Collected Studies. Volume 4
Покупка
Тематика:
История медицины
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Shatzmiller Joseph
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 201
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 979-8-88719-376-2
Артикул: 872495.01.99
In Collected Studies (Volume 4): Jews in the Medical Profession, Joseph Shatzmiller, the prominent scholar of Provence Jewry, presents a fascinating glimpse into the world of Jewish doctors and medicine in medieval Western Europe. Drawing on a wealth of archival sources and intellectual history, Shatzmiller delves into the lives and experiences of Jewish physicians who played a crucial role in the medical profession during the Middle Ages. From their scientific collaborations with Christian colleagues to their role as leaders within the Jewish community, this book provides a rich portrait of the complex and dynamic world of medieval medicine. The book covers topics such as the Jewish students in the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Montpellier, Jewish women in medicine, doctors’ salaries, pharmacology, and medical books. With its insightful analysis and meticulous research, Jews in the Medical Profession is a valuable contribution to the history of medicine and Jewish studies.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Collected Studies Joseph Shatzmiller
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 Collected Studies Joseph Shatzmiller Jews in the Medical Profession V o l u m e 4
Library of Congress Control Number: 2023944590 9798887193724 (hardback) 9798887193762 (ebook PDF) 9798887193809 (ePub) Copyright © 2023, Academic Studies Press, collection Book design by Lapiz Digital Services with Cover desig by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com “In his book Jews in the Medical Profession, Joseph Shatzmiller, the prominent scholar of Provence Jewry, presents a fascinating glimpse into the world of Jewish doctors and medicine in medieval Western Europe. Drawing on a wealth of archival sources and intellectual history, Shatzmiller delves into the lives and experiences of Jewish physicians who played a crucial role in the medical profession during the Middle Ages. From their scientific collaborations with Christian colleagues to their role as leaders within the Jewish community, this book provides a rich portrait of the complex and dynamic world of medieval medicine. The book covers topics such as the Jewish students in the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Montpellier, Jewish women in medicine, doctors’ salaries, pharmacology, and medical books. With its insightful analysis and meticulous research, Jews in the Medical Profession is a valuable contribution to the history of medicine and Jewish studies.” — Ram Ben-Shalom, Professor of the History of the Jewish People, Hebrew University of Jerusalem; author of The Jews of Provence and Languedoc
Contents Vol. Four: Jews in the Medical Profession I The Making of Jewish Doctors 1 1 On Becoming a Jewish Doctor in the High Middle Ages 3 2 Apprenticeship or Academic Education: The Making of Jewish Doctors 13 3 Livres médicaux et éducation médicale: à propos d’un contrat de Marseille en 1316 22 II Attending the Medieval University 31 1 Un cercle de savants de Montpellier vers 1300: Contacts et Échanges entre erudits juifs et chretiens 33 2 Étudiants juifs à la faculté de médecine de Montpellier, dernier quart du XIVe siècle 39 3 La faculté de médecine de Montpellier et son influence en Provence: Témoignages en hébreu, en latin et en langue vulgaire 53 III Activity North and South 57 1 Notes sur les médecins juifs en Provence au Moyen Âge 59 2 Médecins municipaux en Provence, Catalogne et autres régions de l’Europe méridionale (1350–1400) 68 3 Jewish Physicians in Sicily 78 4 Doctors and Medical Practice in Germany around the Year 1200: The Evidence of Sefer Hasidim 85 5 Doctors and Medical Practices in Germany around the Year 1200: The Evidence of Sefer Asaph 97 IV The Medicalization of Society 111 1 Femmes médecins au Moyen Âge: Témoignages sur leurs pratiques (1250–1350) 113 2 Doctors’ Fees and Their Medical Responsibility: Evidence from Notarial and Court Records 122
vi J o s e p h S h a t z m i l l e r : C o l l e c t e d S t u d i e s Médecins et expertise médicale dans la ville médiévale: Manosque 1280–1348 130 4 The Jurisprudence of the Dead Body: Medical Practitioners at the Service of Civic and Legal Authorities 142 V The Range of Medical Services 151 1 Médecine et gynécologie au Moyen-Âge: un exemple provençal 153 2 Soigner le corps souffrant: Pratiques médicales au tournant du XIVe siècle 161 3 Soins de beauté, image et image de soi: le cas des juifs du Moyen Âge 169 4 Herbes et drogues dans la médecine provençale du Moyen Âge 178 5 Roger Bacon’s Critique of the Pharmaceutics of His Day 186 VI References to Previous Publications of the Chapters 193
T H E M A KI NG O F J E W I SH D O CTO R S I
On Becoming a Jewish Doctor in the High Middle Ages1 The involvement of many hundreds, indeed thousands, of Jews in the medical profession during the Middle Ages is recognized by many modern observers as an outstanding feature of the social and intellectual history of the time. So profound and continuous was their commitment to the profession then, that some of us today even go to the extreme and see a medical doctor in almost every medieval Jewish scholar. While we all should, naturally, be advised not to draw hasty conclusions, we should, in my opinion, encourage one another to further study the reasons for this relationship between Jews and medicine, its patterns, and no less, its significance for their political, economic and of course intellectual destiny. In this present inquiry, however, I propose to focus on two rather technical issues: where did the doctors acquire their medical education and how did they formally become part of the profession? Let me start with the second issue. In southern Europe, in the High Middle Ages, an individual was unable to engage in medical practice just because he decided to do so. By 1250 the medical profession was already so structured and so well regulated in the regions of Italy, southern France and Spain, that whoever felt he was well prepared to 1 Thanks are extended to the Hannah Institute for the History of Medicine for the support given to this study.
