The Unique Judicial Vision of Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk. Selected Discourses in Meshekh Hokhmah and Or Sameah
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Cohen Yitshak
Под ред.:
Basser Herbert W.
Год издания: 2016
Кол-во страниц: 188
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-490-7
Артикул: 694245.02.99
This book analyzes the exceptional normative impact of R. Meir Simcha Hacohen’s Biblical commentary, Meshekh Hokhmah, and his halakhic commentary, Or Sameah. It examines the reliance of the poskim on R. Meir Simcha’s innovations and hermeneutic methods as well as their view of his interpretations that broadened or narrowed the scope of Maimonides’ rulings. The book explores the broad-based judicial principles underlying R. Meir Simcha’s legal decisions and approach to Jewish law. It further examines how his legal creativity was impacted by metahalakhic principles that guided him in addressing changing historical and social realities. The book also considers R. Meir Simcha’s unique attitudes toward gentiles. His approach attests to his innovativeness and his halakhic moderation, as he tried to rule as leniently as possible on matters concerning non-Jews. In this book, R. Meir Simcha is shown to be a truly influential rabbi whose contributions will long be a source of study and discussion.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
THE UNIQUE JUDICIAL VISION of RABBI MEIR SIMCHA of DVINSK Selected Discourses in Meshekh Hokhmah and Or Sameah
New York YITSHAK COHEN Translated by Meshulam Gotlieb Edited by Herbert Basser THE UNIQUE JUDICIAL VISION of RABBI MEIR SIMCHA of DVINSK Selected Discourses in Meshekh Hokhmah and Or Sameah
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. ISBN 978-1-61811-489-1 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-61811-490-7 (electronic) ©Touro College Press, 2016 Published by Touro College Press and Academic Studies Press. Typeset, printed and distributed by Academic Studies Press. Cover design by Ivan Grave Touro College Press Michael A. Shmidman and Simcha Fishbane, Editors 27 West 23rd Street New York, NY 10010 USA www.touro.edu/news/publications/touro-college-press/ Academic Studies Press 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135 USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
To our dearly beloved children Efrat, Tamar, Naama, Gilad, Ariel and Hila
Table of Contents Acknowledgments ix xi Chapter 1: Midrashic Technique and Legal Creativity in the Meshekh Hokhmah 1 Introduction 1 1. R. Meir Simcha and the Use of Midrashic Technique to Develop the Law 3 a. Traditional Reluctance to Use Midrashic Technique to Develop the Law 3 b. R. Meir Simcha’s Pioneering Adoption of Midrashic Technique to Develop the Law 5 2. Rejection of R. Meir Simcha’s Rulings Based on Midrashic Technique 6 a. One Who Kills Someone in the Throes of Death 6 b. The Amalekite Proselyte 9 c. Exhuming and Moving a Corpse 10 d. Self-Endangerment to Save the Nation 16 e. Concluding Remarks 21 3. Acceptance of R. Meir Simcha’s Exegesis-Based Rulings 22 a. The Prohibition against Rebuilding Jericho 22 b. Inheriting Property from a Relative One Has Murdered 25 c. Bathsheba and Uriah the Hittite—Conditional Divorce 27 d. The “If Two Perform It” Exemption 29 4. The Normative Intent of R. Meir Simcha’s Exegesis-Based Legal Creativity 30 a. The Prohibition against Abortion: Biblical or Rabbinic? 30 b. Acts Carried Out by One Who Is Inebriated 32 5. Gilat’s Assessment of R. Meir Simcha’s Intent 35 a. Marrying a “Beautiful Captive” 35 b. Stealing from Outside the Owner’s Domain 36
vii 6. Supportive Midrashic Exegesis a. Children of a Convert 37 b. Sanctity of the Temple Mount 38 Conclusion 41 Chapter 2: The Rabbinic Decisors and the Halakhic Material in Or Sameah 44 Introduction 44 1. Expanding Maimonides’ Ruling 45 a. A Pursuer Who Kills by Gerama 45 b. Disabling a Mechanical Heart 46 2. Supplementing Maimonides’ Ruling by Adding One Detail 48 a. The Pursuer 48 b. One Who Murders a Person in His Death Throes 49 c. Saving the Entire Nation of Israel 51 3. Transforming Legal Ground 54 a. One Who Takes His Ex-Wife Back: From Prohibition to Remorse 54 b. Laws of Jealousy and Seclusion: Textual-Criticism Approaches 58 c. Laws of Jealousy and Seclusion According to the Received Text 62 4. The Rabbinic Decisors and R. Meir Simcha’s Refinement of Mishneh Torah 65 a. Acquisition via One’s Movable Property 66 b. Gerama and Garmei in Tort Law 69 c. Tosefet Ketubah When the Woman Petitions for Divorce 73 Conclusion 76 Chapter 3: Metahalakhic Principles in R. Meir Simcha’s Oeuvre 79 1. Taking Human Nature into Account 79 a. Preventing the Salvation of the Entire Nation of Israel 81 b. Is an Individual Obligated to Risk a Limb in Order to Save Another’s Life? 82 c. The Reason Women Are Exempted from the Precept to Procreate 83 d. Should a Minor Exempt Her Co-Wives from Levirate Marriage? 85 e. Coercing Someone into Observing Religious Norms 87 f. We Do Not Force an Individual to Circumcise Himself 88 g. May One Who is not a High Priest Allow Himself to Become Ritually Impure? 90 2. Dealing Stringently with Changing or Deviating from Societal Norms 94 a. A Woman Who Calls Off an Engagement to Marry 95 b. Tortfeasor: Paying According to the Time of Damage 96 c. One Who Steals from a Thief 97 Table of Contents
viii 3. Is Intention or Action the Determining Factor? a. Adjudicating the Laws of Sabbath 99 b. Adjudicating the Laws of the Four Species Based on the Action Taken 104 c. One Who Digs Pits, Ditches, and Caves for the Purpose of Idolatry 107 d. Conditions Pertaining to the Wedding Canopy and Betrothal 108 e. Providing a Post Facto Rationale When Action Was Already Taken 110 f. Do a Minor’s Actions Testify to His State of Mind? 111 g. Halitsah 116 Conclusion 118 Chapter 4: Rabbi Meir Simcha and His Attitude toward Gentiles 120 Introduction 120 1. Religion and Commandments versus Commerce and Negotiation 121 a. Prohibition against Usury: No Agency for Gentiles 121 b. Execution Based on the Testimony of a Single Witness 125 c. Lien on the Body of a Jew and Lien on Assets Possessed by a Gentile 127 2. Rulings that May Bring Jews and Gentiles Closer 133 a. Giving Gifts to a Gentile and Teaching Him Torah 133 b. A Gift Given by a Gentile 136 c. Increased Quantities by Gentiles 139 d. Gentile Kings 141 e. Applying the Law of Orlah to Trees Planted by Gentiles 143 f. A Gentile Writing a Torah Scroll 145 3. Distinction between the Laws of Gentiles and Jews 147 a. Robbing a Gentile and the Commandment to Restore to the Gentile 147 b. May One Who Contracted a Loan Collect from the Gentile’s Purchaser? 150 c. Which Commandments Are Bnei Noah Executed for? 153 4. The Halakhic Attitude toward Gentiles in Meshekh Hokhmah 155 a. Martyrdom (Dying to Sanctify God’s Name): Is a Ben Noah Allowed to Martyr Himself? 155 b. Relations between the Proselyte and His Biological Family 156 Conclusion 158 Index 160 Index of Sources 167 Table of Contents
Acknowledgments This book examines the teachings of Rabbi Meir Simcha Hakohen of Dvinsk, author of the books Or Sameah and Meshekh Hokhmah. Despite Rabbi Meir Simcha’s true genius and tremendous creativity, which spanned several disciplines, his work has not yet received the attention it deserves. I trust that this book will partially fill this lacuna. This book first took shape as a doctoral dissertation submitted to the Senate of Bar-Ilan University in May 2005. I wish to take this opportunity to thank several of my teachers and mentors. First, I must express my profound gratitude to Professor Berachyahu Lifshitz, who supervised my doctoral dissertation and advised me on the articles I wrote that followed it. Over the last decade, he has always made himself available and given me helpful, productive advice. His kindness and humility, accompanied by his broad general knowledge and many scholarly areas of expertise, were of tremendous help to me. I would also like to thank Professor Yedidia Stern for his steadfast and devoted guidance and for granting me the President’s Scholarship for Outstanding Doctoral Students. I am grateful to my mentors at the Institute for Advanced Torah Studies, Bar-Ilan University, and to my rabbi, Rabbi Aaron Katz. For many years, I was privileged to study with Rabbi Katz and learn from his leadership skills. I must also thank Rabbi Moshe Raziel, who was the head of the Institute when I studied for my undergraduate and master’s degrees. During my years at Bar-Ilan University, the institute was my second home, the place where the Torah came alive for me. I cannot adequately describe its crucial impact on my life. In this vein, I must also gratefully acknowledge
x Acknowledgments my rabbis and teachers at Yeshivat Shaalvim, who first introduced me to high-level Torah study and taught me to love the Torah. For approximately ten years, I have been a faculty member at Ono Academic College, an institute that has become both a warm and supportive home for me. The college is making breakthroughs in Israeli society; I am both privileged and excited to be a part of these developments. I thank Mr. Ranan Hartman, founder and chairman of Ono Academic College, for his personal guidance; Professor Dudi Schwartz, Rector of Ono Academic College, to whom I owe most of my academic development; Law School Dean, Professor Amichai Cohen and Dr. Rivi Cohen, the Dean of Students, whose administrative talents have enabled me to dedicate a significant amount of my time to research. The gratitude that I owe my parents and parents-in-law is immeasurable. With genuine love, I wish to bless my parents, Mordecai and Esther, for their boundless dedication and self-sacrifice that instilled in me a love of learning and the awe of Heaven. Likewise, I wish to offer my heartfelt blessings to my in-laws, Nehemiah and Rachel Stern, and I wish to thank them for their assistance and for remaining by our side throughout the years. May the Lord grant my parents and in-laws many years of health and happiness. Last, but not least, I must thank my immediate family: my wife Shuli, my earthly partner, for her great faith in me, her neverending encouragement, and her tireless devotion to the education of our dear children—Efrat, Tamar, Naama, Gilad, Ariel and Hila; and to my children, who gave up their time with me so that I could devote it to the publication of this book. To them, I dedicate this book with great love. Words cannot express my gratitude to the Creator of the World for all the goodness that He has bestowed upon me. I humbly ask that He continue to enable me to study His Torah and to lead our family on the path of righteousness, and that He bestow upon myself and my family His grace and blessings. May the Torah remain in my mouth and in the mouths of my offspring in perpetuity. “May the words of my mouth and the meditation of my heart be acceptable in Thy sight” (Psalms 19: 15).