Книжная полка Сохранить
Размер шрифта:
А
А
А
|  Шрифт:
Arial
Times
|  Интервал:
Стандартный
Средний
Большой
|  Цвет сайта:
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц

Performing History: Approaches to History Across Musicology

Покупка
Артикул: 872417.01.99
Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину
The fifteen essays of Performing History glimpse the diverse ways music historians "do” history, and the diverse ways in which music histories matter. This book’s chapters are structured into six key areas: historically informed performance; ethnomusicological perspectives; particular musical works that "tell,” "enact,” or "perform” war histories; operatic works that works that "tell,” "enact,” or "perform” power or enlightenment; musical works that deploy the body and a broad range of senses to convey histories; and histories involving popular music and performance. Diverse lines of evidence and manifold methodologies are represented here, ranging from traditional historical archival research to interviewing, performing, and composing. The modes of analyzing music and its associated texts represented here are as various as the kinds of evidence explored, including, for example, reading historical accounts against other contextual backdrops, and reading "between the lines” to access other voices than those provided by mainstream interpretation or traditional musicology.
Performing History: Approaches to History Across Musicology : монография / Ed. by N. November. - Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2020. - 359 с. - ISBN 978-1-64469-355-1. - Текст : электронный. - URL: https://znanium.ru/catalog/product/2239589 (дата обращения: 19.11.2026). – Режим доступа: по подписке.
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Performing 
History
APPROACHES 
TO HISTORY ACROSS 
MUSICOLOGY  




B O S T O N
2 0 2 0
Performing 
History
APPROACHES 
TO HISTORY ACROSS 
MUSICOLOGY  


Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: November, Nancy, editor. 
Title: Performing history: Approaches to History Across Musicology / edited 
 
by Nancy November. 
Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2020.
Identifiers: LCCN 2020009722 (print) | LCCN 2020009723 (ebook) | ISBN
 
9781644693544 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644693551 (adobe pdf) 
Subjects: LCSH: Music--Performance. | Music--Performance--History. |
 
Music--Interpretation (Phrasing, dynamics, etc.) | Music and history. |
 
Historiography.
Classification: LCC ML457 .P497 2020 (print) | LCC ML457 (ebook) | DDC
 
780.7809--dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020009722
LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020009723
ISBN 9781644693544 (hardback) 
ISBN 9781644693551 (adobe pdf)
ISBN 9781644694466 (ePub) 
Copyright © 2020 Academic Studies Press
All rights reserved.
Book design by Lapiz Digital Services. 
Cover design by Ivan Grave. 
On the cover: Scenes from a tukumai memorial ritual on Takū, Papua New 
Guinea. Photographs by Richard Moyle, reproduced by permission.
Published by Academic Studies Press
1577 Beacon Street
Brookline, MA 02446, USA
press@academicstudiespress. com
www .academicstudiespress.com


Contents
Introduction
Nancy November
PART ONE
HIP Experiences
7
1  Some Senses of History among HIP Performers 
9
Mary Hunter
2  Counting to Four: The flûte du quatre in Charles Dieupart’s  
Six Suittes (1701) 
29
Imogen Morris
3  The French Style of Viol Bowing and the enflé in the  
Works of Marin Marais 
52
Polly Sussex
4  Contextual History through Rhetorical Visuality in  
Performing Monteverdi’s Il pianto della Madonna 
72
Daniela Kaleva
PART TWO
Performance as Celebration and Conservation
99
5  Celebrating and Enhancing a Virtual Past through Singing:  
The Polynesian Community on Takū 
101
Richard Moyle
6  Reimagining Traditional Ritual Music of Sabah for  
Contemporary Performance as a Means of Conservation 
115
Mia Palencia


vi
Contents
PART THREE
Performing War
137
7  Historical Fidelity and Creative License in two Viennese  
Battles of the Nile 
139
Allan Badley
8  Gallipoli to the Somme: A Musical Witness to History 
160
Anthony Ritchie
9  Britten’s Primal Scream
181
Sterling Lambert	
PART FOUR
Staging Power and Enlightenment
195
10  Staging Power: The Role of Duchess Sophie Elisabeth of 
Braunschweig-Lüneburg (1613–76) in Wolfenbüttel Court 
Festivities of the 1650s 
197
Hannah Spracklan-Holl	
11  An Enlightened Future History on the Milan Opera  
Stage: Niccolò Piccinni’s Il regno della Luna
216
Lawrence Mays
PART FIVE
Performing the Body and the Senses
247
12  “A New World is Opened up to View”: Orchestral  
Gesture in Berlioz’s Roméo et Juliette 
249
Inge van Rij
13  Italian Futurism: Music and the Senses in the Modern Age 
283
Jennifer Rumbell
PART SIX
Performing the Popular
299
14  “Saxophones Sobbed Out Jazz”: New Zealand’s  
First Jazz Recording 
301
Aleisha Ward
15  “To Display Her Chief Accomplishment”: Domestic  
Manuscript Music Collections in Colonial Australia
320
Rosemary Richards
Author Biographies
337
Index
341


Introduction
NANCY NOVEMBER
[O]ral traditions exhale past into present, inhale future into past. The 
common Pacific adage “We face the future with our backs” indicates that 
appreciation and knowledge of the past is vital for shaping a future.
—Selina Tusitala Marsh, “Here Our Words”*
M
usic histories speak, shape, and act. This was foremost in my mind when 
I formulated the title of the conference on which this book is based, the 
2017 Combined Conference of the Musicological Society of Australia and the 
New Zealand Musicological Society: “Performing History” (10–12 December, 
The University of Auckland). Musicological societies worldwide have opened 
their doors to interdisciplinary studies, encouraging cross-fertilisation between 
music sub-disciplines (perhaps especially in Commonwealth countries), and so 
ensure that theorists, performers, teachers, and composers of music are included. 
But as musicology as a discipline opens up, are we in the process losing sight of 
the discipline’s historical dimension, and why it matters? To cite just one piece 
of recent evidence: listening to today’s Music students talking about history 
courses, one gets a monochrome definition of what one “does” in such a setting: 
“Oooh, you’re doing a history course” [laughter], “writing essays?” “Yes.” 
Inspired by indigenous scholars and writers, such as Marsh, I wanted 
our conference to underscore not just the breadth of musicology but the 
“breath”—vitality or relevance—of music history. Yes, music historians sit in 
archives. Yes, we write and read. A lot. But we also perform numerous other 
roles, not limited to critiquing, empathising, uncovering, listening, creating, 
and enabling. So, for example, historically literate Music graduates might be 
*Selina Tusitala Marsh, “Here Our Words,” in The Pacific Islands: Environment and Society, ed. 
Moshe Rapaport (Honolulu, HI: The Bess Press, 1999), 166–78.


Nancy November
expected not just to write essays but also to understand and articulate their 
ways of being and knowing, and their positions in society; thus to have a 
sense of belonging in a larger community; to use knowledge from the past to 
shape their futures; and to lead the work for recognition of different cultural 
ways of being and knowing.
The essays chosen for this volume offer glimpses of the diverse ways music 
historians “do” history, and the diverse ways in which music histories matter. 
The diverse relationships that music can have with history—and the correspondingly various roles of the music historian—can be gleaned from some 
of the gerunds used in the authors’ titles. The musical works—and the music 
historians—represented in this volume are counting, celebrating, enhancing, 
reimaging, witnessing, creating, sensing, and staging; they are creating the 
past, and experiencing the past, in and through all of the senses. Diverse lines 
of evidence are required for the studies documented here, and a keen sense 
for appropriate methodologies. The scholars represented have done their fair 
share of archival work, and writing. But they have also been interviewing performers, composing, and talking to audience members. The modes of reading 
represented here are as various as the kinds of evidence explored, including, 
for example, reading historical accounts against other contextual backdrops, 
and reading “between the lines” to access other voices than those provided by 
mainstream interpretation or traditional musicology.
This book’s chapters are structured into six key areas that emerged at the 
conference, starting with historically informed performance (HIP). Mary Hunter 
explores how historically informed performers experience history. Her evidence 
includes published materials by older-generation HIP performers, and interviews with younger ones; she describe three kinds of historical thinking used 
by performers and notes the complex relation between historical “facts” and the 
performers’ senses of freedom and autonomy. This provides a useful backdrop 
for understanding the approaches of the three performers who wrote the three 
chapters that follow. Each one has uncovered aspects of an original performance 
context in order to open up the performance possibilities of one or more historical works today. Imogen Morris addresses Dieupart’s use of the flûte du quatre, via 
contextual understanding of the recorder-playing scene in England and on the 
Continent, with a view to informing instrument choice in modern-day performance. Polly Sussex considers a particular expressive swell used in bowing technique in Marais’s day, comparing this with the sound ideal of the modern string 
player, and thus suggesting a new approach to High-Baroque French bowing 
technique. And Daniela Kaleva shows how historically informed performance 


