The Many Faces of Maimonides
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Schwartz Dov
Год издания: 2018
Кол-во страниц: 199
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-781-6
Артикул: 872816.01.99
This volume offers a new reading of Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed. In particular, it explores how Maimonides’ commitment to integrity led him to a critique of the Kalām, to a complex concept of immortality, and to insight into the human yearning for metaphysical knowledge. Maimonides’ search for objective truth is also analyzed in its connection with the scientific writings of his time, which neither the Kalām nor the Jewish philosophical tradition that preceded him had endorsed.
Through a careful analysis of these issues, this book seeks to contribute to the understanding of the modes of thought adopted in The Guide of the Perplexed, including the "philosophical theologian” model of Maimonides’ own design, and to the knowledge of its sources.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
The Many Faces of Maimonides
Emunot: Jewish Philosophy and Kabbalah Series Editor DOV SCHWARTZ (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Editorial board ADA RAPOPORT ALBERT (University College, London) GAD FREUDENTHAL (CNRS, Paris) GIDEON FREUDENTHAL (Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv) MOSHE IDEL (Hebrew University, Jerusalem) RAPHAEL JOSPE (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) EPHRAIM KANARFOGEL (Yeshiva University, New York) MENACHEM KELLNER (Haifa University, Haifa) DANIEL LASKER (Ben-Gurion University, Beer Sheva)
Boston The Many Faces of Maimonides DOV SCHWARTZ Translated by Batya Stein
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Schwartz, Dov, author. | Stein, Batya, translator. Title: The many faces of Maimonides / Dov Schwartz ; translated by Batya Stein. Description: Brighton, MA: Academic Studies Press, 2018. Series: Emunot, Jewish philosophy and kabbalah | Collection of essays (some originally published in Hebrew). | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2018006997 | ISBN 9781618117809 (hardcover) Subjects: LCSH: Maimonides, Moses, 1135-1204. Dalåalat al-òhåa®iråin. | Judaism. | Jewish philosophy. | Philosophy, Medieval. Classification: LCC B759.M34 S34 2018 | DDC 296.1/81—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018006997 © 2018 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN 978-1-61811-780-9 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-61811-781-6 (electronic) Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Cover design by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press in 2018 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Table of Contents Introduction vi 1. The Passion for Metaphysics 1 2. The Separate Intellects 61 3. Astral Magic and the Law 90 4. Idolatry as Mediation 104 5. Immortality and Imagination 118 6. Maimonides: A Philosophical Theologian 134 Epilogue 165 Bibliography 167 Index 182
Introduction The present book will address mainly philosophical dimensions in Maimonides’ thought, focusing on a new reading of several issues in The Guide of the Perplexed. A figure like Maimonides would obviously have a variety of interests and goals and his writing will certainly be diverse and multifaceted. Even an esoteric interest or political and religious goals and motives do not exhaust the pursuits of Maimonides, who both transcended and included all of these. I do not accept mystic explanations of his endeavor, and can only study his genius. Medieval Jewish thought can be clearly split into two eras—before and after the appearance of The Guide of the Perplexed. No other philosophical treatise has ever evoked so many discussions, neither in the rabbinic nor in the scholarly literature, and no other work of Jewish philosophy has ever given rise to such polarized interpretations. The Guide of the Perplexed also had an essential influence on medieval (Christian) scholastic thought and, through it, on Western culture in general. My attempt in this introduction is to offer a brief outline of various reasons for this phenomenon. The Guide of the Perplexed, which was completed in 1191, turned into a popular volume that, over centuries, gained acceptance not only among thinkers and scholars but also among the general public. This book’s popularity is an impressive and paradoxical event, given that it absolutely contradicts its writer’s original intention. At the end of his Introduction, Maimonides set a criterion—his book would please one in ten thousand readers: To sum up: I am the man who when the concern pressed him and his way was straitened and he could find no other device by which to teach a demonstrated truth other than by giving satisfaction to a single virtuous man while
