Книжная полка Сохранить
Размер шрифта:
А
А
А
|  Шрифт:
Arial
Times
|  Интервал:
Стандартный
Средний
Большой
|  Цвет сайта:
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц

Macht Arbeit Frei? German Economic Policy and Forced Labor of Jews in the General Government, 1939–1943

Покупка
Артикул: 872808.01.99
Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину
This volume is the first ever study to address Jewish forced labor in Poland's General Government during the Holocaust. The study presents German economic policy on the occupied territories, discussing Germany’s misappropriation and misuse of available resources — particularly human resources and their inhuman treatment—and how this policy ultimately led to the downfall of the Nazi regime. This fascinating study sheds a light on the mutual dependence of economics and warfare during one of the most difficult periods in human history.
Medykowski, W. Macht Arbeit Frei? German Economic Policy and Forced Labor of Jews in the General Government, 1939–1943 : монография / W. Medykowski. – Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2018. - 453 с. – ISBN 978-1-61811-597-3. - Текст : электронный. - URL: https://znanium.ru/catalog/product/2240313 (дата обращения: 20.11.2026). – Режим доступа: по подписке.
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Boston 
J  e  w  s     o  f     P o  l  a  n  d
German Economic Policy 
and Forced Labor of Jews 
in the General Government, 
1939–1943
WITOLD W.
ME ¸DYKOWSKI
MACHT 
ARBEIT 
FREI?


Jews of Poland 
Series Editor ANTONY POLONSKY (Brandeis University)
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: the bibliographic 
record for this title is available from the Library of Congress at
https://lccn.loc.gov/2018036422
© Academic Studies Press, 2018
ISBN 978-1-61811-596-6 (hardcover)
ISBN 978-1-61811-597-3 (electronic)
Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. 
www.kryonpublishing.com 
Academic Studies Press
28 Montfern Avenue
Brighton, MA 02135, USA
P: (617)782-6290
F: (857)241-3149
press@academicstudiespress.com
www.academicstudiespress.com 
This publication is supported by
An electronic version of this book is freely available, thanks to the support of libraries 
working with Knowledge Unlatched. KU is a collaborative initiative designed to 
make high quality books Open Access for the public good. The Open Access ISBN 
for this book is 978-1-61811-907-0. More information about the initiative and 
links to the Open Access version can be found at www.knowledgeunlatched.org.


To Luba, with special thanks and gratitude


Table of Contents
Acknowledgements
v
vii
Part One
Chapter 1:  The War against Poland and the Beginning of 
German Economic Policy in the Ocсupied Territory
1
Chapter 2:  Forced Labor from the Period of Military 
Government until the Beginning of Ghettoization
18
Chapter 3:  Forced Labor in the Ghettos and Labor Detachments
74
Chapter 4:  Forced Labor in the Labor Camps
134
Part Two
Chapter 5:  The War in the East: Galicia during the First Weeks of the War 181
Chapter 6:  Jewish Labor in Galicia
193
Chapter 7:  Jewish Labor in the Shadow of the Aktion Reinhardt
221
Chapter 8:  War Industry Requirements in the Face of 
Annihilation of the Workforce
246
Chapter 9:  Harvest Festival (Erntefest)—Extermination 
of the Remaining Jews in the District of Lublin
273
Conclusion
292
List of Abbreviations
320
Archival Sources
323
Maps
326
Tables
333
Photographs
364
Bibliography
381
Index
407


Acknowledgements
T
his research, as with any academic inquiry, would not be possible without 
the support of many people and institutions that over the past years have 
assisted me in its completion.
Firstly, I would like to express my deepest gratitude to Professor Daniel 
Blatman, the supervisor of this research project at the Hebrew University of 
Jerusalem. Prof. Blatman has been my academic teacher for many years, starting from my studies at Tel Aviv University and during my subsequent studies 
at the Institute of Contemporary Jewry at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. 
Many of his courses have given me not only knowledge regarding the Holocaust, 
but also an understanding of the processes and mechanisms which functioned 
during the Holocaust period, as well as before and afterwards.
I would like to thank Professors Dalia Ofer, Moshe Zimmermann from the 
Hebrew University, as well as Professor Dan Michman from Bar Ilan University 
and Yad Vashem, who assisted me during this research. I would also express my 
deep gratitude to the late Professor David Bankier, who was a brilliant teacher 
and researcher, but who is unfortunately no longer with us.
During my studies at the Institute of the Contemporary History at the 
Hebrew University of Jerusalem, I had the privilege of being a student of such 
researchers as late Professors Israel Gutman, Ezra Mendelsohn and many other 
outstanding scholars, who provided me with knowledge and inspiration which 
led me to follow their footsteps and study the Holocaust. I am very grateful to Professor Eli Lederhendler, Mrs. Tzipi Bibelnik, from the Institute of 
Contemporary Jewry, and Ms. Alma Lessing from the Authority of Research 
and Development at the Hebrew University. I would like to thank my colleagues at Yad Vashem, whose assistance was very helpful.
The German Foundation “Remembrance, Responsibility and Future” 
(Die Stiftung “Erinnerung, Verantwortung und Zukunft,” or EVZ) supported this 
research in Germany in the framework of International Research Project on 


