Defenders of the Faith. Studies in Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Orthodoxy and Reform
Покупка
Тематика:
Беллетристика и публицистика
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Bleich Judith
Год издания: 2020
Кол-во страниц: 441
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-145-8
Артикул: 872932.01.99
Emancipation of European Jewry during the nineteenth century led to conflict between tradition and modernity, creating a chasm that few believed could be bridged. The emergence of modern traditionalism was fraught with obstacles. The essays published in this collection eloquently depict the passion underlying the disparate views, the particular areas of vexing confrontation and the hurdles faced by champions of tradition. The author identifies and analyzes the many areas of sociological and religious tension that divided the competing factions, including synagogue innovation, circumcision, intermarriage, military service and many others. With compelling writing and facile style, this illuminating work provides keen insight into the history and development of the various streams of Judaism and the issues that continue to divide them in contemporary times.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Touro University Press Books Series Editor MICHAEL A. SHMIDMAN, PhD (Touro College, New York) SIMCHA FISHBANE, PhD (Touro College, New York)
New York
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Bleich, Judith, 1938- author. Title: Defenders of the faith: studies in nineteenth- and twentieth-century Orthodoxy and Reform / Judith Bleich. Description: New York: Touro University Press, 2020. | Includes index. Identifiers: LCCN 2019029144 (print) | LCCN 2019029145 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644691441 (hardcover) | ISBN 9781644691458 (adobe pdf) Subjects: LCSH: Orthodox Judaism—Relations—Nontraditional Jews. | Orthodox Judaism. | Reform Judaism. | Judaism—19th century. | Judaism—20th century. Classification: LCC BM197.6 .B54 2020 (print) | LCC BM197.6 (ebook) | DDC 296.8/3209034—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019029144 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019029145 Copyright © Touro University Press, 2020 Published by Touro University Press and Academic Studies Press. Typeset, printed and distributed by Academic Studies Press. ISBN 9781644691441 (hardcover) ISBN 9781644692639 (paperback) ISBN 9781644691458 (electronic) Touro University Press Michael A. Shmidman and Simcha Fishbane, Editors 320 West 31st Street, Fourth Floor, New York, NY 10001, USA tcpress@touro.edu Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com Book design by Kryon Publishing Services, Inc. kryonpublishing.com On the cover: Six-page pamphlet. Shelomei Emunei Yisra'el/Treue Glaubige in Israel, c1845. (Rabbinic Manifesto in response to the first Reform Conference, Brunswick, 1844). Courtesy of the Leo Baeck Institute, New York.
Table of Contents Preface vii Introduction. Nineteenth to Twenty-First Centuries: From Pessimism to Optimism ix 1. Rabbinic Responses to Nonobservance in the Modern Era 1 2. The Emergence of an Orthodox Press in Nineteenth-Century Germany 60 3. The Circumcision Controversy in Classical Reform in Historical Context 85 4. Clerical Robes: Distinction or Dishonor? 108 5. Intermarriage in the Early Modern Period 136 6. Military Service: Ambivalence and Contradiction 174 7. The Testament of a Halakhist 227 8. Between East and West: Modernity and Traditionalism in the Writings of Rabbi Yehi’el Ya‘akov Weinberg 243 9. Liturgical Innovation and Spirituality: Trends and Trendiness 337 Index 413
Preface T he present volume is a collection of essays on Orthodoxy and Reform that appeared over a span of years, presented here with relatively minor additions and revisions. I wish to express my gratitude to the publishers of the journals and books in which these papers were originally featured. The following is a list of these essays and the publications in which they appeared: “The Emergence of an Orthodox Press in Nineteenth-Century Germany,” Jewish Social Studies 13, nos. 3–4 (Summer/Fall 1980), 323–344; “The Testament of a Halakhist,” Tradition 20, no. 3 (Fall 1982), 235–248; “Rabbinic Responses to Nonobservance in the Modern Era,” in Jewish Tradition and the Nontraditional Jew, ed. Jacob J. Schacter, vol. 2 of the Orthodox Forum Series (Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, Inc., 1992), 37–115; “Between East and West: Modernity and Traditionalism in the Writings of Rabbi Yehi’el Ya‘akov Weinberg,” in Engaging Modernity: Rabbinic Leaders and the Challenge of the Twentieth Century, ed. Moshe Z. Sokol, vol. 6 of the Orthodox Forum Series (Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, Inc., 1997), 169–273; “Liturgical Innovation and Spirituality: Trends and Trendiness,” in Jewish Spirituality and Divine Law, ed. Adam Mintz and Lawrence Schiffman, vol. 10 of the Orthodox Forum Series (New York: Yeshiva University Press, 2005), 315–405; “Military Service: Ambivalence and Contradiction,” in War and Peace in the Jewish Tradition, ed. Lawrence Schiffman and Joel B. Wolowelsky, vol. 15 of the Orthodox Forum Series (New York: Yeshiva University Press, 2007), 415–476; “The Circumcision Controversy in Classical Reform in Historical Context,” in Turim: Studies in Jewish History and Literature Presented to Dr. Bernard Lander, vol. 1, ed. Michael A. Shmidman (New York: Touro College Press, 2007), 1–28; “Intermarriage in the Early Modern Period,” in Conversion, Intermarriage and Jewish Identity, ed. Robert S. Hirt, Adam Mintz and Marc Stein, vol. 23 of the Orthodox Forum Series (New York: Yeshiva University Press, 2015), 3–46; and “Clerical Robes: Distinction or Dishonor?” in Dynamics of Continuity and Change in Jewish
viii Religious Life, ed. Simcha Fishbane and Eric Levine (New York: Touro College Press, 2018), 198–225. As is evident from the foregoing, many of the essays included in this work were delivered as papers at symposia sponsored by the Orthodox Forum and were published in volumes of the Orthodox Forum Series. I am indebted to the Forum for serving as a stimulus to my research and wish to voice my appreciation and gratitude to the participants in the Forum, to the editors of the various volumes and to the general editor of the series, Rabbi Robert S. Hirt. I wish to express my appreciation to Ekaterina Yanduganova of Academic Studies Press for her painstaking efforts in preparing the manuscript for publication; to Max Lindenfeld for his meticulous proofreading of the galleys; to Karen Rubin, Administrative Manager, Touro College Graduate School of Jewish Studies, for her constant helpfulness; and to Carol Schapiro and Toby Krausz of the Touro College Graduate School Library for their gracious assistance. It has been my singular privilege and pleasure to be a member of the faculty of Touro College for well over four decades, surrounded by dedicated scholars in a rare atmosphere of intellectual rigor, idealism and warmth. I am indebted in particular to the unforgettable visionary and indefatigable pioneer, Dr. Bernard Lander, of blessed memory, founder and first president of Touro College; to his worthy successor, Dr. Alan Kadish; to the beloved Dean of the Graduate School of Jewish Studies, Dr. Michael A. Shmidman; to Dr. Marian Stoltz-Loike and Dr. David Luchins, devoted Deans of Lander College for Women; to the distinguished former Chairman of the Judaic Studies Department at Lander College for Women, Dr. Samuel N. Hoenig; to my esteemed colleagues; and especially to the generations of students with whom I have had the honor and privilege of studying Torah. Above all, I thank the Almighty for my cherished collaborators, the members of my family. Our prayer to the Almighty is that we merit to continue to witness children and children’s children immersed in Torah and mitzvot.
Introduction Nineteenth to Twenty-First Centuries: From Pessimism to Optimism J ewish history has been marked by recurrent periods of spiritual deprivation and religious apathy. Despite those vicissitudes, Rabbenu Bahya, Ḥovot ha-Levavot, Sha‘ar ha-Teshuvah, chapter 6, offers optimistic assurance that at no time will the people of Israel be bereft of leadership: “Thus has it been in all periods and all countries. There has never been lacking a “kor’e el ha-Elokim ve-el avodato u-moreh et Torato—a person who calls [his coreligionists] to God and to His service and teaches His Law.” The crumbling of the walls of the ghetto in the years following the Emancipation created welcome economic, social, and political opportunities but at the same time brought in its wake novel and unprecedented problems. Tides of assimilation eroded the religious spirit that had successfully withstood centuries of persecution and direct onslaught. It was generally accepted, almost axiomatically, that the social transformations that characterized the times spelled the inevitable demise of a traditional lifestyle that was incompatible with the regnant modernity. Protests and remonstrations expressed in shrill tones by old-time patriarchal figures were deemed to be nothing more than the death throes of an outmoded and anachronistic clerical establishment. To the radical Reform ideologue, Samuel Holdheim, adherence to rabbinic Judaism necessarily entailed removing oneself from the contemporary stage. There was, he claimed, a clear-cut choice: “Either to be a rabbinic Jew and live outside the times or live within the times and cease to be a rabbinic Jew . . . .
