Between Religion and Reason
Покупка
Тематика:
Религиоведение
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Chamiel Ephraim
Год издания: 2020
Кол-во страниц: 233
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-073-4
Артикул: 872928.01.99
The present book is a sequel to Ephraim Chamiel’s two previous works The Middle Way and The Dual Truth — studies dedicated to the "middle” trend in modern Jewish thought, that is, those positions that sought to combine tradition and modernity, and offered a variety of approaches for contending with the tension between science and revelation and between reason and religion. The present book explores contemporary Jewish thinkers who have adopted one of these integrated approaches — namely the dialectical approach. Some of these thinkers maintain that the aforementioned tension—the rift within human consciousness between intellect and emotion, mind and heart — can be mended. Others, however, think that the dialectic between the two poles of this tension is inherently irresolvable, a view reminiscent of the medieval "dual truth” approach. Some thinkers are unclear on this point, and those who study them debate whether or not they successfully resolved the tension and offered a means of reconciliation. The author also offers his views on these debates. This book explores the dialectical approaches of Rav Kook, Rav Soloveitchik, Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, Samuel Hugo Bergman, Leo Strauss, Ernst Simon, Emil Fackenheim, Rabbi Mordechai Breuer, his uncle Isaac Breuer, Tamar Ross, Rabbi Shagar, Moshe Meir, Micah Goodman and Elchanan Shilo. It also discusses the interpretations of these thinkers offered by scholars such as Michael Rosenak, Avinoam Rosenak, Eliezer Schweid, Aviezer Ravitzky, Avi Sagi, Binyamin Ish-Shalom, Ehud Luz, Dov Schwartz, Rabbi Yuval Cherlow, Lawrence Kaplan, and Haim Rechnitzer. The author questions some of these approaches and offers ideas of his own. This study concludes that many scholars bore witness to the dialectical tension between reason and revelation; only some believed that a solution was possible. That being said, and despite the paradoxical nature of the dual truth approach (which maintains that two contradictory truths exist and we must live with both of them in this world until a utopian future or the advent of the Messiah), increasing numbers of thinkers today are accepting it. In doing so, they are eschewing delusional and apologetic views such as the identicality and compartmental approaches that maintain that tensions and contradictions are unacceptable.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
BETWEEN RELIGION AND REASON THE DIALECTICAL POSITION IN CONTEMPORARY JEWISH THOUGHT FROM RAV KOOK TO RAV SHAGAR P a r t I
Studies in Orthodox Judaism Series Editor Marc B. Shapiro (University of Scranton, Scranton, Pennsylvania) Editorial Board Alan Brill (Seton Hall University, South Orange, New Jersey) Benjamin Brown (Hebrew University, Jerusalem) David Ellenson (Hebrew Union College, New York) Adam S. Ferziger (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Miri Freud-Kandel (University of Oxford, Oxford) Jeffrey Gurock (Yeshiva University, New York) Shlomo Tikochinski (Jerusalem)
B O S T O N 2 0 2 0 BETWEEN RELIGION AND REASON THE DIALECTICAL POSITION IN CONTEMPORARY JEWISH THOUGHT FROM RAV KOOK TO RAV SHAGAR E P H R A I M C H A M I E L P a r t I
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Chamiel, Ephraim, author. | Kallenbach, Avi, translator. Title: Between religion and reason / by Ephraim Chamiel ; translated by Avi Kallenbach. Other titles: Ben dat le-daʻat English. Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2020. | Series: Studies in Orthodox Judaism | Includes bibliographical references. Identifiers: LCCN 2020001998 (print) | LCCN 2020001999 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644690727 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644690734 (adobe pdf) Subjects: LCSH: Jewish philosophy--20th century. | Jewish philosophy--21st century. | Dialectical theology. | Jewish philosophers. Classification: LCC B5800 .C37713 2020 (print) | LCC B5800 (ebook) | DDC 296.3/75--dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020001998 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020001999 © Academic Studies Press, 2020 ISBN 9781644690727 (hardback) ISBN 9781644690734 (Adobe PDF) ISBN 9781644693827 (ePub) On the cover: David Breuer-Weil, "Lifetime." Oil on canvas, 196x384 cm. Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon St. Brookline, MA 02446 press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Table of Contents Translator’s Note vii Introduction viii Chapter One: Historical Background 1 Chapter Two: Dialectical Approaches in the Background: Rav Kook as Interpreted by Avinoam Rosenak 7 Chapter Three: Rabbi Joseph Ber Soloveitchik: His Writings and the Interpretations of His Thought 16 Chapter Four: Professor Samuel Hugo Bergman 56 Chapter Five: Rabbi Professor Abraham Joshua Heschel 68 Chapter Six: Professor Leo Strauss and his Commentator Haim Rechnitzer 79 Chapter Seven: Professor Akiva Ernst Simon 98 Chapter Eight: Rabbi Professor Emil Fackenheim 108 Chapter Nine: Rabbi Mordechai Breuer and his Uncle Rabbi Dr. Isaac Breuer 119 Chapter Ten: Professor Tamar Ross 159 Chapter Eleven: Rabbi Shimon Gershon Rosenberg (Shagar) 168
vi Table of Contents Chapter Twelve: Dr. Moshe Meir 177 Chapter Thirteen: Dr. Micah Goodman 185 Chapter Fourteen: Dr. Elhanan Shilo 192 Chapter Fifteen: Summary and Conclusions 200 Afterword 204 Bibliography 206 Index of Subjects 212 Index of Names 218
Translator’s Note I n his third book, Dr. Chamiel takes a thematic approach, drawing attention to those Jewish philosophers and theologians in the twentieth and twenty first century who believed that religion and reason, while both true, often contradict each other. This book discusses a wide range of responses to this dilemma: harmonization or dialectical synthesis, unsuccessful struggles to attain such a resolution, and acceptance of an imperfect world in which the tension is irresolvable and two contradictory truths prevail. As with any translation certain challenges presented themselves as I progressed; I would like to draw attention to one. While many of the thinkers discussed by Dr. Chamiel express their philosophical musings in English, others formulated their ideas in Hebrew. It is certainly possible to express abstract, philosophical ideas in a very “modernized” Hebrew, replete with foreign terminology and vocabulary. Such language lends itself relatively easily to English translation. However, the very nature of the dilemma explored in Dr. Chamiel’s book – the interplay and relationship between religion and reason – meant that many of the thinkers discussed chose to formulate not only their thoughts – but also their language – in close dialogue with the traditions of the Bible, Talmud, and rabbinic literature. While I could rely on previous translations when they existed (as I have documented in the footnotes), I was often required to provide translations of my own. Needless to say, it was no small task and I can only hope my translation does justice to the works of these writers, as well as to Dr. Chamiel’s insightful analysis of their various approaches. My gratitude to Avi Staiman, CEO of Academic Language Experts, and Professor Marc Shapiro who reviewed and corrected the translation as I proceeded. And of course, my many thanks to Dr. Chamiel who took an active part in the translation process offering insightful comments throughout. Avi Kallenbach
Introduction The duality in the attitudes of the cognitive man and the homo religiosus is rooted in existence itself. (Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik, Halakhic Man, trans. Lawrence Kaplan, Philadelphia 1983, 9). The distinction between religion [ ]דתand reason [ ]דעתis in the eye [ ]עיןof the beholder. (E.C.) T his book is the first volume of the third installment of a trilogy, a series on modern, religious Jewish thought from the beginning of the nineteenth century to present today. My first study focused on the historical and ideological background behind the rise of modern forms of religiosity among European Jewry. My goal was to identify the first religious thinkers in the modern period who, instead of rejecting the phenomena of modernity, sought to incorporate them into a framework of traditional Jewish observance. I encountered Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch (1808–1888) from Frankfurt, Germany; Samuel David Luzzatto (1800–1865) from Padua, Italy; and Rabbi Tsvi Hirsch Chajes (1805– 1855) from Żółkiew (Zhovkva), Galicia. Wishing to contend with the challenges modernity posed to believers in divine revelation, these three nineteenth centuries figures formulated elaborate philosophies. After conducting a comprehensive and in-depth analysis of their philosophies, I began to understand how they sought to combine religion with human knowledge, tradition with modernity, and the dictates of reason, attained from philosophy and the sciences with the dictates of revelation encapsulated in the Written and Oral Torah. I submitted my findings to the doctoral senate of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. An adaptation of my doctorate was later published as a book: The Middle Way.1 1 Ephraim Chamiel, The Middle Way: The Emergence of Modern Religious Trends in NineteenthCentury Judaism, Responses to Modernity in the Philosophy of Z.H. Chajes, S.R. Hirsch, and S.D. Luzzatto, trans. Jeffrey Green, 2 vols. (Brighton, MA, 2014).
ix Introduction In order to analyze these different approaches, I adopted the model advanced by Shalom Rosenberg for the study of Jewish philosophy, adjusting and expanding it as needed.2 Using this model, I demonstrated that Chajes advocated a restrictive identicality approach, the approach espoused by Judah Halevi based on the teachings of the Mu’tazila students of Al-Ghazali. According to this approach, the dictates of religion and philosophy are, in principle, identical—meaning, any contradiction between them is impossible. However, in cases of putative contradictions or difficulties, it is the revelation of Scripture which must make the final determination. This is the approach of classic fundamentalism. Hirsch’s approach was similar. However, unlike Chajes, he was forced to admit that, in certain instances, scientific facts have been proven beyond a doubt yet persist in contradicting tradition. In such cases (and only in such cases), he shifted to the interpretative identicality approach advocated by Maimonides, who was, in turn, influenced by the Aristotelian rationalists, Al-Farabi and Ibn Sina. According to this stance, while both religion and science are in principle identical (and thus cannot contradict each other), in cases of difficulty or contradiction, it is reason which must make the final determination. In such cases, Scripture is to be reinterpreted allegorically. Based on the definition of James Barr, I have characterized Hirsch’s inconsistent approach as Neo-Fundamentalism.3 My contribution to the field was my explanation of Samuel David Luzzatto’s approach. Luzzatto’s statements on the subject are prima facie, incoherent and contradictory. This was at least, how my scholarly predecessors characterized his philosophy. I believe, however, that I have successfully demonstrated – based on a study of the majority of his writings and a review of their chronology – that Luzzatto’s approach shifted and evolved over the course of his life. His final approach can be characterized as akin to the “dual truth” stance. Historically, this was a very rare approach circulating in certain scholastic medieval circles. It was advocated by R. Isaac Albalag (the late thirteenth century)4 and Elijah Delmedigo (1460–1497)5 who followed the lead of Christian Averroists, followers 2 See Shalom Rosenberg, Torah Umada’ Bahagut Hayehudit Hahadasha (Jerusalem, 1988), 23–45. Chamiel, The Middle Way, 351–357. An overview of the model is offered below in chapter one, under the heading: “Between Revelation and Reason – The Spectrum of Approaches.” 3 See James Barr, Fundamentalism (Philadelphia, 1978); Chamiel, op. cit., 112–13, 289, 349. 4 Y. Gutmann, Hafilosofia Shel Hayahadut (Jerusalem, 1989), 184–187.
x and interpreters of Muslim philosopher Ibn Rushd (Averroes). Some modern Straussian interpreters of Maimonides, believe that Maimonides also maintained such a position, as I will explain below in a chapter on Leo Strauss. According to the “dual truth” stance, one cannot escape contradictions and challenges by crafting an illusory harmony between the conclusions of reason and those of revelation. These two fields constitute two full, and often antagonistic, truths. Humans cannot in this world and with their reason reconcile them. I labeled this the “irresolvable dialectic approach” in order to denote something less scholastic and more existential; according to this approach, one should not celebrate both truths but rather ponder the tension between them. In truth, however, no real escape is possible until the final redemption. According to the “resolvable dialectical approach” advanced by German philosophers Johannes Gottlieb Fichte (1762–1814) and Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770–1831), each stage in the history of the human spirit and religious belief consists of a thesis and an antithesis. These opposites can be fused into a synthesis – which may be either ephemeral or long-lasting. At this stage, the contradiction is resolved, and the process recurs until a new contradiction arises. By contrast, the irresolvable dialectic approach, based on the philosophy of Friedrich Wilhelm Schelling (1775–1854) maintains that a permanent or enduring synthesis is, at least in this world, nothing but an illusion. One should not seek to resolve opposites, but rather willingly resign oneself to acceptance of the two contradictory truths.6 This approach in which historical development progresses towards a redemption—as described by Fichte, Schelling and Hegel—was taken up by Jewish thinkers seeking to resolve contradictions between Jewish revelation and reason. It is important to note that the dual truth approach not only stands in opposition to the resolvable dialectical approach maintained by Nahman Krochmal (1785–1840)—in terms of the historical process and the difficulties prevailing between religion and reason according to Fichte and Hegel7—but also to the compartmental approach adopted by Isaiah Leibowitz based on the philosophy of the founder of the Haskalah movement Moses Mendelssohn (1729–1786). According to this approach, religion and reason are two parts of one great truth, each discipline pertaining to a separate area of inquiry, each one employing a different language and terminology. Consequently, any contradiction between them is impossible.8 6 See Chapter 2, below. 7 Chamiel, The Middle Way, vol. 1, 197–199; vol. 2, 331–337. 8 For a discussion of Rosenberg’s model, which I expanded and applied to the philosophies of Chajes, Hirsch, and Luzzatto. See Chamiel, The Middle Way, vol. 1, 351–357, 366–370, 402–447, 447–492.