Книжная полка Сохранить
Размер шрифта:
А
А
А
|  Шрифт:
Arial
Times
|  Интервал:
Стандартный
Средний
Большой
|  Цвет сайта:
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц

Yitz Greenberg and Modern Orthodoxy: The Road Not Taken

Покупка
Артикул: 872813.01.99
Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину
Sixteen scholars from around the globe gathered at the Oxford Centre for Hebrew and Jewish Studies in the bucolic Yarnton Manor in the Oxfordshire countryside in June 2014, for the first (now annual) Oxford Summer Institute on Modern and Contemporary Judaism. The current volume is the fruit of this encounter. The goal of the event was to facilitate in-depth engagement with the thought of Rabbi Dr. Irving "Yitz” Greenberg, concentrating particularly on the historical ramifications of his theological and public stances. Consideration was given to his lifelong and complex encounter with the Modern Orthodox stream of American Judaism and the extent to which his teachings functioned as "the road not taken.” This auspicious gathering was most certainly characterized by deep appreciation for Greenberg’s original outlook, which is predicated on his profound dedication to God, Torah, the Jewish people, and humanity. But this was by no means gratuitous homage or naive esteem. On the contrary, those in attendance understood that the most genuine form of admiration for a thinker and leader of his stature — especially one who continues to produce path-breaking writings and speak out publicly — is to examine rigorously and critically his ideas and legacy. We are confident that the creative process that was nurtured has resulted in a substantive contribution to research on the religious, historical, and social trajectories of contemporary Judaism, and, similarly will engender fresh thinking on crucial theological and ideological postures that will ultimately enrich Jewish life. This volume offers readers a critical engagement with the trenchant and candid efforts of one of the most thoughtful and earnest voices to emerge from within American Orthodoxy to address the theological and moral concerns that characterize our times.
Yitz Greenberg and Modern Orthodoxy: The Road Not Taken : монография / Ed. by A. Ferziger, M. Freud-Kandel, S. Bayme. – Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2019. - 309 с. – ISBN 978-1-61811-750-2. - Текст : электронный. - URL: https://znanium.ru/catalog/product/2240320 (дата обращения: 19.11.2026). – Режим доступа: по подписке.
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Yitz Greenberg
and
Modern Orthodoxy
T H E  R O A D  N O T  T A K E N


The studies in this volume emerged from the First Annual Oxford Summer 
Institute on Modern and Contemporary Judaism at the Oxford Centre for 
Hebrew and Jewish Studies, University of Oxford.
Funds for this volume made available through the generosity of
Jack and Giti Bendheim
The Maimonides Fund
The Susan and Jack Lapin Fund for Jewish Continuity (AJC)


Yitz Greenberg
and
Modern Orthodoxy
T H E  R O A D  N O T  T A K E N
ADAM FERZIGER,  
MIRI FREUD-KANDEL,  
AND STEVEN BAYME
Editors
Boston  
2019


© Academic Studies Press, 2019
All rights reserved.
ISBN 978-1-618117496 (hardback)
ISBN 978-1-618117502 (ebook)
Book design by PHi Business Solutions. 
Cover design by Ivan Grave. 
On the cover: Photo of Dr. Greenberg, Masmid 1966, p. 4.
Courtesy of the Yeshiva University Archives.
Published by the Borderlines Foundation for Academic Studies  
with Academic Studies Press. 
1577 Beacon street, 
Brookline, MA 02446, USA
www.borderlinesfoundation.org
press@academicstudiespress.com
www.academicstudiespress.com
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data:
The biographical record for this title is available from the Library of Congress. 
Identifiers: LCCN 2019942083 (print).


The following text is excerpted from the dedication of Masmid 1966, the 
Yeshiva College (Yeshiva University) Yearbook:
We dedicate this issue of Masmid to a man who is doubly unique. Professor 
Irving Greenberg is an extraordinary thinker and educator, being highly proficient 
not only in history, his specialty, but in the Humanities and the Natural and Social 
Sciences as well. Dr. Greenberg’s knowledge is matched by his teaching ability, 
as evidenced by the rare combination of clarity, precision, and subtle humor 
shown in his lectures. Meeting the test of a true professor, Dr. Greenberg always 
stimulates his students to work diligently on their own.
Dr. Greenberg is also an extraordinary human being; never one to neglect 
his students despite an increasingly heavy schedule. Anyone with personal or 
scholastic problems knows that Dr. Greenberg is always available with smiling 
face and a sympathetic heart. His encouraging manner in itself is often the first 
step in solving the difficulty.
More deeply, Dr. Greenberg’s significance lies in that he is the personification of the aim of Yeshiva University. Never reluctant to draw parallels and show 
differences between the heritage of classical Judaism and modern Western 
culture, Dr. Greenberg’s ultimate goal for himself, his students, and the institution 
is “synthesis” in its highest form.
The dedication of Masmid to Dr. Greenberg is only a small token of our deep 
esteem for him. Perhaps the only true recognition that can be given to such a a 
man is our self-dedication towards reaching our goal of Torah U’Madah.




