Reflections on Identity. The Jewish Case
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Sagi Avi
Год издания: 2016
Кол-во страниц: 225
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-535-5
Артикул: 694316.02.99
Two basic approaches have shaped the identity discourse since antiquity. The essentialist view assumes that a person's identity does exist "somewhere," and the discourse on identity is an attempt to disclose it. People do not create their identity, they only realize it. The opposite, deconstructionist view, assumes that the identity is only a linguistic fiction; we have no identity outside our concrete history, which reflects a constantly ongoing dynamic change. The present book offers a third option. It accepts that identity is not a priori datum that precedes our existence but claims we do have a set historical cultural identity it calls "primary," expressing a permanent foundation of our biography. On its basis, we build our concrete identity. Engaging in a critical analysis, the book exposes the foundations and the borders of the identity field. As a test case that illustrates its claims, it presents the discourse on Jewish identity. Lively, vigorous, and widely recorded, this discourse conveys many nuances of the tension between continuity and change and is thus uniquely fit to convey the significance of the identity discourse.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Reflections on Identity T h e J e w i s h C a s e
Emunot: JE wish PhilosoPhy and Kabbalah Series Editor: Dov Schwartz (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Editorial Board Ada Rapoport Albert (University College, London) Gad Freudenthal (CNRS, Paris) Gideon Freudenthal (Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv) Moshe Idel (Hebrew University, Jerusalem) Raphael Jospe (Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan) Ephraim Kanarfogel (Yeshiva University, New York) Menachem Kellner (Haifa University, Haifa) Daniel Lasker (Ben-Gurion University, Beer Sheva)
Boston Reflections on Identity T h e J e w i s h C a s e Avi Sagi Translated by Batya Stein
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Sagi, Abraham, author. | Stein, Batya, translator. Title: Reflections on identity : the Jewish case / Avi Sagi ; translated by Batya Stein. Description: Brighton, MA : Academic Studies Press, [2016] Series: Emunot: Jewish philosophy and Kabbalah Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2016037749 (print) LCCN 2016038646 (ebook) ISBN 978-1-61811-534-8 (hardcover) ISBN 978-1-61811-535-5 (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: Jews—Identity—Philosophy. Classification: LCC DS143 .S1385 2016 (print) LCC DS143 (ebook) DDC 305.892/4—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016037749 ISBN 978-1-61811-534-8 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-61811-535-5 (electronic) ©Academic Studies Press, 2016 Cover design by Inbal Pinto Book design by Kryon Publishing, www.kryonpublishing.com Published by Academic Studies Press 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Acknowledgments vi Preface vii Part One 1 Chapter 1: From an Essentialist to a Multicultural Identity 2 Chapter 2: A Critique of the Jewish Identity Discourse 32 Chapter 3: Primordial Identity: The Jewish Case 59 Part Two 88 Chapter 4: Between a Rights Discourse and an Identity Discourse 91 Chapter 5: “Religion and State”: A Critical Analysis 111 Chapter 6: On Exile, Strangers, and Sovereignty: Identity in the Biblical Tradition 136 Bibliography 197 Sources 209 Index 210
Acknowledgments I am deeply grateful to my two professional homes in recent decades—the Department of Philosophy and the Graduate Program of Hermeneutics and Cultural Studies at Bar-Ilan University and the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem. In the fruitful encounter between them I have found space for my personal growth and for the questions that I grapple with. I have shared many thoughts on the complex issues raised in this book with Donniel Hartman, president of the Shalom Hartman Institute, who has been unfailing in his support and encouragement. I deeply appreciate our longstanding friendship and his untiring efforts in pursuit of the Institute’s development. Special thanks to Laura Gilinsky, the Institute’s PR officer, for her contribution to the publication of this book. Thanks to colleagues whose comments on earlier versions of the chapters of this book contributed to its final form: Shraga Bar-On, Yakir Englander, Menachem Fisch, Eliezer Goldman z”l, Pini Ifargan, David Kurzweil, Charles Liebman z”l, Hanan Mandel, Menachem Mautner, Daniel Statman, Yedidia Stern, and Dror Yinon. Special thanks to my assistant, Roni Barlev. I dedicate this book with thanks and deep appreciation to my friend Batya Stein, who, for close to thirty years, has translated all my work from Hebrew to English. Batya is not only a translator but a serious partner to the thinking about my texts, who successfully presents their optimal possibilities. Her friendship, her commitment, and her exceptional professionalism have all been a source of inspiration to me.
Preface The identity of individuals, as manifest in their lifestyles, practices, myths, memory, and hopes, is not a “natural” datum found “somewhere” in the world. Identity is a signifier denoting the complex story of human existence, and requires a cultural web that both concretizes it and constitutes it. The classic traditional discussion on the question of identity, which had dealt with the relationship between the one and the many, focused on one question: what is the essential element that determines differences and enables the distinction between one and the other? This classic approach, a legacy of Aristotelian thought, has been subject to serious criticism in general and in its application to humans in particular. This book focuses on the identity of real people who, rather than in some atopical realm, live in a specific place with historical, cultural, and political features. These particular features are constitutive of the individual’s identity, not mere additions to a “pure” abstract and universal subject. If this subject indeed exists at all beyond its function as a theoretical hypothesis, it expresses only one dimension of the actual self that is not interchangeable with the person. Descartes’ “thinking self” is thus but one possibility of the individual’s existence as a concrete being, who emerges through a process involving an ongoing dialogue with others, with history, and with culture. This book aims to expose this process and describe its various aspects and implications. My concern is with manifestations of concrete identity and I have chosen to focus on the identity of people who are Jews, though Jewish identity serves here as a case study for a discussion of identity in general. The book is divided into two parts. Part One provides the conceptual framework. Chapter One deals with alternative definitions of identity, and Chapters Two and Three gradually shift from the general construct to the actual context of Jewish identity, including an analysis of the traditional identity discourse represented by Hegelian tradition. Chapters Four to Six in Part Two focus on Israel, reflecting various dimensions of its tense identity discourse—the conflict resulting from
viii Preface the blurred distinction between a discourse of identity and a discourse of rights in Chapter Four, and from the displacement of the identity discourse to the political terms of the religion and state relationship in Chapter Five. Chapter Six focuses on the meaning of the political- geographic realm in the constitution of Jewish identity and, specifically, on the role of the Land of Israel as it plays out in biblical tradition.
Part One
My concern here is the discourse on identity. This chapter is thus a reflective, critical account of the prevalent modes of thinking about identity, specifically in the philosophical literature, mapping out the field of discourse with an emphasis on its poles. On one pole is the essentialist discourse, which views identity as “something” found “there” in reality and independent of people as historical-cultural creatures. Identity is already given and people must find it. The identity discourse, then, follows in the wake of the past and returns to it. On the other pole is the approach that views identity as a cultural project of self-molding and self-creativity. Identity emerges through a complex historical, cultural, and political process, shaped more by the future than by the past, and the field of the identity discourse is realized along the time axis. Whereas the essentialist conception of identity is ancient, the other was born during modernity. Giovanni Pico della Mirandola lived in the fifteenth century and was among the first to suggest that the essence of being human is to be undefined, emphasizing that God, through direct speech, imposes on humans the duty of self-creation: We have given you, Adam, no fixed seat or form of your own, no talent peculiar to you alone. This we have done so that whatever seat, whatever form, whatever talent you may judge desirable, these same may you have and possess according to your desire and judgment . . . . We have made you neither of heaven nor of earth, neither mortal nor immortal, so that you may, as the free and extraordinary shaper of yourself, fashion yourself in whatever form you prefer.1 Pico della Mirandolla’s stance sharply conveys the transition between the old and the new. He speaks in the old language of essences, but argues that the human essence is defined by its emptiness. Rather than being a finished creature whose identity merely awaits discovery, humans find their dignity in being “chameleons,”2 meaning creatures who often change and 1 Giovanni Pico della Mirandola, Oration on the Dignity of Man: A New Translation and Commentary, ed. Francesco Borghesi, Michael Papio, and Massimo Riva (Cambridge: Cambrige University Press, 2012), 117.