Книжная полка Сохранить
Размер шрифта:
А
А
А
|  Шрифт:
Arial
Times
|  Интервал:
Стандартный
Средний
Большой
|  Цвет сайта:
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц

Beyond Jewish Identity. Rethinking Concepts and Imagining Alternatives

Покупка
Артикул: 872929.01.99
Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину
There is something deeply problematic about the ways that Jews, particularly in America, talk about "Jewish identity” as a desired outcome of Jewish education. For many, the idea that the purpose of Jewish education is to strengthen Jewish identity is so obvious that it hardly seems worth disputing — and the only important question is which kinds of Jewish education do that work more effectively or more efficiently. But what does it mean to "strengthen Jewish identity”? Why do Jewish educators, policy-makers and philanthropists talk that way? What do they assume, about Jewish education or about Jewish identity, when they use formulations like "strengthen Jewish identity”? And what are the costs of doing so? This volume, the first collection to examine critically the relationship between Jewish education and Jewish identity, makes two important interventions. First, it offers a critical assessment of the relationship between education and identity, arguing that the reification of identity has hampered much educational creativity in the pursuit of this goal, and that the nearly ubiquitous employment of the term obscures significant questions about what Jewish education is and ought to be. Second, this volume offers thoughtful responses that are not merely synonymous replacements for "identity,” suggesting new possibilities for how to think about the purposes and desired outcomes of Jewish education, potentially contributing to any number of new conversations about the relationship between Jewish education and Jewish life.
Beyond Jewish Identity. Rethinking Concepts and Imagining Alternatives : монография / Ed. by J. A. Levisohn, A. Y. Kelman. – Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2019. - 291 с. – ISBN 978-1-64469-117-5. - Текст : электронный. - URL: https://znanium.ru/catalog/product/2240531 (дата обращения: 18.11.2026). – Режим доступа: по подписке.
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
BEYOND 
JEWISH 
IDENTITY
Rethinking Concepts 
and Imagining 
Alternatives




BOSTON
BEYOND JEWISH
IDENTITY
rethinking concepts and 
imagining alternatives
Edited by
JON A. LEVISOHN
and ARI Y. KELMAN


Library of Congress Control Number:2019943604
The research for this book and its publication were made possible by the 
generous support of the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Center for Studies 
in Jewish Education, a partnership between Brandeis University and the Jack, 
Joseph and Morton Mandel Foundation of Cleveland, Ohio.
© Academic Studies Press, 2019 
ISBN 978-1-64469-116-8 (hardcover) 
ISBN 978-1-64469-117-5 (electronic)
Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd.
www.kryonpublishing.com
Cover design by Ivan Grave
Published by Academic Studies Press
1577 Beacon Street
Brookline, MA 02446, USA
press@academicstudiespress.com
www.academicstudiespress.com


Table of Contents
Introduction
vii
Jon A. Levisohn and Ari Y. Kelman
Taking Jewish Identity Metaphors Literally
1
Eli Gottlieb
You are Jewish if You Want to Be: The Limits of Identity 
in a World of Multiple Practices
17
Samira K. Mehta
On the Origins and Persistence of the Jewish 
Identity Industry in Jewish Education
36
Jonathan Krasner
Identity and Crisis: The Origins of Identity as an 
Educational Outcome
65
Ari Y. Kelman
Regarding the “Real” Jew: Authenticity Anxieties 
Around Poland’s “Generation Unexpected”
84
Katka Reszke
Re-Thinking American Jewish Zionist Identity: 
A Case for Post-Zionism in the Diaspora (Based on 
the Writings of R. Menachem Froman)
113
Shaul Magid
Jewish Educators Don’t Make Jews: A Sociological 
Reality Check About Jewish Identity Work
144
Tali Zelkowicz


vi
Table of Contents
Beyond Language Proficiency: Fostering Metalinguistic 
Communities in Jewish Educational Settings
167
Sarah Bunin Benor and Netta Avineri
Where is the Next Soviet Jewry Movement? How Identity 
Education Forgot the Lessons that Jewish Activism Taught
193
Shaul Kelner
Jewish Education as Initiation into the Practices of Jewishness
216
Jon A. Levisohn
Jewish Sensibilities: Toward a New Language for 
Jewish Educational Goal-Setting
241
Lee Moore and Jonathan Woocher, z”l
Index
266


Introduction
Jon A. Levisohn and Ari Y. Kelman
T
his book is motivated by the deep discomfort that we, the editors, feel 
with the way that the phrase “Jewish identity” is often used by educators, 
educational policy makers, and other leaders in the Jewish community, 
especially (although not exclusively) in the United States. To be sure, we have 
learned much from colleagues who have written rigorously and insightfully 
about the ways that Jews understand themselves, about how Jewishness is 
enacted in contemporary settings, and about the ways that Jewish identity 
coexists alongside other identities (to name a few key studies: Cohen, 1974, 
1983; Cohen & Eisen, 2000; Dashefsky & Shapiro, 1974; Hahn Tapper 2016; 
Hartman & Hartman, 1999; Hartman & Kaufman, 2006; Hartman & Sheskin, 
2011; Horowitz, 1998, 1999, 2002; Pomson & Schnoor, 2018; Sagi, 2016; 
Sklare, 1967). But we also regularly encounter assumptions about the fixedness 
of Jewish identity, about the quantifiability of Jewish identity, and especially 
about the role of Jewish education in strengthening Jewish identity—
assumptions that generated the discomfort to which we have already alluded. 
We launched the project that led to this book when we discovered that the two 
of us shared this discomfort. We wanted to understand the uses of the phrase 
“Jewish identity” in Jewish educational discourse, to develop and articulate 
our concerns with greater precision, to invite others into a conversation about 
how and why the phrase “Jewish identity” is used, and most aspirationally, to 
generate alternative ways that we might understand the desired outcomes of 
Jewish educational interventions. 
To be clear, there is no unified definition of Jewish identity and no single 
discourse (some of the more diverse discussions include Cadge & Davidman, 
2016; Charmé, 2000; Charmé, Horowitz, Hyman, Hyman, & Kress, 2008; 
Cohen, E., 2010; Dashefsky, Lazerwitz, & Tabory, 2003; Gitelman, 2009; 
Harvey, Cohen, & Kopelowitz, 2001; Herman, 1977; Kaufman, 1999, 2005; 
Kelman et al., 2017a, 2017b; Liebman, 1999; Magid, 2013; Moore, 2008; 
Oppenheim, 1984; Prell, 2000; Reszke, 2013; Thompson, 2013). The haredi 


viii
Jon A. Levisohn and Ari Y. Kelman
or utra-Orthodox world eschews the term altogether, and it is less common 
in the Modern Orthodox community than it is in liberal Jewish communities. 
Still, there are important patterns and trends. Since the late 1960s, the phrase 
has grown in popularity and stature, often appearing as an almost self-reflexive 
rationale for many Jewish educational and communal efforts. “It’s Official,” 
trumpeted a headline reporting on a study by Steven Cohen and his colleagues 
of Jewish summer camps (Cohen, Miller, Sheshkin, & Torr, 2011), “Jewish 
Camp Strengthens Jewish Identity” (Fishkoff, 2011). 
The popularity of the phrase left us feeling more and more uncomfortable 
with the range of experiences, meanings, self-conceptions, expressions, and 
affinities to which it seemed to refer. The more popular it grew, it seemed, 
the less well-defined it appeared to become. As our sense of this development 
deepened, we were gratified to learn about other scholarly voices that expressed 
concern with or critical perspectives on the phrase, its meaning and its utility 
(Brubaker & Cooper, 2000; Comaroff & Comaroff, 2009; Fearon, 1999; 
Gleason, 1983; Nicholson, 2008), and we started to gather like-minded fellow 
travelers. In fact, our work on the project got to the point where some of our 
colleagues accused us, only half in jest, of starting a movement to ban the use of 
the phrase “Jewish identity” altogether. 
This is not quite accurate. We affirm that there are good and important 
ways that the phrase “Jewish identity” can and should be used by scholars 
of contemporary Jewish life. There may even be ways that the term can and 
should be used by educators and scholars of education; some of these will be 
suggested in the chapters that follow. If so, then what do we mean when we 
suggest that we need to go “beyond Jewish identity”? What’s wrong with the 
discourse of Jewish identity that we need to go beyond it? And what might lie 
beyond? Each of the contributors to this book has their own perspective on 
these questions, of course. But in general, we can point to some broad themes 
that tie together the chapters of this book. 
First, the discourse of Jewish identity tends to treat identity as unified 
and relatively static. To be sure, Jewish communal discourse often describes or 
advocates efforts to “strengthen” or “build” identity, so nobody really thinks that 
identity is absolutely static. If it were, it could not be strengthened! The claim 
that a stronger Jewish identity is the appropriate desired outcome of Jewish 
educational projects and programs is predicated on the assumption that those 
interventions can change identity, somehow, in positive ways. Still, scholars, 
researchers, communal leaders, and philanthropists often treat identity as if 
it is a unified thing, which a person simply has. That’s why studies often seek 


ix
Introduction
to distinguish “strong Jewish identities” from “weak Jewish identities,” and 
why interventions seek to transform the latter into the former. Implicit in this 
framework is a moral hierarchy between supposed strength and perceived 
weakness. Having a “strong Jewish identity” comes to mean, roughly, being 
more normatively involved in Jewish life, or more interested in or committed 
to Jewish causes, communities, knowledge, etc. In order to measure the relative 
strength or weakness of an identity, one must first create a series of metrics that 
suggest objectivity. What often results, however, is the creation of an identity 
concept that ranks Jewish identities and, in the process, turns a group of people 
who identify as Jewish into lesser versions of some imagined gold standard of 
Jewish identity. They literally do not measure up. 
Surely, one can be Jewish—one can identify as Jewish, one can “have a 
Jewish identity”—in both strong and weak ways, in combination, conflict, 
and conversation with other commitments to other identities that one holds. 
This is the nature of identity. It is not a zero-sum game; there is no finite 
amount of identity to go around, such that being more of x (more American 
or more Western; more of a male or a professor or a musician) means being 
somehow less Jewish. The question, therefore, is not about whether or not 
one has an identity, but about what conditions bring one to act upon it and 
not some other identity or combination of identities. Rather than thinking 
about having an identity, it makes more sense to us to think about enacting 
multiple and intersectional identities, in different ways at different times 
(Brettschneider, 1996; Boyarin, 1997; Crenshaw, 1991; Glenn & Sokoloff, 
2010; Silberstein, 2000). This is not to argue that the Jewish community 
should avoid principled debates over the practices and commitments that 
it values. Instead, it is to caution against totalizing claims that people who 
identify as Jewish behave in ways that demonstrate their Jewishness either 
exclusive of other identities they may hold or in ways that supersede those 
identities. Consequently, as each of the following chapters examines, we 
reject the conclusion that identity is the proper or sole metric for assessing 
articulations of Jewishness. 
So the first general critique of the discourse of Jewish identity is that, once 
we pay close attention to it, it is inconsistent with our best understanding of 
how identity in general, and Jewish identity in particular, actually works. The 
chapters in this book develop this critique by drawing our attention to particular 
ways that the discourse of Jewish identity functions, and to the assumptions 
that it makes. The closer attention we pay, the more these inconsistencies stand 
out and the harder they are to ignore.


x
Jon A. Levisohn and Ari Y. Kelman
In addition, a second general critique focuses on the way that the 
discourse of Jewish identity has become inseparable from Jewish educational 
interventions. The assumption we seek to destabilize is causal in a simplistic 
sense: x experience leads to y outcome. That is, Jewish educational programs, 
of various kinds, lead to more (or stronger or deeper) Jewish identity. In one 
sense, of course, this assumption is demonstrably true. Every responsible study 
of the impact of Jewish education indicates that Jews who participate in Jewish 
educational projects and programs are affected on pretty much every relevant 
measure, in ways that suggest a greater commitment to things Jewish: broader 
institutional affiliation (e.g., membership in synagogues or JCCs), more ritual 
practice (e.g., lighting Shabbat candles or attending a Passover seder), more 
communal Jewish involvement (e.g., donating to Federation), stronger Jewish 
social networks (e.g., percentage of Jewish friends), etc. 
In fact, many of us involved in Jewish educational research find ourselves 
compelled to repeat these well-documented realities in the face of communal 
voices that worry that Jewish education is a failed enterprise. It is not. The 
simple truth, repeatedly corroborated, is that investments in Jewish education 
pay off in terms of Jewish involvements. Participants in Jewish educational 
programs emerge from those programs—almost all of them, with few 
exceptions—with more Jewish knowledge, broader Jewish connections, and 
deeper Jewish commitments (see, e.g., Cohen, 1974; Cohen, 1995; Cohen & 
Kotler-Berkowitz, 2004; Cohen, 2007). In general, if the question is whether 
Jewish education has an effect on participants, the answer is consistently 
positive. 
So if we can affirm that Jewish education works to increase or deepen 
various Jewish attitudes and behaviors, what’s the problem? The problem is 
that there is a world of difference between observing the effect of, say, Jewish 
camp on campers’ patterns of affiliation, on the one hand, and asserting that 
the goal of Jewish camp, or anything else, is to strengthen Jewish identity. 
Proposing that the desired outcome of any particular Jewish educational 
project or program is more or stronger “Jewish identity” has the effect of 
dumbing down larger educational goals to the most superficial and the least 
meaningful. It sets a low bar, and fails to capture anything aspirational. At the 
communal level, Jewish policy makers have long noticed that the the goal of 
“Jewish continuity” is unhelpful, affirming nothing other than a thin survivalism 
(see, e.g., Cohen & Fein, 1985). But “Jewish identity” is the corollary, on the 
individual level, of “continuity” on the communal level, and likewise demands 
critical re-examination. 


Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину