Setting the Table. An Introduction to the Jurisprudence of Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein’s Arukh HaShulhan
Покупка
Тематика:
Право зарубежных стран
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Год издания: 2020
Кол-во страниц: 429
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-071-0
Артикул: 872927.01.99
One of the most basic questions for any legal system is that of methodology: how one interprets, analyzes, weighs, and applies a mass of often competing legal rules, precedents, practices, customs, and traditions to reach final determinations and practical guidance about the correct legal-prescribed course of action in any given situation. Questions of legal methodology raise not only practical concerns, but theoretical and philosophical ones as well. We expect law to be more than the arbitrary result of a given decision maker’s personal preferences, and so we demand that legal methodologies be principled as well as practical. These issues are especially acute in religious legal systems, where the stakes are raised by concerns for respecting not just human, but divine law. Despite this, the major scholars and codifiers of halakhah, or Jewish law, have only rarely explicated their own methods for reaching principled legal decisions. This book explains the major jurisprudential factors driving the halakhic jurisprudence of Rabbi Yehiel Mikhel Epstein, twentieth-century author of the Arukh Hashulchan — the most comprehensive, seminal, and original modern restatement of Jewish law since Maimonides. Reasoning inductively from a broad review of hundreds of rulings from the Orach Chaim section of the Arukh Hashulchan, the book teases out and explicates ten core halakhic principles that animate Rabbi Epstein’s halakhic decision-making. Along the way, it compares the Arukh Hashulchan methodology to that of the Mishna Berura. This book will help any reader understand important methodological issues in both Jewish and general jurisprudence.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Setting the Table An Introduction to the Jurisprudence of Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein’s Arukh HaShulhan
Boston Setting the Table An Introduction to the Jurisprudence of Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein’s Arukh HaShulhan Michael J. Broyde and Shlomo C. Pill
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Broyde, Michael J., author. | Pill, Shlomo C., author. Title: Setting the table : an introduction to the jurisprudence Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein's Arukh HaShulhan / Michael J. Broyde, Shlomo C. Pill. Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2020. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2019050093 (print) | LCCN 2019050094 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644690703 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644690710 (adobe pdf) Subjects: LCSH: Epstein, Jehiel Michael ben Aaron Isaac, Halevi, approximately 1829-approximately 1908. ʻArukh ha-shulḥan. | Israel Meir, ha-Kohen, 1838-1933. Mishnah berurah. | Jewish law--Codification. | Jewish law--Interpretation and construction. Classification: LCC BM521 .B767 2020 (print) | LCC BM521 (ebook) | DDC 296.1/8--dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019050093 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019050094 Copyright © Academic Studies Press, 2020 ISBN 9781644690703 (hardback) ISBN 9781644690710 (adobe pdf) ISBN 9781644693810 (ePub) Book design by Kryon Publishing Services, Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Cover design by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
In memory of: הרב חיים דוב בן משה אהרן ודבורה בראיודע Dr. Barret (Barry) Broyde Who returned his soul to his Maker on September 30, 2018 יצא נשמתו בהושענא רבא תשע"ט Most beloved and loving father, husband, grandfather, and great-grandfather, a kind heart, a sweeping intellect, a broad and deep Torah scholar, an astonishing memory, truly a role model for his family and all who knew him. His loss will be felt by his family for decades to come.
In memory of: ר׳ צבי בן שמואל יהודה Hersh “Heshy” Aron Who returned his soul to his Maker on September 29, 2018 יצא נשמתו בשבת חול המועד סוכות תשע״ט A Holocaust survivor who remained deeply committed to the faith and traditions of his ancestors after experiencing incredible loss, and together with his wife, Ella, built a family of children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren committed to continuing that legacy. In life, Hersh Aron exemplified a simple, deep dedication to Torah and halakhah of a kind that recalls a Jewish past now lost. May his memory be a blessing.
Contents Acknowledgments viii x Part I—Setting the Table: The Codification of Jewish Law 1 Chapter One: Codifying Jewish Law 2 Chapter Two: Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein’s Arukh HaShulchan 33 Chapter Three Competing Models: The Arukh HaShulchan and Mishnah Berurah 45 Part II—The Methodological Principles of the Arukh HaShulchan 69 Introduction 70 Chapter Four: The Rule of the Talmud 83 Chapter Five Rabbinic Consensus 98 Chapter Six Resolving Doubtful Cases 110 Chapter Seven Non-Normative Opinions 135 Chapter Eight Supererogatory Religious Conduct 157 Chapter Nine Law and Mysticism 172 Chapter Ten Law and Custom 185 Chapter Eleven Temporal Rationalization of Halakhic Rules 208 Chapter Twelve Law and Pragmatism 223 Part III—Illustrative Examples from the Arukh HaShulchan 249 The Arukh HaShulchan’s Methodological Principles for Reaching Halakhic Conclusions 250 The Ten Methodological Principles of the Arukh HaShulchan 252 Bibliography 395 Index of Biblical and Rabbinic Works Cited 405 Index of Names and Subjects 409 Index of Examples by Methodological Principle 413
Acknowledgments M any people have contributed in different ways to the writing of this book, and we would like to thank them: Thank you to the Emory University Center for the Study of Law and Religion, the Emory University Law School, Emory University Candler School of Theology, and the Judish London Evans Directors Fund at the Tam Institute of Jewish Studies, which all supported us in writing this work. In particular, we would like to thank Professor John Witte Jr. and Professor David R. Blumenthal, whose vision and hard work created the Center and the Institute, which continue to support excellent research, teaching, and publishing in Jewish law. We would like to thank the editors at Dinei Israel, who published portions of this work as an article in volume 33 of the journal. Portions of this book were also presented at the Jewish Law Annual Moscow Conference in 2018 and various other academic and popular lecture forums. We thank participants in those conversations, whose attendance, questions, and insights have enhanced this work. We also note that this work owes an intellectual debt to a prior work that one of us co-authored; some small portions of this work derive from Michael J. Broyde & Ira Bedzow, The Codification of Jewish Law and an Introduction to the Jurisprudence of the Mishna Berura (2014). We particularly also want to thank Jerry and Chaya Weinberger, who supported our work in dedication to their lovely children, Goldi and Mordechai Reisman, Shmuel, Bailey, and Shevi. The Weinberger family’s support is a demonstration of the ideal that parents wish for their children to continue to grow and study works of Torah and halakhah and also that their learning enhances their practice and observance. We would like to thank the many different people who helped with production of the manuscript. In particular, the very capable editorial team at Academic Studies Press helped us in many different ways. Thank you as well to the many fine research assistants who helped edit the collection of examples, including Tzipporah Machlah Klapper, Carl Johnson, Noah Notis, Ben Notis,
ix Acknowledgments Jacob Pesachov, Vera Wexler, Rami Schwartz, Ashley Stern-Mintz, and Moshe Unger, and to Yael Klausner, who provided valuable editorial and research assistance. Many people—too many to name and thank individually—read different portions of this work; their comments and criticisms have helped clarify and sharpen many of our arguments, and we are grateful to each of them. All errors are, of course, our own. We also thank our wives, Channah Broyde and Tzivie Pill—without whose support and advice this project could not have been completed—and our children Joshua, Aaron, Rachel Irene, and Deborah Malka Broyde, and Arial, Minnie, and Delphine Pill, who make it all worthwhile. This book is dedicated in memory of Rabbi Eitam Henkin, who was murdered before completing his work on the biography of Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein, the author of the Arukh HaShulchan. This work has recently appeared under the title Ta’arokh Lefanai Shulchan (Set a Table Before Me: The Life, Times, and Works of Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein, Author of the Arukh HaShulchan, Maggid Press, 2019). We—along with the whole community— deeply mourn his murder and the murder of his wife Na’ama on October 1, 2015. We thank the extended Henkin family, and particularly Rabbi Yehuda Herzl and Rabbanit Chana Henkin, for sharing the above manuscript with us, and we cite it extensively in the biographical sections of this work. Rabbi Eitam Henkin indicated in this above manuscript an intent to address the many topics we discuss in this work,1 but he sadly did not live to write those sections. We are certain he would have done a better job at this book than we have done, and it is only with tears in our eyes that we attempt to undertake this task. We relied heavily on Rabbi Henkin’s research and used material from his biography in chapter two of this book. His work was groundbreaking, pathbreaking in its insights, and astonishing for one so young. If we have accomplished anything novel in this work, it is because we are midgets on the shoulders of a young giant taken from our community before he could grow to his full height. Each of us suffered losses in our family while writing this book, and we note with sadness the passing of Rabbi Dr. Barret Broyde, father of one of us, and Hersh Aron, grandfather-in-law of one of us. They both returned their souls to their Maker on Chol HaMoed Sukkot 5779, one on Hoshana Rabbah and the other on Shabbat Chol HaMoed. Their losses are deeply felt, and we dedicate this volume to their memories. 1 See Eitam Henkin, Ta’arokh Lefanai Shulchan: Chayo Zemano U’Mepaalo Shel HaRav Yechiel Mikhel Epstein Baal Arukh HaShulchan 309 (2019).
T his book is about the magnum opus of Rabbi Yechiel Mikhel Epstein, the Arukh HaShulchan, focusing particularly on Orach Chaim, the section of his work that is most extensive and complete, and which addresses matters of normative daily Jewish law, such as prayers, Sabbath observance, and festival celebrations. In this work, we do not focus on specific rulings or on Rabbi Epstein’s social or linguistic presentations. Rather, we are interested in understanding how the work functions as a law book—the jurisprudence of the work and the way it reaches its halakhic (Jewish law) conclusions. How does the Arukh HaShulchan decide matters of Jewish law in light of the panoply of rabbinic sources, such as Talmudic texts, Maimonides’s code, the Shulchan Arukh, the glosses of the Rema, and the many other great authorities who came before the Arukh HaShulchan? How does this seminal restatement of halakhah navigate and resolve tensions between text, interpretation, precedent, tradition, custom, spirituality, and pragmatism? By the time Rabbi Epstein first raised his pen to write about 150 years ago, Jewish law was far from a tabula rasa. Indeed, by the mid-1800s, the classical code of Jewish law, the Shulchan Arukh, had spawned dozens of commentaries and related works, many of which had become deeply integrated into the ways that rabbinic scholars approached Jewish law such that the Shulchan Arukh could not be approached without also engaging a multivocal chaos of commentary and legal disagreement. Yet the Arukh HaShulchan undertook to write a new and completely different restatement of Jewish law, not a commentary, nor a set of responsa proposing new answers to a few very specific questions. Instead, he wrote whole new code because he had a deeply important methodological contributions to make to how Jewish law is determined. This halakhic methodology—like that of so many major figures in the annals of rabbinic law—is never explicitly or fully explained by Rabbi Epstein, but it becomes clear upon a close examination of the Arukh HaShulchan. In