Rabbi Joseph Dov Soloveitchik on the Experience of Prayer
Покупка
Тематика:
Религии Древнего мира. История религий.
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Schwartz Dov
Год издания: 2019
Кол-во страниц: 497
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-972-8
Артикул: 872924.01.99
This book is devoted to Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik’s discussions on the practice of prayer. Prayer is analyzed across a broad and complex spectrum in Soloveitchik’s work, and his writings describing and analyzing the experience of prayer afford a profound insight into its diversity, ranging from existential crisis to communion with God. Through a careful reading of R. Soloveitchik’s texts dealing with this topic, the book follows the consciousness of prayer across its various stages until maturity, starting with an analysis of Worship of the Heart, through to Reflections on the Amidah and other writings.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Rabbi Joseph Dov Soloveitchik on the Experience of Prayer
Emunot: Jewish Philosophy and Kabbalah Series Editor DOV SCHWARTZ (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Editorial board ADA RAPOPORT ALBERT (University College, London) GAD FREUDENTHAL (CNRS, Paris) GIDEON FREUDENTHAL (Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv) MOSHE IDEL (Hebrew University, Jerusalem) RAPHAEL JOSPE (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) EPHRAIM KANARFOGEL (Yeshiva University, New York) MENACHEM KELLNER (Haifa University, Haifa) DANIEL LASKER (Ben-Gurion University, Beer Sheva)
Rabbi Joseph Dov Soloveitchik on the Experience of Prayer Dov Schwartz Translated by Edward Levin BOSTON 2019
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The bibliographic data for this title is available from the Library of Congress. © 2019 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN 978-1-61811-718-2 (hardcover) ISBN 978-1-61811-719-9 (paper) ISBN 978-1-61811-972-8 (electronic) Cover design by Ivan Grave. Book design by Kryon Publishing Services Pvt. Ltd. http://www.kryonpublishing.com Published by Academic Studies Press in 2019 1577 Beacon St. Brookline, MA 02446 press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Table of Contents Introduction vi Part I. Worship of the Heart: The Consciousness of Prayer 1 Chapter 1: Nature and Purpose 3 Chapter 2: The Consciousness of Prayer: An Outline 29 Chapter 3: The Consciousness of Prayer: The Subjective and the Objective 59 Chapter 4: The Consciousness of Prayer: The Process of Consolidation 86 Chapter 5: The Path of the Consciousness of Prayer to Perfection 139 Chapter 6: The Dialectic of Consciousness: Between Reading Shema and Prayer 164 Chapter 7: The Interpretation of Reading Shema and Its Blessings: (1) Methodology and Sources 193 Chapter 8: The Interpretation of Reading Shema and Its Blessings: (2) Application 223 Part II. “Reflections on the Amidah” in Perspective 261 Chapter 9: Prayer and Redemption 263 Chapter 10: Covering the Profound: The Legal-Halakhic Dimension of the Amidah 305 Chapter 11: Interpretation of the Amidah Prayer 349 Part III. Community 397 Chapter 12: Synagogue and Community 399 Summary: The Consciousness of Prayer 439 Bibliography 451
A ny discussion of the relationship between prayer and philosophical, theological, and Kabbalistic thought must go beyond the philological, historical, and halakhic study of prayer. Prayer is an inherent component of the world of the religious individual, and in consequence has always occupied center stage in the intensive research of the history of religions and comparative religion. Prayer is perceived as a defining experience in the relationship between man and the divine, and between man and himself. This experience places man and his initiatives at its center. Man praises, requests, and sings to his God. At times God is seen as a partner to the conversation, and at other times, as a passive listener. On occasion the prayer experience overwhelms the being of the worshiper to the extent that he has no need of any tangible response; it suffices for God to be aware of his prayer. There are times when the worshiper expects that prayer will cause God to actively intervene in his life. Sometimes prayer expresses man’s self, and makes him aware of his personality and the deep strata of his soul. The act of prayer and its formulation enable the worshiper to understand his authentic needs, and there are instances in which the worshiper gains insights into the divine by means of his addressing Him. In any event, prayer is humanly-initiated action. It expresses the wealth of a person’s expression, progressing from the word and the sound to language and dialogue. Formal dialogue is conducted between man and God, while accompanied by a dialogue between man and himself. The liturgical text became the basis of the experience, and as such, the prayer experience blazed a trail over the course of time to the very heart of religiosity. These features of the prayer experience are manifest in the Jewish world, as well.1 It is not surprising that prayer has captivated modern Jewish thought. It is perceived as a subjective act par excellence, which represents 1 A detailed list of studies on Jewish prayer was prepared by Joseph Tabory, the indefatigable bibliographer of prayer. See Joseph Tabory, Jewish Prayer and the Yearly Cycle: A List of Articles, supplement to Kiryat Sefer 64 [Hebrew] (Jerusalem, 1992-1993).