Contents
Editors’ Foreword
Adam S. Ferziger, Miri Freud-Kandel, and Steven Bayme
Modern Orthodoxy and the Road Not Taken:  
A Retrospective View
7
Irving (Yitz) Greenberg
PART ONE
Law and Theology
55
1  History and Halakhah
55
Steven T. Katz
2  Rabbi Yitz Greenberg’s Covenantal Theory of Bioethics
67
Alan Jotkowitz
3  Irving Greenberg’s Theology of Hybrid Judaism
81
Darren Kleinberg
4  On the Meaning and Significance of Revelation for  
Orthodox Judaism
96
James Kugel
5  Divine Hiddenness and Human Input: The Potential  
Contribution of a Postmodern View of Revelation to  
Yitz Greenberg’s Holocaust Theology
107
Tamar Ross 
6  Modern Orthodoxy and Religious Truth
129
Marc B. Shapiro
7  On Revelation, Heresy, and Mesorah—from Louis Jacobs  
to the TheTorah.com
146
Miri Freud-Kandel


viii
Contents
PART TWO
Past and Present
172
  8  What Is “Modern” in Modern Orthodoxy?
172
Alan Brill
  9  Can Modern Orthodoxy Survive?
193
Jack Wertheimer
10  Where Have All the Rabbis Gone? The Changing Character  
of the Orthodox Rabbinate and its Causes
211
Samuel C. Heilman 
11  Modern Orthodox Responses to the Liberalization of  
Sexual Mores
224
Sylvia Barack Fishman
12  “The Road Not Taken” and “The One Less Traveled”:  
The Greenberg–Lichtenstein Exchange and  
Contemporary Orthodoxy
254
Adam S. Ferziger
Editors and Contributors
289
Index
293


Editors’ Foreword
ADAM S. FERZIGER, MIRI FREUD-KANDEL, AND 
STEVEN BAYME
I
n late June 2014, sixteen scholars from around the globe gathered at the Oxford 
Centre for Hebrew and Jewish Studies in the bucolic Yarnton Manor in the 
Oxfordshire countryside, for the first (now annual) Oxford Summer Institute 
on Modern and Contemporary Judaism. The goal of this inaugural event was to 
facilitate in-depth engagement with the contributions of Rabbi Dr. Irving “Yitz” 
Greenberg, concentrating particularly on the historical ramifications of his theological and public stances. Consideration was given to his lifelong and complex 
encounter with the Modern Orthodox stream of American Judaism and the extent 
to which his teachings functioned as “the road not taken.” Toward these aims, each 
of the participants prepared a first draft of a research study that was distributed in 
advance. These papers then served as the springboards for the seminar sessions. 
This auspicious gathering was most certainly characterized by deep appreciation for Greenberg’s original outlook, which is predicated on his profound dedication to God, Torah, the Jewish people, and humanity. But this was by no means 
gratuitous homage or naive esteem. On the contrary, those in attendance understood that the most genuine form of admiration for a thinker and leader of his 
stature—especially one who continues to produce path-breaking writings and 
speak out publicly—is to examine rigorously and critically his ideas and legacy. 
Others might have found it overwhelming, if not discouraging, to experience the depth and array of piercing analysis to which Greenberg’s positions 
and works were subjected. The appreciative manner in which Yitz—and his 
wife Blu—listened to their counterparts, and in parallel the gentle assertiveness 
with which he challenged points that were raised, was decisive in facilitating 
healthy and candid discourse. 
This volume brings together updated versions of many of the papers 
that were first presented at the Oxford Summer Institute. In the interim, each 


Adam S. Ferziger, Miri Freud-Kandel, and Steven Bayme
was revised in response to the dynamic deliberations that took place and new 
materials that have subsequently appeared, as well as the critical comments of 
anonymous readers who evaluated them for their academic quality. We are confident that the creative process that was nurtured has resulted in a substantive 
contribution to research on the religious, historical, and social trajectories of 
contemporary Judaism, and, similarly will engender fresh thinking on crucial 
theological and ideological postures that will ultimately enrich Jewish life.
***
Greenberg, as detailed in his own contribution to this volume, grew up in an 
Orthodox Jewish home in the Borough Park section of Brooklyn. He was educated in Orthodox Jewish schools that provided both religious and secular 
studies and encouraged integration into American life, and subsequently in a 
more traditionalist-oriented advanced yeshiva, where he gained rabbinical ordination. In 1959, while completing his Harvard University PhD in American 
history, he was appointed a full-time faculty member at Yeshiva College (Yeshiva University), the banner institution of the burgeoning “Modern Orthodox” camp within American Jewry. A few years later, he accepted the position 
of rabbi of the Riverdale Jewish Center, a synagogue in an area of New York 
that had only recently attracted Orthodox Jews. Over the course of the 1960s 
his reputation soared as a dynamic academic, communal rabbi, public activist, 
and creative educator intent on advancing an expansive approach to Orthodox 
Jewish engagement with contemporary intellectual and cultural trends. Subsequently, his progressive alienation from the increasingly more conservative directions of the Modern Orthodox sector was given concrete expression, when 
he simultaneously resigned from Yeshiva University and the Riverdale Jewish 
Center rabbinate in 1972. Henceforth, his public career focused on spreading 
Jewish knowledge and enhancing identification of the broader American Jewish population with their heritage. Here, too, his efforts met with considerable 
excitement and wide support. Some referred to him as “the rabbi of American 
Jewry.” He also emerged as a groundbreaking post-Holocaust theologian. While 
Greenberg remained a committed Orthodox Jew, outside his local community 
his formal public role within mainstream late twentieth and early twenty-first 
century Orthodox life was relatively limited.
Greenberg’s interests span a broad range of concerns. He introduced one 
of the earliest university courses on the Holocaust and served as executive 
director of the United States Holocaust Commission, which in turn recommended the establishment of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum 


Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину