Messianism in Medieval Jewish Thought
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Schwartz Dov
Год издания: 2017
Кол-во страниц: 288
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-570-6
Артикул: 693859.02.99
How did medieval Jewish scholars, from Saadia Gaon to Yitzhak Abravanel, imagine a world that has experienced salvation? What is the nature of reality in the days of the Messiah? This work explores reactions to the seductive promises of apocalyptic teachings, tracing their fluctuations between intellect and imagination. The volume extensively surveys the tension between naturalistic and apocalyptic approaches to the history of the messianic idea so fundamental to the history of Jewish philosophy in the Middle Ages and reveals the scope and challenges of medieval thought.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Messianism in Medieval Jewish Thought
Emunot: Jewish Philosophy and Kabbalah Series Editor Dov Schwartz (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Editorial Board Ada Rapoport Albert (University College, London) Gad Freudenthal (CNRS, Paris) Gideon Freudenthal (Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv) Moshe Idel (Hebrew University, Jerusalem) Raphael Jospe (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Ephraim Kanarfogel (Yeshiva University, New York) Menachem Kellner (Haifa University, Haifa) Daniel Lasker (Ben-Gurion University, Beer Sheva)
Boston Messianism in Medieval Jewish Thought Dov Schwartz Translated by Batya Stein
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Schwartz, Dov, author. | Stein, Batya, translator. Title: Messianism in medieval Jewish thought / Dov Schwartz; translated by Batya Stein. Other titles: ha-Ra-ayon ha-meshihi ba-hagut ha-Yehudit bi-Yeme ha-Beinayim. English Description: Academic Studies | Press: Brighton, MA, [2017] Series: Emunot: Jewish philosophy and Kabbalah | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2016052710 | ISBN 9781618115690 (hardback) Subjects: LCSH: Messianic era (Judaism)—History of doctrines. Redemption— Judaism—History of doctrines. | Jewish philosophy. | Philosophy, Medieval. Classification: LCC BM625 .S3413 1997 | DDC 296.3/3609—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016052710 Copyright © 2017 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN 978-1-618115-69-0 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-618115-70-6 (electronic) Cover design by Jen Stacey Book design by Kryon Publishing www.kryonpublishing.com Published by Academic Studies Press in 2017 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Preface vi Chapter 1: Methodological Introduction 1 Chapter 2: Apocalyptic Messianism in a Rationalist Garb 16 Chapter 3: Individual Redemption and Naturalism 34 Chapter 4: The Resurgence of Apocalyptic Messianism 78 Chapter 5: The Decline of Collective Naturalism 98 Chapter 6: Between Naturalism and Apocalyptic Messianism 137 Chapter 7: Clarifying Positions: The Last Stage 180 Chapter 8: Conclusions: Redemption, Models, and Decisions 220 Appendix History, Ideas, and the History of Ideas 231 Bibliography 248 Index 272
Preface Messianism has played a significant role in Jewish thought and culture. This yearning for redemption in a people in exile is understandable, given that the announcement of its exile was tied to that of its birth at the “covenant between the parts” (Genesis 15:1-15). Jewish thought was first systematically formulated in the Middle Ages, and it was then that messianic approaches also found fitting expression. Knowledge about these messianic views in medieval thought is thus also important as a conceptual and cultural foundation of modern and contemporary messianic approaches. The present work is an attempt to outline the basic characteristics of rationalist messianic approaches in the Middle Ages, and particularly the conceptual tensions between them. Specifically, it focuses on various manifestations of two messianic approaches that address the nature of the messianic process as well as the outlines of future redemption in general. The first approach will, for the current purposes, be referred to as apocalyptic.1 Terms such as “miraculous” or “supernatural” do not encompass the full span of this view. In its context, redemption means an essential and profound change in the cosmos, up to its destruction and rebuilding, and its attainment is tied to a glorious messianic tableau, with a plot and a distinctly mythical order. The second approach, to be referred to as naturalistic, challenges the assumption of the end of the world as a condition of redemption. It holds that we should not despair of the present world and its amendment and, therefore, should not ask for a new world to emerge on the ruins of the present one. This approach significantly lessens direct divine involvement in the redemptive process and almost excludes it altogether. This view characterized classic rationalists who recoiled from changes in the natural order and from the imaginary, and to some extent dangerous, character of the apocalyptic legacy. This book traces the emergence of these two positions in Jewish philosophy and their various manifestations until 1 In this work, apocalyptic is used to denote content rather than form. Content-wise, the apocalyptic chapters in Isaiah, Daniel, and other biblical texts deal with the end of the world, with a wondrous war with mythical and demonic creatures, and so forth. In other words, apocalypse is tied to the supernatural and the mythical. Formwise, apocalypse is formulated as visions, with their usual literary characteristics. By contrast, visionary writing is not widespread in the philosophical literature of the Middle Ages, and its character is also alien to the genre. See Malcolm Bull, ed., Apocalypse Theory and the Ends of the World (Oxford: Blackwell, 1995).