vii Introduction displeasing ten thousand ignoramuses—I am he who prefers to address that single man by himself, and I do not heed the blame of those many creatures.1 Maimonides knew that most people in the Jewish community would not understand the claims of the Guide, and wrote the book with this purpose in mind. Indeed, he actively tried to distance ordinary readers from his book and therefore wrote it using deliberate contradictions, as he admitted in the introduction. Maimonides thus adopted all possible means to ensure the book would not be popular but to no avail. The paradox of the book’s acceptance is evident in the fact that it was written for a specific student, R. Joseph b. Judah. Contrary to Maimonides’ previous large treatises, Commentary to the Mishnah and Mishneh Torah, which were written for the Jewish community in general, the Guide was tailored for Joseph: a scholar, interested in various scientific and philosophical fields, who had become perplexed. In the “Introduction to the First Part,” Maimonides clarified that the work had been designed for one who is knowledgeable in Torah as well as in the theoretical and philosophical2 sciences but has difficulty reconciling them. The rabbi’s personal guidance to his student thus opened up possibilities of deeper knowledge to many. In this book, I focus mainly on the Guide and only in Chapters Three and Five consider his other writings. Structure Before attempting to consider the general principles of the Guide, I will briefly present its structure and its main conceptual approaches in the table below: Part Chapters Content I 1-49 Negating corporeality: lexicographical discussions, focusing on the negation of corporeality. Almost every chapter interpretsbiblical attributes of God in non-corporeal terms. 50-70 Attributes: Denying any attributes to God, who is entirely indescribable.3 71-76 Dispute: Polemic with Muslim theologians. 1 Moses Maimonides, The Guide of the Perplexed, trans. Shlomo Pines (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963), 16. All further English citations of this work are from this translation (henceforth and throughout this book, Guide). 2 Today, the expertise of a “philosopher” is in a field entirely different from that of a “scientist,” who deals with order in the material world. In the Middle Ages, however, there was no significant distinction between a theoretical scientist and a philosopher. 3 Maimonidean scholarship has discussed the extent of Maimonides’ recourse to analogy in the description of God.
viii Introduction Part Chapters Content II 1 Demonstration: A series of proofs of God’s existence, unity, and non-corporeality. 2-12 The Spheres and the Angels (separate intellects): The notion of emanation, which clarifies how the heavenly elements and the angels came into being. 13-31 Creation: The impossibility of demonstrating scientifically either the creation or the eternity of the world. Reasons for preferring creation. 32-48 Prophecy: Divine revelation is natural and subject to a set order. Its functions are political III 1-7 The Account of the Chariot: A meteorological and physical interpretation of the biblical chapters on the chariot. 8-24 Providence and Knowledge: God’s providence protects only humans according to their level of knowledge. God knows the details from his knowledge of himself. 25-50 The Reasons for the Commandments: Rational arguments for all the commandments 51-54 Perfection: The ethos of worshipping the divine among those who attained perfection. This division is only one way of presenting the contents of the Guide, but immediately raises questions about its structure and order, which have proven extremely controversial. For example, the polemic with the Muslim theologians is closer in its character and contents to the issue of creation than to the issue of negative attributes, but Maimonides nevertheless set it in Part I. Not only are the contents of the Guide puzzling, but so are the structure and order of the discussions. In the first two chapters of this book, I consider the structure and the order of two sets of chapters in the Guide, drawing lessons from them about Maimonides’ philosophical writing in general. The Legitimation of Scientific Philosophical Pursuits A fundamental principle of the Maimonidean approach that appears already in the introductions to the Guide is the equation of macaseh bereshit [the Account of the Beginning] with physics, and of macaseh merkavah [the Account of the Chariot] with metaphysics. What is revolutionary in this equation? Macaseh bereshit and macaseh merkavah reflect the most esoteric concerns of tannaitic thought—the former referring to the secrets of creation, and the latter, based on the visions of Isaiah and Ezekiel, to the supreme
