The Unique Family Law in the State of Israel
Покупка
Тематика:
Право зарубежных стран
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Cohen Yitshak
Год издания: 2021
Кол-во страниц: 257
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-541-8
Артикул: 872427.01.99
In the State of Israel, the unique family law derives from ancient Jewish law, halakhic traditions, and an extensive legal tradition spanning many centuries and geographic locations. This book examines Israeli family law in comparison with the corresponding law in the United States and illuminates common issues in legal systems worldwide. The Israeli system is primarily controlled by the religious law of the parties. Thus, religious courts were also established and granted enforcement powers equivalent to those of the civil courts. This is a complex situation because the religious law applied in these courts is not always consistent with gender equality and civil rights practiced in civil court. This book seeks to clarify that tension and offer solutions. The comprehensive analysis in this book may serve as a guide for those interested in family law: civil court judges, rabbinical court judges, lawyers, mediators, arbitrators, and families themselves. Topics central to the book include issues subject to modification, the right of a minor to independent status, extramarital relationships, and joint property.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
THE UNIQUE FAMILY LAW IN THE STATE OF ISRAEL
Touro University Press Books Series Editor MICHAEL A. SHMIDMAN, PhD (Touro College, New York) SIMCHA FISHBANE, PhD (Touro College, New York)
N E W Y O R K 2 0 2 1 THE UNIQUE FAMILY LAW IN THE STATE OF ISRAEL Y I T S H A K CO H E N
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Cohen, Yitshak, 1971- author. Title: The unique family law in the state of Israel / Yitshak Cohen. Description: Brookline, MA: Academic Studies Press, 2021. Identifiers: LCCN 2020048081 (print) | LCCN 2020048082 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644695401 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644695418 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9781644695425 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Domestic relations--Israel. | Domestic relations (Jewish law) | Domestic relations--United States. Classification: LCC KMK540 .C64 2021 (print) | LCC KMK540 (ebook) | DDC 346.569401/5--dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020048081 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020048082 Copyright © Itshak Cohen, 2021 Please do not copy or photocopy without the written permission of the author Published by Touro University Press and Academic Studies Press Typeset, printed and distributed by Academic Studies Press ISBN 9781644695401 (hardback) ISBN 9781644695418 (adobe pdf) ISBN 9781644695425 (epub) Touro University Press Michael A. Shmidman and Simcha Fishbane, Editors 320 West 31st Street, Fourth Floor, New York, NY 10001, USA tcpress@ touro.edu Book design by PHi Business Solutions Limited Cover design by Ivan Grave. Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@ academicstudiespress.com www . academicstudiespress.com
To my dearly beloved in-laws, Nehemiah and Rachel Stern (”כִּי בִי יִרְ ּבּו יָמֶיָך וְיֹוסִיפּו לְָּך שְׁנֹות חַיִּים.” (משלי ט, יא
Contents Acknowledgments xiii Introduction 1 Chapter 1: Issues Subject to Modification in Family Law 9 I. Introduction 9 II. Issues Subject to Modification in Family Law 10 III. Bargaining and Indemnification in Divorce Agreements 15 IV. Issues Subject to Modification—A New Model 19 A. Argument I: Broadening Issues Subject to Modification 19 1. A Theoretical View 19 2. A Practical View 23 B. Argument II: Eliminating Modification in Divorce Settlements 27 1. The Perspective of Contractual Obligations: Breach of Agreements 29 2. The Perspective of Public Policy: The Ongoing Destructive Relationship 31 3. The Perspective of Normative Harmony: Monetary Claims 33 4. The Limitations of Modifying Judicial Decisions 35 C. An Intermediate Path—Comprehensive Legislative Rules for Modification 37 1. Defining the Changed Circumstances Standard through Fixed Rules 38 2. The Effective Support Approach 45 3. The Tort Model 49 V. Conclusion 52
viii Chapter 2: The Right of a Minor to Independent Status I. Introduction 54 II. Importance of the Minor’s Right to Independent Status 55 A. Finality of Judgment 55 B. Natural Guardianship 57 C. The Right of the Minor to Independent Status 58 III. Exclusion of Other Interests in Family Law 61 A. Res Judicata and the Burden of Proof 61 B. Contractual Certainty, Rehabilitation, and Motivation to Settle 64 IV. Three Models for Balancing the Competing Interests 68 Model A: Consideration of the Interest of the Minor by the Court 68 Model B: Clear Legislative Guidelines 71 Model C: Independent Representation for the Minor 75 V. Conclusion 81 Chapter 3: Extramarital Relationships and the Theoretical Rationales for the Joint Property Rules 84 I. Introduction 84 II. Property Distribution and Extramarital Relationships—The Laws in the United States 86 A. The System of Family Property Distribution 86 B. The No-Fault Divorce Revolution 89 C. The No-Fault Divorce Revolution—The Shattered Dream 92 D. Fault in Property Distribution—The Laws in the United States 93 III. Extramarital Relationships and Property Distribution— The Normative View 100 A. The Moral Argument 100 B. A Dilemma Facing the Moral Argument 103 C. A Lack of Guidelines Leads to Judicial Arbitrariness 105 D. Which Field of Law Should Deal with Extramarital Relationships? 107 IV. Israeli law—Extramarital Relationships 109 A. Extramarital Relationships under a Joint Property Regime 109
ix Contents B. Balancing of Resources—The Property Relations Law C. Jewish Religious Law 113 V. The Modern Theoretical Rationales for Joint Property 114 A. The Joint Property Principles 114 B. Different Fields of Law and Extramarital Relationships 124 C. The Moral Argument—The Approach of Society 125 D. A Proposal for a New Model—The Dominant Cause Model 126 VI. Conclusion 128 Chapter 4: Property Sharing Arrangements in Israeli Family Law 131 I. Introduction 131 II. The Property Relations Law—The Theoretical and Normative Framework 133 III. The Knobler Case—A Solution with Endless Difficulty 136 IV. The Case Law That Followed the Knobler Case 139 A. The Abu Romi Case—An Obiter Dictum Becomes Precedent 139 B. An Asset Registered in the Name of One Spouse Is Held to Be a Shared Asset 140 C. The Simchoni Case—A Separate Asset Registered in the Name of Its Owner and Held by Creditors 142 D. The Ben Giat Case—Reinstatement of the Presumption of Sharing 143 E. Family Court Case Law 146 V. The Law in the United Kingdom 146 VI. The Law in the United States 152 VII. A New Model in Light of Amendment 4 158 A. Amendment 4—A Significant Change 158 B. A Desirable Normative Arrangement in Light of Amendment 4 160 C. The Normative Arrangement Concerning the Residential Apartment 162 VIII. Conclusion 164 Chapter 5: Recognition of Foreign Civil Marriages 166 I. Introduction 166 II. The Schlesinger Case—A Marriage between a Jew and a Non-Jew 169
x III. The Validity of Civil Marriage A. The Skornik Case—The Validity of a Marriage with Regard to Maintenance 172 B. Three Approaches for Examining the Validity of a Marriage 174 C. The Anonymous Case—The English Approach 175 IV. The Ben Ari Case—Registration of Same-Sex Civil Marriage 178 V. Conclusion 181 Chapter 6: The Issue of Document Disclosure in General Court and in Family Court 183 I. Introduction 183 II. The Unique Nature of the Family Court 185 A. Establishment of the Family Court—Historical Background 185 B. The Release from Procedural Rules—Analysis and Review 187 III. Document Disclosure 190 A. Document Disclosure in the General Courts 190 B. Document Disclosure in Family Court 192 C. Does General Document Disclosure Apply in Family Court? 193 IV. The Response of the Family Court—A Critical Review 196 A. The “Pre-Trial” Rules as Authority for Document Disclosure 197 B. The Sanction for Noncompliance with Document Disclosure Orders 199 C. Rejection of the Constructions by the Courts of Appeal 200 D. Partial Adoption of the General Procedure: A Critical Review 201 V. The Legal Systems in Several Other Countries 203 A. The Australian Legal System 203 B. The Legal Systems in Canada 206 C. The Legal System in Several States within the United States 207