vi
Acknowledgements
Forced Labor during the National Socialist regime. Thanks to this support, I 
was able to visit archives in Germany and Poland as well as to attend conferences in Schwanenwerder and Berlin. In particular, I would like to thank Dr. 
Martin Salm, Mr. Günter Saathoff, Mr. Martin Bock as well as Ms. Ekaterina 
Engel, Ms. Judith Blum, Ms. Anna Henk, and Ms. Veronika Sellner. I wish to 
express my gratitude to other institutions which supported my research during 
its early stages: the Institute of Contemporary Jewry, The Leonid Nevzlin 
Research Center for Russian and Eastern European Jewry, The Dinur Center 
for Research in Jewish History at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and the 
Avraham Margaliot Foundation at Yad Vashem.
During my research, I used material from the Military Archives in Freiburg, 
The Federal Archives in Germany, the State Archives in Lublin, the Institute of 
National Remembrance (IPN), the Yad Vashem Archives and many collections 
from various archives around the world copied by and stored at the Yad Vashem 
Archives. I had the opportunity to consult the research literature in the following libraries: the Bloomfield Library at Mt Scopus, the Jewish National Library, 
the Yad Vashem Library, The National Library in Warsaw and others.
I would like to thank my colleagues, Prof. Stephan Lehnstaedt and 
Dr. Klaus-Peter Friedrich, who helped me in obtaining several important 
sources, Mr. Jarosław Suproniuk who graphically prepared the maps, and 
Yochanan Amichai, a specialist in German sources.
I am very grateful to Yad Vashem Photo Archives in Jerusalem and the 
National Digital Archives (NAC) in Warsaw.
Finally, yet importantly, my family members were witnesses of the long 
hours spent on writing—the hours I was not able to give to them. I would like 
to thank them for their patience and support.


T
his book examines various questions concerning the forced labor of 
Jews in the General Government. Since labor in general provides means 
of subsistence, it is important to the economy and existence of any society. 
However, in this case we are dealing not only with labor but “forced labor” in 
the times of war and the Holocaust. This was one of the greatest catastrophes 
of the Jewish people and with no doubt one of the blackest times of the history of the humanity. Therefore, the concepts of subsistence and labor in this 
period take new and important meaning, especially if terms like “labor,” “productivity,” and “utility” are the ones which could have played a role in saving 
the lives of able-bodied Jews from imminent destruction. The key term here 
is “forced labor” (Zwangsarbeit) because, apart from some variants, it was the 
word employed for the labor of Jews during most of the period of the General 
Government’s existence and, in general, this term was one of the most widely 
used during World War II. But the question is not only semantics; rather, our 
goal is to examine the the real meaning hidden behind this term. This idea was 
first conceived in the official documents of the General Government in the 
autumn of 1939 but, quite quickly, other words were adopted to supplement 
or clarify the meaning. Perhaps, a term that better reflects the meaning of such 
labor is the word “slave labor” (Sklavenarbeit), although the Nazi official establishment tried to avoid its use. 
The period of utilization of forced labor in the General Government can 
be divided into two key phases that will be examined:
-
	a period when Jews worked as a means to obtain a bare subsistence
-
	a period when Jews worked as a means to save themselves from immediate destruction
The first period begins with the outbreak of the war and ends with the 
beginning of the Aktion Reinhardt. It important to stress that during this 


viii
period most of the Jews in occupied Poland and, in particular, in the territory of the General Government were still alive. Moreover, during that period 
more and more Jews were deported from the territory of Warthegau and other 
formerly Polish territories annexed to the Reich as well as from the Reich itself 
(from Vienna, Stettin, and other places). Therefore, the problem of finding 
work that could provide means of subsistence concerned millions of Jews. 
Contemporary research still does not dedicate enough space and attention to 
this question.
Additionally, our research aims to understand the role that forced labor 
played in the economic policies of the German authorities in the General 
Government. War economy has its rules, its limitations, and its regulations, 
making it different from a free market capitalist economy. To complicate 
matters, in the ghettos of the General Government there existed a particular 
economic system, which could be described as “forced economy.” It was very 
different from the general economic system outside the ghettos, which also had 
its limitations and regulations. However, this “forced” economic system was 
also limited by general legal restrictions, such as rationing of means of energy, 
restrictions concerning the functioning of the market, and so on. The people 
inside the ghettos were struggling with additional legal restrictions, which limited their movement, transfer of money, and so forth. This system forced the 
Jews to work under the conditions of hunger and lack of raw materials. In some 
cases, the workers were not able even to feed themselves and their families. 
They were underpaid and exploited. This economic system requires further 
research, however.1
The second period, starting with the Aktion Reinardt, begins a completely new phase in the life of the Jews in the General Government as well 
in other areas of Nazi-occupied Central and Eastern Europe. This period 
is marked by the partial liquidation of the ghettos, acompanied by brutal 
Aktionen, and by the beginning of mass deportation to the death camps, so 
that most of the Jews at this time faced danger of imminent annihilation. 
The only ones who could hope for a prolongation of their existence were 
able-bodied men and women who could work for the Germans. The Jews 
faced a choice: to work or to perish. Not all Jews were able to work; thus, this 
question was irrelevant to most of them. However, in many cases, even those 
  1	 Witold Mędykowski, “Der jüdische Kampf um Lebensunterhalt in den Ghettos des 
Generalgouvernements,” in Lebenswelt Ghetto: Alltag und Soziales Umfeld während der nazionalsozialistischen Verfolgung, ed. Imke Hanse Katrin Steffen, and Joachim Tauber (Wiesbaden: 
Harrassowitz Vlg., 2013), 230.


