Collected Studies. Volume 2
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Shatzmiller Joseph
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 233
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 979-8-88719-374-8
Артикул: 872493.01.99
In Collected Studies (Volume 2): Christian Majority — Jewish Minority, Joseph Shatzmiller, the preeminent scholar of the Jews in Provence, examines the complex relationship between Christians and Jews during the Middle Ages. Through a careful analysis of historical documents and primary sources, Shatzmiller sheds light on the diverse experiences of the Jewish minority in Provence, from their legal status in Christian courts to the persecution and violence they faced during times of crisis. This book provides a nuanced understanding of the relationship between Christians and Jews in medieval Western Europe, and the role of the Jewish community in shaping the social and political landscape of the region.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Collected Studies Joseph Shatzmiller
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 Collected Studies Joseph Shatzmiller Christian Majority— Jewish Minority V o l u m e 2
Library of Congress Control Number: 2023944590 9798887193700 (hardback) 9798887193748 (ebook PDF) 9798887193786 (ePub) Copyright © 2023, Academic Studies Press, collection Book design by Lapiz Digital Services with Cover desig by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com “In Christian Majority—Jewish Minority, Joseph Shatzmiller, the preeminent scholar of the Jews in Provence, examines the complex relationship between Christians and Jews during the Middle Ages. Through a careful analysis of historical documents and primary sources, Shatzmiller sheds light on the diverse experiences of the Jewish minority in Provence, from their legal status in Christian courts to the persecution and violence they faced during times of crisis. This book provides a nuanced understanding of the relationship between Christians and Jews in medieval Western Europe, and the role of the Jewish community in shaping the social and political landscape of the region.” — Ram Ben-Shalom, Professor of the History of the Jewish People, Hebrew University of Jerusalem; author of The Jews of Provence and Languedoc
Contents Vol. Two: Christian Majority—Jewish Minority I Under One Roof 1 1. The Papal Monarchy as Viewed by Medieval Jews 3 2. Terminologie politique en hébreu médiéval: Jalons pour un glossaire 14 3. L’anthroponomie dans le monde juif 23 II Jurisprudence and Legal Practice 33 1. Droit féodal et législation rabbinique: la cuisson du pain chez les juifs au Moyen Âge 35 2. הליכתם של יהודים לערכאות של גויים בפרובאנס בימי הביניים (Jews in the Christian Courts of Provence in the Middle Ages) 43 3. Jews “Separated from the Communion of the Faithful in Christ” in the Middle Ages 50 4. Christian “Excommunication” of Jews: Some Further Clarifications 59 III Quests for Holy Shrines 69 1. Jews, Pilgrimage, and the Christian Cult of Saints: Benjamin of Tudela and his Contemporaries 71 2. In Search of a ‘Jewish Compostela’: Benjamin of Tudela and Petrachia of Regensburg 83 IV Hostility and Persecutions 95 1. L’inquisition et les juifs de Provence au XIIIe siecle 97 2. Church Articles: Pawns in the Hands of Jewish Moneylenders 108 3. Les juifs de Provence pendant la peste noire 119
vi 4. מגילוייה של האנטישמיות בימי־הביניים׃ האשמת יהודים בחילול הצלב (Desecrating the Holy Cross: A Rare Medieval Accusation) 146 5. Profaner la Sainte-Croix: une rare accusation anti-juive au Moyen Âge 159 V Converts: Church Vs. State 167 1. Jewish Converts to Christianity in Medieval Europe, 1200–1500 169 2. Converts and Judaizers in the Early Fourteenth Century 188 3. Paulus Christiani: Un aspect de son activité anti-juive 201 4. האם העליל המומר ניקולאס דונין ?את עלילת־הדם (Did Nicholas Donin Promulgate the Blood Libel?) 217 VI References to Previous Publications of the Chapters 225 J o s e p h S h a t z m i l l e r : C o l l e c t e d S t u d i e s
UN D ER ONE RO O F I
The Papal Monarchy as Viewed by Medieval Jews Let me start by justifying my participation in this encounter of “Italia Judaica.” As it happens, I know very little about the Papal state in the sixteenth century, about the life of Jews within its borders, or about the establishment of the ghetto. If I dare, nevertheless, to take a precious thirty minutes of your time, it is because Italy was not the only region in Europe which had a Papal state. During most of the fourteenth century, when people referred to the “Roman Curia”, they did not have in mind the eternal city but rather a smaller one, Avignon, situated in the South of France, in the Rhone Valley. I have in mind, of course, the Comtat Venaissin, which was a Papal holding (Avignon would be purchased from the Queen of Naples in 1348). There, around the year 1321, when Pope John XXII occupied the Holy See, a partial expulsion of Jews took place. At exactly the same time the Jews of Rome were themselves facing the threat of expulsion. Examining the scanty information that we have about this strange event will permit me, I hope, to uncover elements concerning the manner in which medieval Jews regarded the Papacy and, most importantly, the political expectations they nurtured — rightly or wrongly — regarding the Apostolic See. Hebrew terminology is of much significance in this respect. To designate the Pope, medieval Jews used to employ the Talmudic term Apifior, as we do nowadays. But they also used (and this is less frequent in our medieval
documents and utterly suppressed today) the term “king” (Melech) when referring to the Lieutenant of St. Peter. Thus in 1372, the Jewish community of Avignon had good news to share with the community of Perugia concerning privileges obtained from the Pope1. Gregory XI is not mentioned by name, neither is he called Apifior but rather “King of the Gentile” (Melech ha-Goyim). When, some thirty or forty years earlier, the success of Gersonides at the court of Avignon is referred to by a fellow rabbi, the Pontiff is described as “The Great King” (ha-Melech ha-Gadot)2. A vivid, yet quite imaginary picture of the Papacy in Rome is given by a thirteenth century Hebrew writer, Isaac ben Yedaiah: There, in his palace, dwells the Pope, who rules and presides over all who follow the faith. And the cardinals, his advisors, surround him, wisely strengthening every breach in the religion day after day. Each year, many notables and summoned leaders come there faithfully to greet [the Pope]. Whatever he decrees to the gentile kings who are adherents of the faith, not one of them will disobey him, nor will they speak after he has spoken; whatever he seals with his bull can not be reversed, whether it apply to a nation or to an individual alike3. Years afterwards, while the Jews were recovering from the traumatic events of the year 1348, an assembly of notables convened in Catalonia to look for ways to prevent riots from occurring again. Among the decisions they reached was one in which the monarch of Aragon would be approached and, in his tumt would defend the case of the Jews before “The King of the Gentiles”, the Pope of Avignon4. A political plot involving the Pope is imagined already by Nachmanides in 1263: when the messiah will arrive the will come and command the Pope and all the kings… “Let my people go”5. A more detailed program, along the lines of that imagined by Nachmanides, is delineated by the aforementioned Isaac ben Yedaiah: [The messianic king] will go to Rome, and request their supreme leader and his advisers to write to the kings under his hegemony, and seal it with 1 A. Toaff, Gli ebrei a Perugia, Perugia, 1975, p. 228. 2 Cfr. my note in Studies in the History of the Jewish People and the Land of Israel, Vol. V, Haifa, 1980, p. 174. 3 M. Saperstein, Decoding the Rabbis: A Thirteenth Century Commentary on the Aggadah, Cambridge, Mass., 1980, p. 103. Even a hostile author, Todros ben Isaac of Gerona, in his litany against Pope John XXII, written in 1321 or 1322, labels him “King of the Gentiles”. Cfr. Eliezer Birnbaum, “Mahzor Roma — The Cluj Manuscript dated 5159 AD/1390 CE and the Public Fast in Rome in 1321 CCE” in JQR 76 (1985), pp. 59–95, in particular pp. 66–67. 4 F. Baer, Die Juden im christlichen Spanien, 2 vols., Berlin, 1929–1933, vol. I, p. 348. 5 Cfr. H. Maccoby, Judaism on Trial: Jewish Christian Disputations in the Middle Ages, London and Toronto, 1982, pp. 122–123.