles to give Jewish religious thought coherence and urgency. The idea of the particularistic Jewish covenant immediately creates an insider/outsider problem: How should Jews inside the covenant relate to those people who stand outside the covenant? And does acknowledging the divinity of the particularist Jewish covenant imply that other purported religious covenants cannot not be valid? At the very outset of God establishing a covenant with Abraham and his descendants stands the challenge to be a blessing to the world (Gen. 12:3). Blessing is also implicit in God’s call for Israel to be a nation of priests (Ex. 19:15–16), since the function of priests is to be conduits of God’s blessings to His1 human children. But what is the meaning of this blessing, and how should the Jewish people fulfill this theological mission? Clearly, these biblical challenges entail Abraham’s children exercising influence on humanity, but the Bible does not tell us how this blessing is to be achieved. Is Israel’s role to actively engage gentiles, be passive models of excellence for non-Jews, or merely to engage in theurgic piety that results in divine overflow of goodness to gentiles? Chapter 2, “Israel as Blessing: Theological Horizons,” analyzes these options found within rabbinic writings. “Extra Synagogam Nulla Salus? Judaism and the Religious Other” argues from traditional rabbinic principles that authentic Jewish thought allows for limited religious pluralism, and requires Jewish moral and civil responsibilities 1 Throughout this book I use the masculine “Him,” “His,” and “He” in reference to God as a linguistic convention only, and do not want to imply any gender or gender preference to God. In the Jewish theological tradition, God transcends gender although in attempting to understand God it is helpful to ascribe to God traits traditionally associated with both masculinity (such as authority and punishment) and femininity (such as compassion and nurturing). This has significant pedagogical implications: Imitatio Dei would demand that human beings also strive to develop a combination of personality traits as religious and ethical ideals. According to Jewish mysticism, all these traits will merge into a perfect unity in the messianic era—in both God and His creatures.
I n t r o d u c t i o n to the gentile stranger (Hebrew: ger toshav). “Revelation, Gentiles, and the World to Come” extends the argument of the previous essay by analyzing the historic debate among Jewish thinkers regarding whether gentiles must acknowledge classic Mosaic revelation at Sinai to gain eternal life and be loved by God. “Idolatry Today” examines the two major biblical and rabbinic understandings of idolatry, asking whether idolatry has any application in today’s world. It argues that a contemporary definition of idolatry that combines the two classical conceptions is necessary today as a basis for rejecting religious violence and intolerance. In Europe and America Jewish exposure to and engagement with gentiles has predominantly meant interaction with Christians and their faith. The last four essays discuss philosophical, theological, and halakhic considerations of the particular relationship between Judaism and Christianity. “Rethinking Christianity: Rabbinic Positions and Possibilities” surveys traditional rabbinic evaluations of Christianity and Christians in light of the changes in Christian thinking about Judaism and the Jewish people, as well as contemporary social, political, and religious realities. Is it possible today to overcome the polemics and hostilities of the past to form sympathetic and constructive relationships for the future? The chapter points to a way for greater Jewish appreciation of Christianity as a faith and for Jews to see the Image of God in the face of a believing Christian—all within the parameters of Jewish law. “Esau Hates Jacob” reviews an age-old but still influential rabbinic dictum. Using recent scholarship, the chapter analyzes whether hatred between Jews and Christians is built into the universe as an irreversible law of nature, as some traditional rabbinic hermeneutics imply. “The Man of Faith and Religious Dialogue” analyzes in detail the thought of Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik regarding interfaith dialogue and its limits, which has become the dominant policy for Orthodox participation in interfaith events. The essay suggests that much of R. Soloveitchik’s public policy on interfaith dialogue has been misunderstood and his concerns about supersessionist policy by the Catholic Church toward Jews are no longer a factor in today’s Jewish-Catholic—and most Jewish-Christian—dialogue. Lastly, “The People Israel, Christianity, and the Covenantal Responsibility to History,” argues for a Jewish understanding of contemporary Christianity that allows traditional Jews to see Christians as participants in the covenant of Abraham, and partners with Jews in a mission to be a kingdom of priests to bring divine blessing to humanity and human history. In sum, this book takes up texts, questions, and arguments essential to Jewish-gentile relations, Jewish law, and religious thought. It analyzes the issues
standing at the heart of the critical discussion about Jewish teachings regarding gentiles and how Jews do and should behave toward others in contemporary life. It is my hope that this book will interest Christian scholars, clergy, and laity, as well as Jews interested in interfaith relations, and that the volume be a valuable resource for scholars, clergy, and laypersons in ongoing discussions about current Jewish experience and thought. Unlike how traditional rabbis and theologians understood the primordial creation of the universe, no human thinking is done ex nihilo, out of a vacuum. Even scholars who achieve conceptual breakthroughs rely on intellectual antecedents and build on the work of those who come before them. In trying to explain the twists and turns of Jewish thinking about non-Jews and point to a constructive Jewish orientation of relating to humanity today, I have been blessed to be able to stand on the shoulders of previous giants, among them the Talmudic rabbis and medieval Tosafists, Maimonides, Rabbis Menahem Meiri, Yaaqov Emden, and Samson Raphael Hirsch, the historian Jacob Katz, and the contemporary theologians Joseph B. Soloveitchik, Abraham Heschel, and David Hartman. And much of this book would have been impossible without the Christian visionaries Popes John XXIII and John Paul II, A. Roy Eckardt, Alice L. Eckardt, and Krister Stendahl. I am indebted to many scholars, rabbis, clergy, and friends with whom I have discussed these ideas over the years, who commented on my initial drafts of this material and improved it immeasurably. They include Professors Menachem Ben Sasson, David Berger, Phillip Cunningham, Shlomo Fisher, Yehuda Gellman, Alon Goshen-Gottstein, Robert Jenson, Menachem Kellner, Martin Lochshin, Gerald McDermott, Robert McKim, Don Seeman, and Noam Zion, as well as Rabbis Irving Greenberg, David Hartman, David Rosen, Shlomo Riskin, Jonathan Sacks, and Fathers Dennis McManus and John Pawlikowski and Sister Mary Boys. Many of the chapters were published previously in different form. They have been updated and I have tried to weave them into a seamless coherent whole. I gratefully acknowledge the following for granting permission to republish the material, even when altered: Meorot for “The Covenant and Its Theology”; Academic Studies Press for “Israel as Blessing: Theological Horizons,” which appeared in Judaism’s Challenge: Election, Divine Love, and Human Enmity, edited by Alon Goshen-Gottstein. Brill Publications for “Extra Synagogam Nulla Salus? Judaism and the Religious Other,” which originally appeared in Religious Perspectives on Religious Diversity, edited by Robert McKim.