ix
not particularly abled, old, or underaged made all the possible effort in order 
to work. We will, however, examine closely whether the work really meant 
survival or not. This question is quite important, since not all working Jews 
survived. Was the Nazi policy in this regard consistent during the examined 
period, and who were the people or organizations making those decisions? 
The aim of this research is also to identify these actors, the conflicting objectives of their activities, the competition among them, and even their opposing interests. The use of a monolithic understanding of the SS turns out to 
be incorrect in the case of the General Government. Moreover, even from a 
broader perspective, the SS, as well as its different agencies, seems to be less 
monolithic. 
Forced labor in general and forced labor of Jews in particular were also 
important in the context of migrations inside the Third Reich as well as in 
territories occupied by Nazi Germany in Europe. Frequently mentioned are 
foreign laborers, including concentration camp prisoners and forced laborers, 
among them the Jews. For example, in 1944, 7.1 million foreign workers were 
employed in Nazi Germany.2 According to Wolfgang Benz, “A total of about 
15 million Soviet citizens had been recruited into the one or other forms to 
perform work for the German side.”3 We do not have the exact numbers for 
all the occupied territories but, surely, we may speak about tens of millions 
of forced laborers performing daily work for the Nazi regime. In this case, the 
General Government may serve as a case study. It is a very complex case, but 
especially important because the General Government suffered Nazi occupation during an especially long period, which allowed the Nazis to develop 
special policies concerning the territory’s multiethnic population, which 
included ethnic Germans. The Nazi authorities introduced new migration 
policies, settlement of ethnic Germans, a Jewish policy that involved construction of more death camps than anywhere in Europe and annihilation 
measures such as Aktion Reinhardt. Their legislation also aimed at developing the region’s armament industry. Close examination of the developments in the General Government may answer many questions concerning 
the Nazi policy in general and SS policy in particular. Although the General 
Government was conceived as an independent administrative unit, it was, 
however, a playground of multiple actors within the German administration 
  2	 Wolfgang Benz, “Zwangsarbeit im nationalsozialistischen Staat: Dimensionen—
Strukturen—Perspektiven,” in Dachauer Hefte 16 (2000): 4.


x
on different levels, in the Reich proper, the SS, the Wehrmacht, among the 
German entrepreneurs, as well as, to lesser extent, the Polish entrepreneurs 
and the Jewish institutions and individuals. 
From autumn 1942 forward, forced labor was increasingly used in the 
German armament industry. Because of the importance of this industry for 
the Third Reich’s war effort, working there took on a new meaning. These 
protected workplaces could save lives. However, the controversy between 
the Wehrmacht and the SS in this matter was not a new problem. It existed 
in the Reich since the beginning of the war and reemerged periodically. 
It seems that this controversy remained unsolved until the very end of the 
Third Reich. 
During the last twenty-five years, the question of forced labor during 
the Nazi period has become a subject not only of intensive research but also 
a battlefield of various theories and theses. Many researchers have advanced 
arguments for this or that position, trying to explain the meaning of forced 
labor policies that led to the annihilation of millions of people, among them 
most of the European Jewish population. Thus, labor, forced labor, and the war 
economy are directly linked to the key questions surrounding the very nature 
of the Nazi State. We hope that this research may contribute to this larger 
historical debate.
BEGINNING OF THE WAR
The use of forced labor in the 1930s serves as a basis for the analysis of the development of forced labor in Polish territory during the period of hostilities and 
military administration. The creation of the General Government in October 
1939 initiated a period of exploitation of forced labor of the Jews. Hans Frank,4 
and subsequently the higher SS and police leader in the General Government, 
Friedrich-Wilhelm Krüger,5 created a legal basis for exploitation of the Jews. 
  4	 Hans Frank (1900–1946), founder of the Academy of German Law, Member of the 
Reichstag and Minister without portfolio. In September 1939 he was nominated by General 
Gerd von Runstedt as the chief of the civil administration (Chef der Zivilverwaltung) by the 
Army Group South. Since October 26, 1939, Frank served as the general governor for the 
occupied Polish territories (Generalgouverneur für die besetzten polnischen Gebiete). Arrested 
by American troops on May 3, 1945, he was tried before the International Military Tribunal 
in Nuremberg. He was sentenced to death on October 1, 1946, and executed on October 16, 
1946.
  5	 Friedrich-Wilhelm Krüger (1894–1945) became on October 4, 1939 HSSPF “Ost,” 
then HSSPF in the General Government. Since May 1942 he was also Secretary of State 


Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину