How Dehumanization Leads to Murder and Genocide. Lessons from the Nazi Era
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Gabel Stewart
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 203
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 979-8-88719-304-5
Артикул: 872488.01.99
This book discusses psychological aspects of dehumanization and of the human tendency to dominate, control and potentially murder those considered less than or "other” by the dominant group. It explores how increasingly severe dehumanization resulted in the genocide of six million Jews in the second World War. Psychological and behavioral strategies Nazi aggressors and ordinary citizens used to mislead themselves during this process are described. Understanding the sequence of events from dehumanization to murder has implications for the apparent tendency of human beings to harm and potentially kill those who appear "different”, or who are made into the "other”. Efforts to prevent genocide should actively challenge dehumanization of weaker populations whenever possible, even when dehumanization appears mild, "insignificant,” or "innocuous.”
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
H O W D E H U M A N I Z AT I O N L E A D S TO M U R D E R A N D G E N O C I D E Lessons from the Nazi Era
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 S t e w a r t G a b e l H O W D E H U M A N I Z AT I O N L E A D S TO M U R D E R A N D G E N O C I D E Lessons from the Nazi Era
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Gabel, Stewart, 1943- author. Title: How dehumanization leads to murder and genocide: lessons from the Nazi era / Stewart Gabel, MD, PhD. Description: Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2023. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2023026258 (print) | LCCN 2023026259 (ebook) | ISBN 9798887193038 (hardback) | ISBN 9798887193045 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9798887193052 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Genocide--Psychological aspects. | Murder--Psychological aspects. | Nazis--Psychology. Classification: LCC HV6322.7 .G33 2023 ( print) | LCC HV6322.7 (ebook) | DDC 304.6/63--dc23/eng/20230609 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2023026258 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2023026259 Copyright © 2023 Stewart Gabel All rights reserved. Book design by PHi Business Solutions Cover design by Ivan Grave On the cover: Menschengruppe vor der Deportation Holzschnitt um 1938, by Maria Luiko. (In public domain) Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Introduction 1. A Brief History of the Jews from Antiquity through the Middle Ages 17 2. Antisemitism and Dehumanization of the Jews in the Modern Period. Enlightenment and Emancipation. Political Antisemitism 25 3. Dehumanization. Research. Definitions. Examples in the Nazi Era 52 4. The Human Propensity toward Violence, Destruction, and Murder. Prohibitions against Killing Other Humans. Examples of the Tendency toward Violence and Murder in the Nazi Era 70 5. The Progression from Dehumanization to Murder and Genocide in the Nazi Era 108 6. Dehumanization of School-Aged Children in Nazi Germany 132 7. Medical Implementation of Aryan Ideology: Sterilization, Euthanasia, Experimentation 145 8. Summary and Conclusions. Alternative Approaches. Addressing Dehumanization 166 References 183 Index 189
Introduction This book is about the relationship between dehumanization, murder, and genocide, emphasizing the characteristics and intricacies of this relationship. I use, as an example of these processes, the treatment of Jews during the Nazi era in Germany (1933–1945) and consider, to a lesser extent, the treatment of Jews in countries conquered by or allied with Germany, as well as the treatment of residents of institutions for the mentally or physically impaired in Germany. I argue that dehumanization, applied in an increasingly severe manner to demean, subjugate, and control Jews in Nazi-dominated territories during the Nazi era ultimately led to the murder of Jews in these areas. I will consider the mechanisms and precipitants of this movement from dehumanization to murder that was associated with the Holocaust, perhaps the most horrific genocide in history. Background and Overview The dehumanizing tactics used by Germany’s Nazi leaders, abetted by many followers, targetted the Jewish people who had been considered a centuries-long threat. Adolf Hitler (1925/1999) and his Nazi followers argued that Jews were representative of the Semitic race and were the oldest and most formidable enemy of the German people that had ever existed. The German people, themselves, according to Hitler’s view, had descended from an ill-defined Aryan race many centuries ago. For Hitler and his followers, Jews had to be eliminated from German (and European) soil if the Germanic people were to achieve world domination and the full potential of the Aryan race, although exactly what the latter meant was an ill-defined construct that, nonetheless, resulted in not only the genocide of Jews, but the murder of other nationalities, minority groups, and disabled individuals who were within the German sphere of influence. Hitler’s (1945) views on race, and on what he felt to be the Jewish menace, were fanatical. His misplaced and dangerous views spanned his political career and were included in his final political testament shortly before his death. On ascending to power in 1933, he and the Nazi party made it clear that there was no place in Germany for any Jew and that all Jews were to be eliminated from
the country. It was unclear what “elimination” meant in the early stages of systematic dehumanization. At the beginning of the Nazi years, elimination was taken to mean coerced emigration. Toward the end of the Nazi era, elimination came to mean extermination through various forms of murder, such as starvation regimens in ghettos, German death squads, and gassing in concentration camps (Landau, 2016; Vasey, 2006). The overall Nazi strategy regarding the Jews, therefore, was a policy of elimination that became total extermination, with the ultimate goal that Germany would become a country (and Europe a continent) free of Jews. The Nazi program was one of genocide, a term coined by Raphael Lemkin (1946) from the ancient Greek word (genos) for race and the Latin suffix (cide) for killing. Lemkin used this newly coined term to describe the numerous attempts to destroy national, racial or religious groups that he recognized as being common in human history. In the case of the Nazi-inspired Holocaust, the tactics to arrive at these goals of elimination or extermination involved a process of increasingly severe dehumanization that isolated Jews from non-Jews, restricted the livelihoods, activities, education, and freedoms of Jews and increasingly convinced the German public (the bystanders) that Jews were a separate, subhuman or inferior people that was a menace to them. The Nazi leadership and those supporting its views used these dehumanizing tactics to persecute and ultimately enslave and murder the Jewish people. The Nazi leaders justified the dehumanization and killing of other human beings to themselves and to German citizens by arguing that these enslaved or murdered people were in essence inferior, subhuman, or not actually people at all. The people being killed, to the victimizers, were less than human or subhuman in either their personal, ethical, or moral development, and/or they were animals, creatures that did not have the essential characteristics (including moral or personal qualities) that human beings have. Killing such people, who are considered to not really be people, often is justified by aggressors if the victimized person or group can be understood as hostile and dangerous to the victimizers (Smith, 2011). Not surprisingly, the group considered subhuman usually has less power than the larger, stronger individual or group that argues it has been “forced” to defend itself against what it considers to be a subhuman “monster.” These deceptive tactics result in dehumanization of the victim but are often complicated and associated with other psychological processes through which victimizers deceive themselves (and others). Victimizers may engage in distortions, diversions, rationalizations, denial, and blame. Mental health professionals describe the psychological processes employed by perpetrators that allow horrendous acts to be committed against
I n t r o d u c t i o n victims as “psychological defenses.” These “defenses” are intended to ward off anxiety, guilt, shame, or other unpleasant feelings in the victimizers by blaming victims, making the victimizers able to believe, act, and react in ways that are satisfying or self-justifying to them, regardless of what the unpleasant truths, realities, and consequences of their actions or beliefs might be. In the Nazi era, many Germans believed Hitler (1925/1999) when he falsely accused Jews of instigating or saboutaging WWI or of conspiring with fellow Jews in other countries to form a financial cabal to rule the world (Landau, 2016). These claims had no merit but allowed those Germans who believed them to blame Jews for their own financial insecurity and for their lack of political or military power. German citizens became increasingly able to project the blame for their failures onto Jews, a ready scapegoat, while diverting attention from a realistic appraisal of their own failures and fears. Based on these groundless assumptions of Jewish treachery, the Germans holding these beliefs, who might otherwise have felt powerless or inferior, were able to divert attention from themselves onto the Jews, thus fostering desires for revenge against Jews as a group. Dominating the Jews and “punishing” or expelling them from Germany was, from this more psychological perspective, intended to relieve the guilt and blame that would otherwise have been attributed to the victimizers or to their leaders. The Jews were an obvious target because centuries of antisemitism could be used to incite conspiracy theories about this group. Dehumanization thereby became a potential catalyst, justification, and tactic to incite violence and murder. It was an activator for futher, increasingly severe dehumanizing actions and an instigator of what Freud called the death instinct (that was later called the death drive), a phenomenon related to mass murder and genocide. In this book, I do not employ Freud’s (1920; 1930) formulation but offer an approach that views murder along a continuum with dehumanization. I argue that humans demonstrate a natural proclivity toward violence, destruction, and murder that may be stimulated by dehumanizing tactics perpetrated against those who are considered less than human or as “animals,” given that animals are convenient targets for deadly aggression. These dehumanizing judgments render animals and dehumanized individuals less worthy of usual human protections against violence and aggression than it is true for one’s fellow human beings. Essentially, the severly dehumanized individual or group becomes an opportune target to express the inherent potential that human beings have for violence. The individuals and groups who harbor these types of psychological defense mechanisms may be entirely unaware or unconscious of their own reactions (or the reasons for them), making them likely to take actions they believe are
justified, but that in reality they do not fully comprehend. Calling Jews or any other dehumanized group vermin or dogs, for examples, avoids an understanding of the chain of personal and social attitudes that have contributed to the aggressor’s malign designations. Hitler and the Nazis burned books written by psychoanalysts and were notorious for their antipathy to this form of psychological analysis. Had they pursued this form of understanding further, they might have concluded that dehumanization of others was in part an externalizing tactic for “resolving” their own internal conflicts and fears of inadequacy and failure that resulted in a series of behaviors and actions perpetrated against Jews. Dehumanization of Jews was also reflected as the internal state of these victimizers whose judgments rested on assumptions about the perpetrators, themselves, and the attitudes and behaviors of Jews, their would-be-and assumed enemies. Dehumanization in victimizers is, therefore, both (1) an internal state that denigrates the victims and their attitudes and behaviors and (2) one or more external behaviors perpetrated against the victims that the perpetrators consider justified because of their own faulty assumptions about the victims and the victims’ motivations. This internal denigrating appraisal results from a series of psychological defenses within the dehumanizer that are intended to shift responsibility, to whatever degree possible, onto the victims who are usually individuals or groups with less power. Dehumanizing tactics, as indicated here, deny victims “personhood”—a sense of the value of their own humanity, their justification for being, and their own identity in its various forms (Bastian & Haslam, 2011). This denial of personhood is justified by the aggressor through blaming the victim for sins and errors, as defined by the victimizer. Often, these sins and errors, as suggested earlier, have little or nothing to do with what the victim actually has done; rather, they reflect prejudices linked to assumed innate or enduring qualities of the victim (such as skin color), religious identity/affiliation, or social status (such as living in poverty) that are used to justify the persecution of the victim, even when the malign social situation is due to the actions of the aggressors themselves. Regardless of the apparent unfairness of the immutable conditions of birth or the prejudicial actions of the oppressor, a series of moral and ethical failures are attributed by the victimizers to the victimized individual or group who are now considered to be less than human. The victim group essentially becomes dehumanized, a state that in severe form, as described throughout this book, carries considerable mortal danger. The human proclivity to commit violence or to murder others (who may or may not be known to the assailant) is often attributed by mental health