vii the religious experience of the worshiper. On a parallel track, philosophers such as Hermann Cohen and Franz Rosenzweig highlighted prayer as an expression of the individual, and probed the meaning of the movement from personal to communal, public prayer. Of especial scholarly interest is prayer’s median position: on the one hand, it is a product of intimate mental processes, while on the other, it embodies the imperative. Prayer oscillates between the autonomous and the authoritative. The current book analyzes R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik’s writings on prayer. R. Soloveitchik created extensive discussions to this topic, which occupies a prominent place in his legacy. In the current book I will analyze the place of prayer in his writings and the insights regarding prayer that emerge from his writings and thought. The Study of the Religious Consciousness R. Soloveitchik did not act in a vacuum. Prayer is an important component of Jewish religiosity in the United States, where R. Soloveitchik was active (as it is in other Diaspora communities), from both the existential-experiential viewpoint and the communal perspective, and its significance will be discussed in the chapters of this book.2 The centrality of prayer for American Jewry also finds philosophical expression.3 The philosophical and theological orientation concerned with the phenomenology of religion occupies an important place in terms of the sources and scholarly methodologies of R. Soloveitchik’s thought, as we shall see below. Both the context of the discussion of prayer in R. Soloveitchik’s writings and the terminology of this discussion are based on the literature of the phenomenology of religion. I intend to argue that the main goal of R. Soloveitchik’s thought on prayer is to offer a phenomenological description of the consciousness of prayer. To this end, we should more sharply define the boundaries of this consciousness. Phenomenologists of religion generally accepted the principles formulated by Edmund Husserl (1859-1938), viewing religion as a given. Rather than judging the religious phenomenon, the phenomenologist of religion seeks to decipher it and understand its nature. The phenomenologist is occupied with description, and therefore examines the structure of the consciousness, that is, the manner in which objects are perceived by the 2 See below, Chapter Twelve. 3 See, for example, Shalom Ratshabi, Between Destiny and Faith: The Jewish Theological Discourse in the United States [Hebrew] (Tel Aviv: Am Oved, 2003), 241-242.
viii consciousness. According to Husserl, consciousness is intentional and relates to objects. For the phenomenologists of religion, the religious individual possesses a distinct consciousness that includes a series of epistemological acts that relate to objects such as God. These phenomenologists examine the various—at times contradictory—appearances of religion in order to isolate the essential elements of the religious consciousness: in this case, the consciousness of prayer. Philosophers and scholars have discussed the nature and definitions of the phenomenology of religion. Eric Sharpe formulated the task of the phenomenology of religion in five stages: (1) to assign names to groups of phenomena—such as sacrifice, prayer, saviour, myth, etc.; (2) to interpolate the experiences within one’s own life and experience them systematically—a point which seems at the first sight hard to reconcile with the claim that the aim of phenomenology is “pure objectivity”; (3) to exercise epoche, that is, to withdraw to one side and observe; (4) to clarify and comprehend. (5) to confront chaotic reality and testify to what has been understood.4 Sharpe based the work of the phenomenologist on the writings of Gerardus van der Leeuw (1890-1950), Jan Hermelink (1924-1961), and others. Joseph D. Bettis noted that the phenomenology of religion differs from the philosophy of religion in that, inter alia, it is not concerned solely with ideas and doctrines but also studies the diverse forms of religious expression, such as ritual, symbolism, and the like.5 In other words, phenomenology is also concerned with the epistemological meaning of “objective” acts, and not only with the subjective experience. This distinction is a formative element in the thought of R. Soloveitchik. This forms the background for the phenomenological inquiry into prayer. The Consciousness of Prayer The phenomenological discussion of prayer in the scholarly literature of the history of religion in general, and particularly that of the Jewish world, was conducted in at least two planes. 4 Eric Sharpe, Comparative Religion (London: Duckworth, 1975), 234. 5 Joseph D. Bettis (ed.), Phenomenology of Religion: Eight Modern Descriptions of the Essence of Religion (New York: Harper & Row, 1969), 3. See Sharpe, Comparative Religion, 248-249.