x Introduction Nineteenth to Twenty-First Centuries: From Pessimism to Optimism Rabbinic Judaism is the diametric opposite of our time.”1 No wonder that the masterful bibliographer Moritz Steinschneider, to whom “Wissenschaft des Judentums was an end in itself,”2 described his meticulous recording of rabbinic texts as an honorable burial for a moribund culture.3 The prominent nineteenth-century American Reform spokesman, Isaac Mayer Wise, mistakenly predicted that in the twentieth century the majority of Americans of all faiths would become Jews, but he also foretold that there would be no future for adherents of what he termed the “half-civilized orthodoxy” and those who “gnawed the dead bones of past centuries.”4 He was fully conscious of the sharp divide between Reform congregations and other elements of the Jewish populace and was even desirous of formalizing a schism. 1 Samuel Holdheim, Das Cermonialgesetz im Messiasreich (Schwerin, 1845), 122–123, cited in translation by Michael A. Meyer, “Should and Can an Antiquated Belief Become Modern? The Jewish Reform Movement in Germany as Seen by Jews and Christians,” in The Jews in European History: Seven Lectures, ed. Wolfgang Beck (Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press, 1994), 65. 2 Michael A. Meyer, Response to Modernity: A History of the Reform Movement in Judaism (New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), 76. 3 Steinschneider’s statement to this effect has been widely cited and disparaged. See, for example, Milton Himmelfarb, The Jews of Modernity (New York: Basic Books, 1973), 8 and Arthur Hertzberg and Aron Hirt-Manheimer, Jews: The Essence and Character of a People (San Francisco: Harper Collins, 1998), 240–241. However, the accuracy of the attribution of this comment has also been the subject of dispute. The remark, “Wir haben nur noch die Aufgabe die Überreste des Judenthums ehrenvoll zu bestatten” (“We now only have to give a decent burial to the remains of Judaism”), famously attributed to Steinschneider, is not found in his published writings but was posthumously attributed to him by Gotthold Weil, Jüdische Rundschau, February 8, 1907, 54. See the intriguing account by Charlies H. Manekin, “Steinschneider’s ‘Decent Burial.’ A Reappraisal,” in Study and Knowledge in Jewish Thought, ed. Howard Kreisel (Beer Sheva: Ben Gurion University Press, 1996), 239–251. For Gershom Scholem’s trenchant criticism of Steinschneider see Gershom Scholem, “Mitokh Hirhurim al Ḥokhmat Yisra’el,” in Devarim be-Go (Tel Aviv: Am Oved, 1975), 385–405. Compare, however, the strong reaction of Avriel Bar-Levav, “A Living Citizen in a World of Dead Letters: Steinschneider Remembered,” Studies on Steinschneider: Moritz Steinschneider and the Emergence of the Science of Judaism in Nineteenth-Century Germany (Leiden: Brill, 2012), 339–348. See the more recent carefully reasoned and measured assessment of Michael A. Meyer and Ismar Schorsch, “‘Zunz and Steinschneider Would be Astonished— and Reassured’: Two Senior Scholars of Wissenschaft Reflect on Its 200th Anniversary,” Pardes, Journal of the German Association for Jewish Studies 24 (2018), 19–23. Whether or not the comments attributed to Steinschneider are indeed his exact words and accurately reflect his sentiments, they certainly typify the views espoused by many of the exponents of Wissenschaft des Judentums and are emblematic of the attitude so forcefully attacked by the Orthodox critics of the Wissenschaft agenda. See, for example, Samson Raphael Hirsch, The Collected Writings, vol. VII (Jerusalem and New York: Feldheim Publishers, 1997), 42. 4 The American Israelite 33, no. 31 (Jan. 28, 1887), 4.