If This Is a Woman: Studies on Women and Gender in the Holocaust
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Год издания: 2021
Кол-во страниц: 293
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-711-5
Артикул: 872459.01.99
The present volume contains thirteen articles based on work presented at the "XX. Century Conference: If This Is A Woman” at Comenius University Bratislava in January 2019. The conference was organized against anti-gender narratives and related attacks on academic freedom and women’s rights currently all too prevalent in East-Central Europe. The papers presented at the conference and in this volume focus, to a significant extent, on this region. They touch upon numerous points concerning gendered experiences of World War II and the Holocaust. By purposely emphasizing the female experience in the title, we encourage to fill the lacunae that still, four decades after the enrichment of Holocaust studies with a gendered lens, exist when it comes to female experiences.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
If This Is a Woman Studies on Women and Gender in the Holocaust
B O S T O N 2 0 2 1 If This Is a Woman Edited by Denisa Nešťáková, Katja Grosse-Sommer, Borbála Klacsmann, and Jakub Drábik Studies on Women and Gender in the Holocaust
Cover photograph: The Hoenig sisters, Prešov, Czechoslovakia, 1941. From right to left: Yolana was in Auschwitz for three years and survived; Regina was deported in 1944 and perished; Magda was among the first deportees to Auschwitz in 1942; Anna hid near Prešov, was deported, and perished; Ilona hid with Anna and perished; Irena was deported to Auschwitz in 1942. Photo Credit: Yad Vashem Photo Archives, archival signature 7753 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Nešťáková, Denisa, 1987- editor. | Grosse-Sommer, Katja, 1994-editor. | Klacsmann, Borbála, 1983- editor. Title: If this is a woman : studies on women and gender in the holocaust / edited by Denisa Nešťáková, Katja Grosse-Sommer, Borbála Klacsmann, and Jakub Drábik. Description: Boston, MA: Academic Studies Press, 2021. | Summary: “The present volume contains thirteen articles based on work presented at the “XX. Century Conference: If This Is A Woman” at Comenius University Bratislava in January 2019. The conference was organized against antigender narratives and related attacks on academic freedom and women’s rights currently all too prevalent in East-Central Europe. The papers presented at the conference and in this volume focus, to a significant extent, on this region. They touch upon numerous points concerning gendered experiences of World War II and the Holocaust. By purposely emphasizing the female experience in the title, we encourage to fill the lacunae that still, four decades after the enrichment of Holocaust studies with a gendered lens, exist when it comes to female experiences”– Provided by publisher. Identifiers: LCCN 2021034951 (print) | LCCN 2021034952 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644697108 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644697115 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9781644697122 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Jewish women in the Holocaust. | Holocaust, Jewish (1939-1945) Classification: LCC D804.47 .I47 2021 (print) | LCC D804.47 (ebook) | DDC 940.53/18082–dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021034951 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021034952 ISBN 9781644697108 (hardback) ISBN 9781644697115 (adobe pdf) ISBN 9781644697122 (epub) Copyright © 2021 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. Book design by Lapiz Digital Services. Cover design by Ivan Grave. Published by Academic Studies Press. 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446 USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Acknowledgements vii Foreword: Unholy Alliances ix Andrea Pető Introduction xi Denisa Nešťáková, Katja Grosse-Sommer, Borbála Klacsmann, and Jakub Drábik Part One Theoretical Reflections on a Gender Focus in Holocaust Studies 1 1. “Will You Hear My Voice?” Women in the Holocaust: Memory and Analysis 3 Dalia Ofer 2. A Familial Turn in Holocaust Scholarship? 20 Natalia Aleksiun Part Two Gender in Times of Occupation and Authoritarianism: Expectation and Reality 43 3. Masculinities under Occupation: Considerations of a Gender Perspective on Everyday Life under German Occupation 45 Agnes Laba 4. New Slovak Woman: The Feminine Ideal in the Authoritarian Regime of the Slovak State, 1939–1945 62 Eva Škorvanková
Contents vi Part Three Women’s Lives in Camps 81 5. “Our mother organized it all”: The Role of Mothers of Sereď Camp in the Memories of Their Children 83 Denisa Nešťáková 6. Women in the Ilava Camp as Political Detainees in 1939 101 Marína Zavacká Part Four Women in Positions of Community Leadership 121 7. Women in Dror and Gendered Experiences of the Holocaust? 123 Anna Nedlin-Lehrer 8. Female Involvement in the “Jewish Councils” of the Netherlands and France: Gertrude van Tijn and Juliette Stern 142 Laurien Vastenhout Part Five Women in the Resistance 161 9. “Ma’am, do you know that a Jew lives here?” The Betrayal of Polish Women and the Jewish Children They Hid during the Holocaust—the Case of Cracow 163 Joanna Sliwa 10. “And with these boots, I’m gonna run away from here”: The Significance of Female Narratives in the Sobibor Uprising and Its Aftermath 181 Hannah Wilson 11. “After all, I was a ‘female’ and a ‘yid’ to boot.” Jewish Women among Partisans in Lithuania, 1941–1944 201 Modiane Zerdoun-Daniel Part Six Sexuality and Sexual Violence 219 12. Listening to Women’s Voices: Jewish Rape Survivors’ Testimonies in Soviet War Crimes Trials 221 Marta Havryshko 13. Male Jewish Teenage Sexuality in Nazi Germany 243 Florian Zabransky Contributors 264 Index 268
Acknowledgements As we believe the saying should go, “no woman is an island.” This is particularly true for this volume, which could not have been created without the work and support of many individuals and institutions. The editors want to warmly thank the institutions under whose auspices the conference was organized—Comenius University in Bratislava (the Department of General History at the Faculty of Arts, in particular), the Institute of History at the Slovak Academy of Sciences, and the Institute for Contemporary History in Munich. Thank you to the staff at Comenius University who enabled us make our conference a success. Thanks to Professor Eduard Nižňanský for early support and the motivation to organize the conference. We are grateful to the partners that cooperated with in organizing the conference: the European Holocaust Research Infrastructure (EHRI), the Faculty of Arts of Palacký University, Olomouc, the Jewish Historical Institute in Warsaw, the Department of History at the University of Szeged, as well as the Sereď Holocaust Museum. We are more than thankful to the institutions offering us financial support, without whom we could not have brought together such amazing scholars. They are the Visegrad Fund, Comenius University in Bratislava, the Goethe Institute Bratislava, the Polish Institute in Bratislava, the French Embassy, and the Israeli Embassy in Slovakia. Furthermore, we would like to express our gratitude to the institutions providing the additional financial support that made possible the publication of the book you are holding in your hands. Our thanks go to the Institute of History at the Slovak Academy of Sciences (Project APVV-15-0349—The Individual and Society: Their Mutual Reflection in the Historical Process), the Slovak Research and Development Agency
viii (APVV-18-0333), the Faculty of Arts at Comenius University in Bratislava, the Polish Institute in Bratislava, and Paideia—The European Institute for Jewish Studies in Sweden. The vital bureaucratic work was taken on by the Vincent Múcska (the head of the Department of General History), the department’s treasurer, Dr. Eva Škorvánková (a contributor to this volume), and the department’s administrators Mária Bajbarová, Viera Feriancová, and Oľga Petreková. We want to warmly thank all the conference’s participants, including those whose work is not featured in this volume. In particular, we want to thank our co-organizer Dr. Anna Ullrich for her dedication to the project. Thank you to Academic Studies Press for providing the opportunity to publish our work and to Alessandra Anzani for her involvement in pushing it forward. We are grateful to the anonymous reviewers for their extensive comments on the manuscript.1 Thank you to Wolfgang Schellenbacher from the EHRI Document Blog for giving us the opportunity to share our research in a more popular setting. The blog contributions of conference participants are collected at https://blog.ehri-project.eu. Thank you to all those who have encouraged this project from its conception to its realization. We are honored to collaborate with such intelligent, dedicated, and concerned individuals, and have enjoyed their support for this project. If these are the women and allies we could work together with in every project, we believe that academia would certainly be richer and more supportive. 1 Authors were responsible for the implementation of reviewers’ comments. Acknowledgements
Foreword: Unholy Alliances Andrea Pető We all know the value of the discussions during conference breaks. These are the moments when experts on gender and women’s history usually talk to each other about their marginalization in the profession. Unless they find the separately flagged “gender” panels and special issues of peer-reviewed journals comforting, not much has changed in the power dynamics of the historical profession in the past decades. In the institutional inertia, the concept of “gender” as an analytical category has gone through a major transformation. Joan Scott, in her very influential and widely quoted Siegriest lecture of 2001, pointed this out in her article entitled “Gender as a Category of Historical Analysis,” published in the American Historical Journal in 1986, did not bring the expected intellectual and political breakthrough. Instead of a major epistemological transformation by applying gender as a category of analysis, it led to “genderism,” meaning that researchers used gender as a category of analysis ignoring intersectional approaches that take into consideration other differences.1 Those who are working in the field of Holocaust and Jewish studies are of course familiar with these complexities of institutionalization and application of gender as a category of analysis too well. They do not even need a conference break to recall that the famous debate about “asking the wrong question” has a long shadow, especially when jobs are scarce 1 Joan W. Scott, “Millennial Fantasies. The Future of ‘Gender’ in the 21st Century,” in Gender: Die Tücken einer Kategorie. Joan W. Scott, Geschichte und Politik. Beiträge zum Symposion anlässlich der Verleihung des Hans-Sigrist-Preises 1999 der Universität Bern an Joan W. Scott, ed., Claudia Honegger and Caroline Arni (Zürich: Kronos-Verlag, 2001, 19–37.
Andrea Pető x anyway.2 Historians working on gendering the Holocaust are also struggling not only of the remasculinization of their profession but also the resistance of history writing against these epistemological challenges. Sara Horowitz sets out two aims for those undertaking gender analyses of the Holocaust: “recovering the experiences of women and reshaping or nuancing Holocaust memory.”3 The first approach—“recovering the experiences of women”—seeks to gather the lost and neglected stories of the Holocaust; the second focuses on the framework, or rather settings, in which these stories are situated. Recently, however, unexpected allies showed up on the thus far quite gloomy horizon of gender historians of the Holocaust. A number of books and journal articles covering this “recovery of the experiences of women” during the Holocaust has, surprisingly, increased. But these new allies are only interested in the first task set by Horowitz: to recover women’s voices as they were. Representatives are returning to the main objective of women’s history writing of the 1970s, but with a very different political agenda. This “her-story turn” is a result of the failed epistemological change in history writing together with the illiberal memory turn. Their aim is to recover female figures, mainstreaming them into the very center of national history where they failed to find a “proper home” in the past decades.4 The ongoing illiberal shift demonstrates that feminists do not have a monopoly to write women’s history, just as they cannot count on their monopoly to politically represent women. They have to prove that they are better, more relevant and first of all more interesting. If This Is a Woman: Studies on Women and Gender in the Holocaust is an attempt to do exactly that: because if we fail, there will not be too many conferences in the future to complain about marginalization over coffee. 2 Andrea Pető, Louise Hecht, and Karoline Krasuska, eds., Women and the Holocaust: New Perspectives and Challenges (Warszawa: IBL, 2015). 3 Sara R. Horowitz, “Gender, Genocide, and Jewish Memory,” Prooftexts 20, nos. 1–2 (2000): 176. 4 Andrea Pető, “Roots of Illiberal Memory Politics: Remembering Women in the 1956 Hungarian Revolution,” Baltic Worlds 10, no. 4 (2017): 42–58.