ix (1) Prayer by itself. The discussion encompassed various aspects of the virtues, properties, and consequences of prayer. In many instances, the nature of prayer was determined in accordance with its effect and purpose. The aims of prayer are defined as follows: (a) influence on divine and cosmic providence; (b) influence on the worshiper’s moral and religious degree (= education); (c) influence on the social fabric (community, public prayer). (2) Prayer in the context of the worshiper. Prayer is not perceived as an autonomous religious act. Rather, it reflects the worshiper’s consciousness and his general relationship to God and the world. In this plane, prayer is not weighed in accordance with its purpose, but by the contribution it makes in the fashioning of the worshiper’s religious state and the expressions of this situation. This approach was expressed in three perceptions of prayer: (a) as a mirror and symptom of the worshiper’s way of life and religious consciousness;6 (b) as standing before God,7 and as an expression of the relationship with the transcendental dimension of life; (c) as an expression of community (public prayer).8 The first plane, that of prayer by itself, corresponds to the perception of prayer as an expression of “sacred words,” in the terminology of the phenomenologist of religion Edvard Lehmann (1862-1930). According to Lehmann, prayers play a central role in the second of religion’s three components (“sacred actions,” such as ritual and magic; “sacred words,” such as sacred music and ceremonies; and “sacred places,” in the sense of 6 Maharal (R. Judah Loew ben Bezalel) argued that prayer is a component in the definition of the perfect man. According to him, man was created deficient, and he completes himself by means of prayer. Maharal used the Aristotelian terminology that refers to man as medabber (“rational one”; literally, “the one who speaks”), but while Aristotle referred to inner speech, that is, verbal thought, Maharal meant audible speech. Prayer completes speech, and man is a whole “speaking entity” (Judah Loew ben Bezalel, Netivot Olam, Netiv ha-Avodah 2 [Jerusalem, 1972], 81a). On speech, see also Karl Erich Grözinger, “Sprache und Identität—Das Hebräische und die Juden,” in Sprache und Identität im Judentum, ed. K. E. Grözinger (Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz Verlag, 1998), 75-90. 7 Schechter stated that prayer attests to affinity between man and his God. He sharply opposed the view that ascribes a transcendentalist position to the rabbinic literature. See Solomon Schechter, Aspects of Rabbinic Theology (New York: Schocken, 1961 [1901]), 22-23. 8 See, for example, Perry D. LeFevre, Understandings of Prayer (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1981).
x expanse and place in the expanse).9 Alston listed prayer and “other forms of communication with gods” as one of the “religion-making characteristics.”10 The second plane, that of prayer as a dynamic reflection of the life of the worshiper, is suitable for the discussion of prayer in the mystic and the phenomenological literatures. Christian spirituality is based in part on the book of Psalms and on the prayers constructed from it. The monastic agenda relies on such prayers as is reflected, for instance, in the writings of Augustine. In the mystical literature, prayer is at times an expression of the aspiration for communion and union with God. For example, Teresa of Avila (1515-1582) called the first stage of such union the “prayer of quiet.” Unlike verbal prayer, this is the meditative stage of a sacred ceremony or event from the life of the saints. This results in an experience of proximity to God. She termed the second stage the “prayer of full union,” which is marked by the manifestation of the divine presence within the soul. This results in the union of God and the soul in a mutual embrace. The third stage is the ecstatic.11 According to this depiction, prayer is merely a reflection of the different levels of the mystical experience. An expansive approach of the epistemology of prayer is also to be found among thinkers who are not identified as mystics. For example, Emil Brunner (1889-1966) writes that prayer is a mirror of the worshiper’s soul and his relationship to the divine. He argues that prayer proceeds from “profound reflection upon our own lives, as well as from the study of God’s Word.”12 R. Judah Halevi’s thought, for example, is not mystical—but, nevertheless, views prayer as an expression of the flow of religious life in its entirety.13 The Phenomenological Study of Prayer The academic interest in prayer first arose at the end of the nineteenth century. Scholars who viewed prayer as a central expression of religion 9 See Sharpe, Comparative Religion, 227. 10 William P. Alston, “Religion,” in The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Paul Edwards (New York: Macmillan, 1967), vols. 7-8, 141-142. 11 See Nelson Pike, Mystic Union: An Essay in the Phenomenology of Mysticism (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1992), 1-11. 12 Emil Brunner, The Divine Imperative: A Study in Christian Ethics, trans. Olive Wyon (Cambridge: Lutterworth, 2002]), 314. R. Soloveitchik cited Brunner in Out of the Whirlwind: Essays on Mourning, Suffering and the Human Condition, ed. David Schatz, Joel B. Wolowelsky, and Reuven Ziegler (Hoboken, NJ: Toras HoRav Foundation, 2003), 151, 154-155. 13 See below, Chapter Eleven.