Advancing the Learning Agenda in Jewish Education
Покупка
Тематика:
История образования и педагогики
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Год издания: 2018
Кол-во страниц: 227
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-754-0
Артикул: 872815.01.99
Jewish educational projects and programs are thriving, attracting philanthropic support for exciting and creative approaches in every sector and setting. But underneath that energy, we are not as clear as we ought to be about desired outcomes, the kinds of learning needed to achieve these, and how those kinds of learning actually occur. This volume is the first of its kind to bring together scholars from inside Jewish education and from the learning sciences. It offers a set of critical perspectives on learning, sometimes borrowing models from other domains (such as science) and sometimes examining specific domains within Jewish education (such as havruta learning or the learning of Jewish history). Collectively, these contributions help to advance a smarter, sharper conversation about Jewish learning that matters.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
ADV UU CI U G J H 3 L 3U R U I U G AG 3U D U I U J 3 U UISH EDUC UJ IO U
Jewish Identity in Post-Modern Society Series Editor ROBERTA ROSENBERG FARBER (Yeshiva University) Editorial Board SARA ABOSCH (University of Memphis) GEOFFREY ALDERMAN (University of Buckingham) YORAM BILU (Hebrew University) STEVEN M. COHEN (Hebrew Union College – Jewish Institute of Religion) BRYAN DAVES (Yeshiva University) SERGIO DELLA PERGOLA (Hebrew University) SIMCHA FISHBANE (Touro College) DEBORAH DASH MOORE (University of Michigan) UZI REBHUN (Hebrew University) REEVA SIMON (Yeshiva University) CHAIM I. WAXMAN (Rutgers University)
Boston ADV UU CI U G J H 3 L 3U R U I U G AG 3U D U I U J 3 U UISH EDUC UJ IO U Edited by JON A. LEVISOHN and JEFFREY S. KRESS
The research for this book and its publication were made possible by the generous support of the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Center for Studies in Jewish Education, a partnership between Brandeis University and the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Foundation of Cleveland, Ohio. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Levisohn, Jon A., editor. | Kress, Jeffrey S., editor. Title: Advancing the learning agenda in Jewish education / Jon A. Levisohn and Jeffrey S. Kress, editors. Description: Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2018. | Includes bibliographical references. Identifiers: LCCN 2018023237 (print) | LCCN 2018024454 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618117540 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618117533 (hardcover) | ISBN 9781618118790 (pbk.) Subjects: LCSH: Jews—Education. | Jewish religious education. | Judaism—Study and teaching. Classification: LCC LC715 (ebook) | LCC LC715 .A33 2018 (print) | DDC 296.6/8—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018023237 © Academic Studies Press, 2018 ISBN 978-1-618117-53-3 (hardcover) ISBN 978-1-618117-54-0 (electronic) ISBN 978-1-618118-79-0 (paperback) Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Cover design by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Table of Contents Introduction: What the “Learning Agenda” Is and Why It Matters Jon A. Levisohn and Jeffrey S. Kress PART ONE Learning from the Learning Sciences 9 Activating Jewish Learners: Positioning Youth for Persistent Success in Jewish Learning and Living 9 Rena Dorph and Christian D. Schunn Fostering Identity and Disposition Development in Jewish Education: A View from the Learning Sciences 27 Janet L. Kolodner Learning about Learning in Jewish Education 51 Ari Y. Kelman Old Traditions, New Practices: A Proposal for a Return to Text Study as a Centerpiece of Jewish Community and Family Life 71 Daniel P. Resnick and Lauren B. Resnick PART TWO Learning from Jewish Education 93 Observing Havruta Learning from the Perspective of the Learning Sciences 93 Baruch Schwarz Learning the Whole Game of Shabbat 112 Joseph Reimer What We Can Learn about Learning from Holocaust Education 129 Simone Schweber
vi Table of Contents PART THREE Conceptualizing Learning Outcomes 141 Is this a Real Story? Learning Critical History and Learning Its Limits 141 Sam Wineburg Learning to be Jewish 159 Eli Gottlieb The Holistic Goals of Jewish Education 177 Gil G. Noam and Jeffrey S. Kress Subject-Specific Learning Versus Jewish-Developmental Outcomes in Jewish Education: What Should We Aim For? 199 Jeffrey S. Kress and Jon A. Levisohn Index 215
Introduction: What the “Learning Agenda” Is and Why It Matters Jon A. Levisohn and Jeffrey S. Kress T he title of this volume declares its aspiration: to advance the learning agenda in Jewish education. What does that mean? Why does something called “the learning agenda” need to be advanced? And how might that happen? Over the past thirty years, we have seen the growth of familiar forms of Jewish education and the development of new ones. In the former category, we can name day schools, camps, academic Jewish studies, and Israel trips, as well as innovative new forms of supplementary Jewish education and renewed interest in early childhood education. In the latter, we can point to Jewish service learning, Jewish environmental and food programming, Jewish heritage tourism to other countries, online Jewish learning and Jewish gaming, and more. In every sector, talented and creative educators are developing new materials and new pedagogies. Yet, amid the creativity and growth, we believe that contemporary American Jewish education is not as strong as it could be. And we believe that at least part of the reason for this is that American Jewish education suffers from a lack of clarity about our desired learning outcomes, inconsistent focus on and assessment of those outcomes, and insufficient understanding of the experiences of learners. For example, supplementary school educators have been known to say that their programs should be more like camp. This is undoubtedly an important development, but their focus tends to be on the atmosphere and activities, the things that make camp “fun” rather than clarifying appropriate learning outcomes or documenting impact. The field of Israel education, according to several studies, bounces between uncritical celebrations of Israel
Jon A. Levisohn and Jeffrey S. Kress and narrowly focused advocacy activities, lacking a coherent framework that describes what can reasonably be called “learning outcomes” in the domain of Israel education. And in higher education, academics in the field of Jewish studies tend to invest their time and energy in crafting the excellent lecture or presentation, or assembling the most important materials into a syllabus, but invest far less time in exploring their students’ understanding. It is a truism in teacher education that novice teachers must overcome a natural tendency to focus on themselves—on saying and doing the right thing in the classroom—in order to focus on the students in front of them. In her work on novices, Sharon Feiman-Nemser calls this the “transition to pedagogical thinking.”1 We can also describe it as a move from thinking about teaching, primarily, to thinking about learning. At the risk of hyperbole, we believe that this is a move that the field of Jewish education, as a whole, needs to make. The point is not to reach consensus or unanimity about what those desired learning outcomes are. That is unlikely to happen, and our efforts here should certainly not be understood as endorsing one particular set of learning outcomes over others. But we do believe that educational leaders in the various settings in which Jewish education takes place need to focus more attention on learning. Thus, the “learning agenda” is shorthand for encouraging increased focus on conceptualizing learning outcomes in sophisticated ways, more sustained attention to how learning actually happens and how it sometimes fails to happen, and deeper curiosity about the experience of learners themselves in educational environments. “Advancing the learning agenda” means promoting these ideas among practitioners and researchers alike. We want educators and educational policy makers to be asking more and better questions about what kinds of learning ought to be happening, and what kinds of evidence we might have that they are. Why? We are scholars, but our interest in advancing the learning agenda is not only a scholarly one. Our interest is also a practical one. We believe that the more we understand about what we want students to learn and how that learning comes about (or does not come about), the more directed and more effective our educational efforts will become. In other words, advancing the learning agenda in the ways we have described is a strategic intervention into the system. We believe that the best way to improve pedagogic practice is by helping educators, of all kinds, to be more reflective about their desired 1 Sharon Feiman-Nemser and Margret Buchmann, The First Year of Teacher Preparation: Transition to Pedagogical Thinking? (East Lansing, MI: The Institute for Research on Teaching, Michigan State University, 1985), microfilm.
Introduction: What the “Learning Agenda” Is and Why It Matters outcomes, more self-critical about the effectiveness of their teaching, and more curious about the learning of their students. An example may be useful to illustrate what this can look like. Recently, as part of another project, we have had the opportunity to share the results of a pilot study of recent graduates of Jewish day schools—specifically, a study of their thinking about and understanding of rabbinic literature. Setting aside the specific findings of that study, what is relevant here is the reaction of educators when they learn about the findings, or even when they encounter the interview transcripts. In this case, we watched as they responded with energetic and intense curiosity. They eagerly pulled apart the data, interpreting nuances in the students’ formulations and raising endless questions about their significance. Unprompted, they turned their analyses back on their own teaching, challenging their prior assumptions, and they expressed excitement about asking similar questions of their own students or even designing their own studies. We cannot claim that all educators will react in similar ways, of course, nor do we know precisely how these reactions will translate into classroom practices. But we consider these experiences as corroborations of our hypothesis. Professionals in the field of Jewish education have precious few opportunities to dive into the learning of their students, and few structures to support doing so. The cultures of Jewish educational programs and institutions do not emphasize this kind of attention to learning. However, when given the opportunity to do so, educators seize hold of it with enthusiasm. This is what it can look like to advance the learning agenda in Jewish education. *** For the most part, the chapters of this book do not present specific empirical studies of learners and learning (although almost all are based on empirical work by the authors or others). Instead, these chapters and this book strive to advance the learning agenda in different ways—by promoting nuanced ideas about what learning means in Jewish education and by drawing on work outside of Jewish education to propose new models and frameworks. In several instances, authors took the opportunity to think out loud, as it were, about how we might think differently about learning in Jewish education. The first section of the book, “Learning from the Learning Sciences,” does this most explicitly. Two chapters, one by Rena Dorph and Christian Schunn and one by Janet Kolodner, build upon extensive research in science education, the most well-developed area of the learning sciences. Researchers in that field have long understood that they cannot be satisfied with rote learning, that the
Jon A. Levisohn and Jeffrey S. Kress desired outcomes are more subtle and nuanced (and harder to assess) than that. In Kolodner’s chapter, she describes her work in developing a series of science education programs that explicitly focus on cultivating a kind of scientist- or engineer-identity, and draws implications from that work for Jewish education. Dorph and Schunn, on the other hand, delineate an outcome that they call “science learning activation,” that is, a set of dispositions, practices, and knowledge that enable success in proximal learning experiences. They propose, in other words, that the goal of science education is to enable further (richer, deeper) science learning, which is enabled by “science learning activation.” The analogy to Jewish education, while imperfect, is generative: they propose that in Jewish education, too, the goal is to enable further (richer, deeper) Jewish learning—and not just learning but also living. In the third chapter in this section, Ari Kelman starts by broadening our purview; he wants us not to focus on learning specific Jewish content, primarily, but rather to think about “learning Jewish,” i.e., how people learn the numerous practices, formal and informal, that comprise Jewishness. He then roams widely over the literature on learning in general education in order to chart a number of promising avenues for investigating learning in Jewish education, avenues that are attuned to the situated and social nature of learning in ways that Jewish education rarely is. Finally, in the last chapter of this section, co-authors Lauren Resnick and Daniel Resnick call our attention to the dramatic shift in the scholarship on general education from didactic pedagogy to dialogic pedagogy—pedagogy that creates an environment for substantive conversation around a text. This paradigm emphasizes inquiry over information transmission. Notably, this kind of dialogic pedagogy has begun to take hold in fields such as science and math, and also, unsurprisingly, in the humanities. The Resnicks celebrate the tradition of text study within Judaism, but call for renewal of that tradition, especially in liberal Jewish settings. The second section of the book, “Learning from Jewish Education,” includes three chapters that focus on specific Jewish educational settings. The authors are each experienced researchers of those settings, but in these chapters, their task is not merely descriptive. Instead, they attend to those settings in order to draw out ideas or implications for learning more generally. It is commonplace, in the study of contemporary Jews, to separate the orthodox and especially the haredim, or ultra-orthodox. Their lives are different, with ritual and cultural practices that seem oriented around an entirely distinct set of norms. It is a culture that, at least for men in yeshivas, is intensely focused