engage in the profession first had to pass examinations and to obtain a license, (licentia practicandi as it was generally called, or licentia curandi et practicandi) from the right authorities. An unlicensed practitioner would be considered as “empiricist” in the sense of a “charlatan” and would have to answer to the court for his medical activities. Civil authorities were quite adamant on this point and did not mince words in order to make their policy clear to all those concerned. The Angevines of Naples, who governed areas where medicine and law were particularly developed, left abundant data in their archives about theories and practices of their licensing policy. In the statutes of Charles II of Provence, issued on July 12, 1296, the royal policy is thus formulated:2 “We forbid anyone, of whatever condition or status he be, to dare practice medicine or surgery, unless his expertise and fitness in the area are beforehand established.” A decree to the same effect, restating a previous law, was issued in Montpellier on July 20, 1272,3 while the old municipal laws of Arles which go back to the years around 1200 already included the following warning:4 “No doctor who comes to this city from abroad to practice medicine or surgery, will be able to practice in this city unless beforehand examined by a doctor and a surgeon.” Identical legislation was also passed in Spain: we find it as part of the decisions of various courts of Aragon, such as the one in Monzon in 1289, in Cervera in 1359 and that of Monzon again in 1363.5 That such legislation did not remain a “dead letter of the Law”, can be seen by fines that were levied upon individuals who were caught practicing without authorization. In Bayonne near Talard, on the northern border of Provence, we have the case of a Jewish lady, Marrona, who was practicing “sine licentia” and “without having been authorized by those who 2 Ch. Giraud, Essai sur l’histoire du droit français au Moyen Age, Vol. 2 (Paris, 1846), p. 49. Prohibemus, ne quis, cujuscunque conditionis aut status sit, in medicine aut cirugia practicare presumat, nisi prius de ipsius fide et legalitate in curia nostra testimonio sufficienti perhabito, in eadem curia, ad cuius officium spectare consetur, de suae artis peritia, idoneus approbetur. Practicantes autem contra preasentis nostrae prohibitionis it determinationis edictum poenam quinquaginta librarum turonensium fore sanximus nostro aererio applicandam. 3 J. Régné, History of the Jews in Aragon (Jerusalem, 1978), p. 46 (no. 525); A. Germain, Cartulaire de l’université de Montpellier, Vol. 1 (Montpellier, 1890), pp. 202–203. …illorum audaciam reprimamus, qui presumunt ibidem sine examin(atione) et licentia practicare, per quod non solum nomen et fama ejusdem studii denigratur, sed et multa incumbunt mortis pericule et rerum dispendia interuntur. Et… prohibemus in perpetuum et districte omnibus utriusque sexus, Christianis et Judeis ne quis in villa Montispessulani et tota ejus dominatione audeat in Facultate Medicine aliquod officium practicandi exercere, nisi prius ibi examinatus et licentiatis fuerit. 4 Ch. Giraud, Essais sur l’histoire etc., p. 49. infirmo vel amicis infimi. Et nullus medicus extraneus qui veniat in hac villa operari de fiscia vel cirologia non possit operari in hac villa nisi primitus fuerit per unum fisicum vel unum chirurgum examinatus. 5 C. Roth, “The Qualifications of Jewish Physicians in the Middle Ages”, Speculum 28 (1958): 834–843, especially p. 839.