Music, Society, Agency
Покупка
Тематика:
Теория и история музыки. Музыковедение
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Под ред.:
November Nancy
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 262
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
ВО - Специалитет
ISBN: 979-8-88719-395-3
Артикул: 872496.01.99
Musicologists have increasingly taken a wide-angled lens on the study of music in society, to explore how it can be intertwined with issues of politics, gender, religion, race, psychology, memory, and space. Recent studies of music in connection with society take in a variety of musical phenomena from diverse periods and genres — medieval, classical, opera, rock, etc. This ten-chapter book not only asks how music and society are, and have been, intertwined and mutually influential, but it also examines the agents behind these connections: who determines musical cultures in society? Which social groups are represented in particular musical contexts? Which social groups are silenced or less well represented in music’s histories, and why?
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
MUSIC, SOCIETY, AGENCY
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 E d i t e d by MUSIC, SOCIETY, AGENCY
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: November, Nancy, editor. Title: Music, society, agency / edited by Nancy November. Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2023. | Series: Studies in the History and Sociology of Music | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2023041419 (print) | LCCN 2023041420 (ebook) | ISBN 9798887193946 (hardback) | ISBN 9798887193953 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9798887193960 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Music—Social aspects. | Agent (Philosophy) | Music—Performance—Social aspects. Classification: LCC ML3916 .M87825 2023 (print) | LCC ML3916 (ebook) | DDC 306.4/842—dc23/eng/20230922 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2023041419 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2023041420 ISBN 9798887193946 (hardback) ISBN 9798887193953 (adobe pdf) ISBN 9798887193960 (epub) Copyright © 2023 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved Book design by Tatiana Vernikov Cover design by Ivan Grave On the cover: Takū’s clan elders and purotu performance specialists (1970s). Photographer unknown Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www academicstudiespress.com
Contents Introduction Nancy November Part One: Cultural and Cross-Cultural Agencies The Year the Music Died: Agency in the Context 14 of Demise on Takū, Papua New Guinea Richard Moyle His Majesty’s Theatre: A Hub of Musical 35 and Theatrical Entertainment in Colonial Dunedin Sandra Crawshaw “In the Tiki Tiki Tiki Tiki Tiki Room”: 55 Musicalizing the South Pacific in Disney’s Theme Parks Gregory Camp Part Two: Vocal Music’s Agencies Figaro Transmuted through the Agency of Neapolitan Social 74 and Political Creatives: Niccolò Piccinni’s La serva onorata Lawrence Mays Josephinism and Leopold Koželuh’s Masonic Cantata 113 Joseph der Menschheit Segen Allan Badley Agency, Politics, and Opera Arrangements 136 in Fanny von Arnstein’s Salons Nancy November
Part Three: Performance and Agency Reflections on Aladdin’s Lamp: Creative Practice Research in-and-through Historically Informed Performance Imogen Morris When Your Heart is Set on Both Broadway and the Met: 174 An Exploration of Vocal Technique in Contemporary Musical Theatre Christopher McRae Part Four: Composition and Agency Ratner's Topoi and the Cultural Middlebrow 200 in Britten’s First Suite for Cello Eliana Dunford Provincializing Practice: Agency and Positionality 222 in Cross-Cultural Music in Aotearoa New Zealand Celeste Oram Contributors 247 Index 250
Introduction Musicologists have increasingly used a wide-angled lens to study of music in society and explore how it is intertwined with issues of politics, gender, religion, race, psychology, memory, and space. Recent studies of music in connection with society take in a variety of musical phenomena from diverse periods and genres—medieval, classical, opera, rock, and so on. This book not only asks how music and society are, and have been, intertwined and mutually influential, but also examines the agents behind these connections: who determines musical cultures in society? Which social groups are represented in particular musical contexts? Which social groups are silenced or less well represented in music’s histories, and why? This volume arose from a conference of the same title, a meeting of the New Zealand Musicological Society, which was held in Auckland, New Zealand in July 2020. Thus there is a strong emphasis on the Pacific. Its four parts explore, in order, cultural and cross-cultural agencies, agencies within vocal music, performance and agency, and agency regarding composition. Part one, concerning cultural and cross-cultural