vii Preface the end of the Middle Ages, including the tension between them following their confrontation. A book of this kind could hardly have been written in its present form during the nineteenth century or the beginning of the twentieth. I will not enter here into the recurring conflict between the present and previous generation of scholars with the Wissenschaft des Judentums school and the extent of its biases. Clearly, however, misgivings still prevail about delving too deeply into the issue of messianism and its implications. Three brief examples of how messianism was handled will serve to illustrate this determination: 1) In an article devoted to this topic in his Jüdische Schriften, Hermann Cohen described the messianic idea relying solely on naturalistic motifs. He did not consider that apocalyptic messianism had any right to exist or exerted any influence. 2) David Neumark, among the more sober scholars of Wissenschaft des Judentums, devised an ambitious plan for writing, in ten volumes, the “history of Jewish philosophy” up to the end of the Middle Ages. He succeeded in writing four—an introductory volume, matter and form, the attributes in antiquity, and dogma. The messianic idea never featured in this plan, even though other theological issues, such as prophecy, do appear. 3) When Benzion Netanyahu dealt with the messianic issue in his important book on Abravanel (published in 1953), he rushed to explain and justify the motif of vengeance from Gentiles. The vengeance motif is widespread in apocalyptic messianic trends, be they philosophical or mythical, and one of their integral components. Apologizing and downplaying messianic positions is currently unnecessary. Gershom Scholem’s merit is that he dared to present a direct analysis of the messianic idea’s elements without restricting himself to specific issues, such as the dates of redemption or historical messianic movements. Scholem’s disciples presented detailed and exhaustive analyses of messianic manifestations in Kabbalah and Jewish mysticism. The messianic component in rationalist Jewish philosophy, however, seems to require further attention. Scholars have not found the juncture of rationality and messianism appealing and this topic, except for a few important studies, has not been sufficiently discussed. Note that the present work does deal at length with the approach conveying apprehensions about any concern with messianism. These apprehensions,
viii Preface however, are not a modern phenomenon and had already existed in the Middle Ages. At that time, a trend emerged seeking to make messianic descriptions enlightened and universal, confronting the sources on the one hand and the zeitgeist on the other. The visions in the biblical, talmudic, and midrashic sources prophesied vengeance and retribution as well as a wonderful world for the god-fearing, mostly only for the Jews among them. The popular mood longed for the great and terrible day of the Lord, when God would take revenge on the Gentiles and on the “members of religions” (Moslems and Christians) for the suffering they had inflicted on God’s chosen people. Rationality, as noted, attempted to contend with this sweeping approach and, supported by several prestigious figures (Maimonides, Rashba, and others), presented a fair and balanced confrontation with the apocalyptic view. Among rationalists, this confrontation persisted until the end of the Middle Ages and was only settled with the appearance of R. Yitzhak Abravanel. The importance of this historical and philosophical chapter in the study of the history of ideas seems quite obvious, but an inquiry into this question will also provide some perspective on the conceptual forces active in Jewish thought. A deeper analysis of these philosophical and theological sources indeed reveals that contemporary positions have their roots in the Jewish world of ideas. Describing how the messianic idea came into being within Jewish thought is crucial because, contrary to Islam and Christianity, which required only a few decades to formulate a systematic theology, Judaism took many centuries to present a methodical philosophy. Hence, the study of medieval philosophy is not an archaic concern with dusty and crumbling books and manuscripts of interest to a tiny group of academics, but an inquiry into the cradle of systematic thought in Judaism. This probe into the messianic idea, then, is doubly significant: it points to fundamental trends that Jewish culture draws upon to this day, and affords a glimpse into the relationship of Judaism with its surroundings in the past and possibly in the present. The research method adopted in this study focuses on a wide spectrum of thinkers. The present book’s essential innovation is that it does not, unlike the studies on messianic thought so far, focus on key figures. Both historically and philosophically, describing the conceptual aspects of a culture according to the doctrine of one or two thinkers as a suitable representation of a century or more seems mistaken. This is the approach that was applied in Joseph Saracheck’s book, published in 1932, which attempts to describe a period by studying the teachings of a few isolated figures. Attention has also focused on printed works, while neglecting
ix Preface manuscripts. In the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, however, printed works are only a fraction of the active thought of the period. The merit of the present work is that it describes currents of thought developing and resonating in the teachings of dozens of thinkers, seeking to present the leading philosophical doctrines against the backdrop of the period and its spirit. Many conceptual phenomena that seem startling and unusual in isolation thereby become understandable. The research method focusing on conceptual circles rather than on the thought of individual figures is applied in this work to one issue in the general context of the messianic idea—messianic tension—which bears implications for other dimensions of the encounter between philosophy and theology. This book does not pretend to encompass the philosophical dynamic of the Middle Ages as a whole. It concentrates on the “Sephardic” rationalism that arose in the Iberian Peninsula, Provence, and Italy, and its impact on Jewish thought in Byzantium.2 Lacunas will most probably be revealed regarding personalities or cultural areas, given that research on the philosophy and theology of rationality in Byzantium and Ashkenaz is only beginning. It does describe, however, the central developments in the messianic idea from West to East and suitably reflects the philosophical endeavor within the circles of Jewish rationality. *** Many colleagues have read this manuscript, wholly or partly, and most of them also made important comments. Some of them inspired the ideas mentioned in it—Moshe Hallamish, Moshe Idel, Menachem Kellner, Daniel Lasker, Lawrence Schiffman, and Eliezer Schlossberg. I am grateful to all. I wish to express once more my deep thanks and appreciation to Batya Stein. Batya is not only my translator but a genuine partner to my writing, whose insights and contributions make her an author. I am honored and grateful for this privilege. 2 In Ashkenaz, the rationalistic trend was marginal. For the differences between “Ashkenazi” and “Sephardic” messianism in general and specifically on Ashkenazi messianism, see, for example, Gershon D. Cohen, “Messianic Postures of Ashkenazim and Sephardim,” Leo Baeck Memorial Lecture 9 (1967): 117–158; Elisheva Carlebach, Between History and Hope: Jewish Messianism in Ashkenaz and Sepharad (New York: Touro College, 1998); Israel Yuval, Two Nations in Your Womb: Perceptions of Jews and Christians in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages, trans. Barbara Harshav and Jonathan Chipman (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2006); Sarit Shalev-Eyni, “Between Carnality and Spirituality: A Cosmological Vision of the End at the Turn of the Fifth Jewish Millennium,” Speculum 90 (2015): 458-482.