ix Introduction revelations of prophecy. Maimonides, then, at one stroke, interpreted these two terms according to the Aristotelian science that he had come to know through the Arabic translations of the Greek philosopher and through the writings of Muslim philosophers—Alfārābī, Avicenna, Ibn Bājjah, Ibn Țufaīl, and others.4 To Maimonides, macaseh bereshit conveys the physical order of the material world—the laws of motion, time, meteorology, and so forth—whereas macaseh merkavah conveys the order of the heavenly world—the movement of the spheres and their movers. In this daring interpretation, Maimonides pivoted the most secret traditions of the Oral Law on the scientific laws of his time. Furthermore, Maimonides adopted in the Guide (I:71) the approach that ancient Jews had displayed wondrous expertise and creativity in various sciences. When the Jewish people went into exile, Gentile nations learned these sciences from the Jews who, over the centuries, had forgotten them due to the hardships and persecutions afflicting them. With this explanation, Maimonides instantly legitimized the study of philosophy from the books of Muslim thinkers. The study of the great Muslim philosophers merely returns a lost item to its rightful owners. Maimonides tells the scholar, as it were, that learning about scientific problems from Arabic sources is, in fact, a return to the rabbis’ esoteric tradition. The acquisition of scientific knowledge as the supreme human purpose is an approach that Maimonides endorses in all his writings. This notion is already developed systematically in his Introduction to Commentary to the Mishnah and is the basis for the discussions in the Guide. Maimonides emphasized that the Torah and its commandments aim at “the welfare of the soul and the welfare of the body.”5 By “welfare of the body” he meant imparting normative and ethical foundations for the existence of the society, and by “welfare of the soul”—the acquisition of general and proper scientific knowledge. For Maimonides, then, philosophical and religious ideals coalesce. The Torah is unique because it directs us to acquire knowledge and scientific learning.6 Scientific knowledge, however, must be acquired from scientific sources, meaning Greek science through Muslim 4 Maimonides greatly respected Alfārābī, and L. V. Berman has even referred to Maimonides as Alfārābī’s “disciple.” Currently, several scholars have pointed to various thinkers and philosophical traditions that have contributed to the shaping of the views in the Guide. See, for example, chapter 5 below. 5 Guide, III:27, 510. 6 Several scholars hold that Maimonides was a skeptic and an agnostic and, therefore, preferred political pursuits to the acquisition of metaphysical knowledge, but this approach has proved controversial and is not the one accepted in Maimonidean scholarship.
x Introduction mediation, not from the Torah. In the following chapters, I consider the Muslim sources of the Guide and, specifically, the notion of idolatry as mediation that is manifest in Maimonides’ attitude to astral magic and in his conception on the immortality of the intellect. Maimonides was aware that many in the rabbinic world did not agree with the rationalist version he upheld. Indeed, toward the end of his life, a bitter polemic had already erupted regarding his thought, which would persist long after his death. Scientific Truth versus Religious Truth For Maimonides, as noted, the authoritative scientific sources were the writings of Muslim philosophers from Alfārābī onward. What about the two centuries of Jewish philosophizing that had preceded his birth? Systematic theological and philosophical treatises had been written before the appearance of the Guide—Saadia Gaon’s The Book of Beliefs and Opinions, Bahya ibn Paquda’s The Duties of the Heart, and Solomon Ibn Gabirol’s The Fountain of Life. Maimonides did not flinch from controversy with his predecessors, and this matter requires an understanding of his view on the contrast between scientific and religious truth. Maimonides sharply distinguished theologians, who focus on proving religious truths at any price, from philosophers, who seek scientific objective truth. Specifically, Maimonides addressed a phenomenon widespread in the Muslim world—the Kalām. The term “Kalām”—meaning thought, speech, logic, and so forth—denotes Muslim theological schools that strove to offer the truth of Islam in rational terms. These theologians used polemical and dialectic arguments to prove that reason supports Muslim religion. Since existing sciences did not meet the aims of the Kalām supporters (known as Mutakallimūn), they created an alternative science. The natural science of the Mutakallimūn relied on elements (atomism, the existence of a vacuum), which Maimonides strongly opposed. Interestingly, modern science accepts these elements, but the dominant paradigm in Maimonides’ times was Aristotelian science, which negated them. Maimonides viewed Muslim theologians—and theologians in general—as self-serving and uninterested in objective truth, concerned only with the verification of their approach at any cost.7 He argued that they first made presumptions 7 Guide, I:71. See chapter 6 below.