agencies, is devoted to the Pacific. The first chapter, “The Year the Music Died,” documents agency in the context of the diminution over two generations of almost an entire musical culture among the atoll community on Takū in Papua New Guinea. The author, Richard Moyle, has been involved with the community since 1994. In that time Takū has changed from a vibrant island community of 600 people, who sing and dance both contemporary and ancient creations for on average twenty hours each week, to a remnant of 150 residents, occasionally performing mostly imported material. Moyle charts the change from hundreds of locally composed songs boasting of fishing success to a small repertoire of love songs in another language; from long songs acknowledging the presence of ancestors and their help in everyday activities to short dance songs, highly repetitive in both lyrics and movements; from graveside songs forewarning spirits of the imminent arrival of a dead resident in the afterworld to songs asking an ancient foreign deity to comfort the living. He considers how aesthetics and networks of social relationships help define how Takū shape and sustain musical standards, and how they categorize themselves in various sacred and secular circumstances, in and
I n t r o d u c t i o n outside the island’s ritual arena. Such agency gradually brought about changes in the performing arts and society itself. Using contemporary newspapers and ephemera collections, Sandra Crawshaw explores the agents responsible for building up His Majesty’s Theatre in Dunedin, New Zealand, as a major cultural institution in the early part of the twentieth century and “one of the finest and best-appointed theatres in the colonies.” Until John Mansfield Thomson’s The Oxford History of New Zealand Music was published in 1991, very little had been written about the early days of New Zealand’s musical culture. With an “overseas is better” attitude, New Zealanders’ agency within music history was often overlooked. In recent years, research has revealed that the cultural and musical life in New Zealand from colonial times onwards was a lot richer and more varied than was previously believed. Many recent studies have focused upon institutions such as New Zealand’s national and regional orchestras, chamber music societies, and choral and opera activities, telling fascinating stories of their struggles to become established. His Majesty’s Theatre had its beginnings in the agricultural sector, starting life in 1896 as the Agricultural Hall. Funded privately by a group of businessmen and gentlemen farmers, who then took a gamble on the vision of entrepreneur J. C. Williamson, the hall was lavishly refurbished and renamed in 1902. Williamson’s wealth and innate business sense gave him influence over what New Zealand audiences came to see, and the new, up-to-date His Majesty’s Theatre extended his reach. The theme of who gets to speak on behalf of a culture is taken up in Gregory Camp’s “‘In the Tiki Tiki Tiki Tiki Tiki Room: Musicalizing the South Pacific in Disney’s Theme Parks.” The Walt Disney Company has frequently used the South Pacific as a setting for its various films, television shows, and theme parks. Its use of music in these texts marks the company’s attitude (and the attitude they construct for their global audiences) towards the region. Camp examines Disney’s construction of South Pacific music in its theme parks as a reflection of the societies in which they operate. In the 1950s and ’60s Disney capitalized on the Tiki craze of the time by designing Disneyland’s Adventureland largely around American ideas of the “exotic” South Pacific and its music, with attractions ranging from the mostly fictitious version of Pacific music heard in the Enchanted Tiki Room to the somewhat more authentic constructions in the Tahitian Terrace restaurant’s floor show (and, later, the similar luau show at Walt Disney World’s Polynesian Village Resort). While in more recent Disney films such as Lilo & Stitch (2002) and Moana (2016) the company has attempted to convey a Pacific soundscape grounded in local musics, giving agency to the
I n t r o d u c t i o n people whose stories are told, the theme parks have largely retained their midcentury exoticism. This disconnect between the parks and the films shows this massive multinational corporation caught between nostalgia for ’50s pop culture and a desire for authenticity, trying to speak and sing both to and for people in multiple societies around the world. Part 2 shifts attention from the Pacific to Europe and from the twentieth century to the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. In “Figaro Transmuted through the Agency of Neapolitan Creatives: Niccolò Piccinni’s La serva onorata,” Lawrence Mays discusses how Giambattista Lorenzi and composer Niccolò Piccinni exerted agency. The libretto for La serva onorata, premiered in Naples in 1792, is a substantially reworked version of Lorenzo Da Ponte’s Le nozze di Figaro, which premiered in Vienna in 1786. The Neapolitan king and queen had much contact with Da Ponte in Vienna, and it is likely that they offered his libretto to a local theatre. Lorenzi’s engagement to recast the imported text was consistent with the preference of impresarios to employ librettists who knew Neapolitan taste, customs, and dialect. Influences on the authors’ creative choices included the expectations of theatre management, performers, and audiences. Although Lorenzi’s libretto draws heavily on Da Ponte’s, with many points of concurrence and some nearly identical wording, new elements are added and the overall tone is more farcical and at times vulgar, consistent with local preference. Piccinni demonstrates his ability to meld eclectic influences within a circumscribed environment. Mays explores how the librettist and composer, both in the final phases of successful careers, translated a known opera for a particular theatrical milieu. Its enthusiastic reception in Naples was a testament to their artistic choices under various constraints and influences. Allan Badley takes the setting to Vienna with his “Leopold Koželuh’s Masonic Cantata Joseph der Menschheit Segen and Josephinism,” which discusses how freemasonry affected agency. On 1 September 1783, Koželuh’s Joseph der Menschheit Segen was performed in Vienna for the first and possibly only time in a ceremony of thanksgiving organized by the Zu den drei Adlern, Zur gekrönten Hoffnung, and Zur Beständigkeit lodges. The early 1780s was a golden age for freemasonry in Vienna. Initially Emperor Joseph II approved of the many practical ways in which the craft involved itself in the education and welfare of the poor. But by 1785 he had become sufficiently alarmed by the rapid growth of freemasonry throughout the Habsburg lands to publish a patent that demanded its radical reorganization; this led to a sharp decline in lodge membership during the late 1780s and increasing suspicion of the movement in general after the outbreak of the French Revolution. This chapter considers Joseph der Menschheit
I n t r o d u c t i o n Segen in the context of Habsburg imperial politics of the 1780s and their impact on society, and also examines the incorporation of masonic symbolism in both Leopold Föderl’s libretto and Koželuh’s score. The composer’s arrangement of the work for voices and fortepiano, published in Vienna by Torricella in December 1784, took the work to a wider public, and its handsomely engraved title page includes many masonic symbols that even non-masons would have recognized. To what extent Koželuh endorsed the sentiments expressed in the work is unknown, but the care with which he treated certain aspects of masonic symbolism suggests that he was sincere in his commitment to the craft, and belief in its value as an agent of societal change. Arrangements of musical works offer a fascinating field for exploring matters of agency within musical culture. Nancy November’s chapter “Agency, Politics, and Opera Arrangements in Fanny Arnstein’s Salons” stays within the context of Vienna but now in the early nineteenth century, when arrangements of public music flourished in great variety in that city. She asks: what does this culture of musical arrangements tell us about shifting musical and social values and agency in this period, especially as they concern women? Focusing on Fanny von Arnstein in particular, she considers how arrangements offered amateurs agency in terms of education, entertainment, and sociability in the home, and a bridge to public music-making. This was particularly valuable to female amateurs, who otherwise had little say or share in the public spheres of composition, criticism, and orchestral performance. Even when it seemed to offer sheer entertainment or straightforward escapism, private sphere music-making also helped to define musicians’ sense of freedom—a freedom of choice regarding what they heard, where they heard it, and how. Here we can already speak of a cultivation of agency, understood as simple autonomy; but arrangements could also assist those who otherwise had no “voice” in the public sphere with talking politics. The chapter zooms in on a salon hosted by Arnstein in which the programming choices, as well as the performance of arrangements, spoke subtly against the politics of Emperor Francis I, implying a perception of him a tyrannical dictator. Part 3 moves to the topic of performance and agency. Anner Bylsma described the interpretative process used in Historically Informed Performance (HIP) as “Aladdin rubbing his lamp”: serendipitous discovery with little to do with historical correctness. In “Reflections on Aladdin’s Lamp: Creative Practice Research in-and-through Historically Informed Performance,” Imogen Morris explores this process further, with the goal of developing a theoretical framework for conducting Creative Practice Research (CPR)