Introduction
can take in visual as well as written and organological sources, to embrace performance-led research: she explores the use of visualization techniques to inspire 
modern-day performers of Monteverdi’s Il pianto della Madonna.
The ethnomusicological perspectives of the next two chapters further 
open up the view of what it means to “perform history.” Richard Moyle’s exploration of song in the Polynesian community on Takū questions the pervasive 
image throughout Polynesia of song lyrics as a reliable repository of accurate 
accounts of the past; song becomes a means by which to reinterpret the past, 
according to the intentions of the singer; this can include, for example, partisan 
accounts based on family politics, and selective accounts for personal or familial 
aggrandizement. Mia Palencia’s practice-based approach considers how a past 
culture of song might be conserved, not by some process of museumification, 
but rather by making it relevant. The titikas of the Indonesian Orang Sungai is 
closely analysed and set in context. Palencia then describes how its distinctive 
musical characteristics can be used in combination with Western contemporary genres to produce new pieces for performance.
In the next five chapters the emphasis is on particular musical works that 
can be seen to “tell,” “enact,” or “perform” history in various ways. So often the 
discipline of History has been one of wars. Here we take a step back, into the 
realm of aesthetic experience, considering the historical representation of wars 
and the work such representations do in shaping how we view, understand, 
remember, and come to terms with those events. Allan Badley examines two 
late eighteenth-century works, Viennese representations of the Battle of the 
Nile, considering the composers’ access to information about the battle, their 
understanding of it, and the extent to which creative licence is privileged above 
historical fidelity in each. Anthony Ritchie offers a composer’s perspective on 
the subject, discussing his own Gallipoli to the Somme, written to commemorate 
World War I and performed internationally. What is the purpose of composing 
and performing war history? What is the most effective way of representing 
war in music and words? He explores what it means to commemorate war and 
the danger of distorting reality to make war more manageable for audiences. 
Sterling Lambert then considers Britten as a composer in dialogue with other 
composers, and with history, in his War Requiem. Ostensibly “doing” history 
by celebrating the rebuilding of Coventry Cathedral after its destruction in the 
Second World War, War Requiem might also be understood to relate to World 
War II in the Far East, and specifically the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and 
Nagasaki. He reads Britten’s War Requiem together with Bach’s St. John Passion, 
arguing that both are about sacrifice on behalf of humanity.


Nancy November
More overt “doing of historical work” through music is to be found in opera. 
Hannah Spracklan-Holl offers a critical reading of the surviving sources from 
Sophie Elisabeth’s 1655 festivities, Glückwünschende Freudendarstellung and Der 
Minervae Banquet, focusing on staging of dynastic power in their performance. 
Theories of performativity provide a framework for an examination of the text, 
music, and staging (suggested by the accompanying illustrations) of these festivities. Lawrence Mays reads Niccolò Piccinni’s dramma giocoso Il regno della 
Luna (1770) as forward-thinking in that it combined the Enlightenment view of 
a planned ideal future with the historicist notion of societal evolution. This work 
uses the moon as a striking stage on which to project and interrogate topical 
issues of the late eighteenth century, including the political position of women, 
commerce, militarism, colonialism, and interaction with the Other. 
These writers are all “doing” history in diverse ways, through performance, 
composing, recomposing, reading, rereading. The next two writers consider 
cases where diverse methodologies are not only helpful, but highly necessary 
for uncovering what we might term the historical work of the musical work: 
these writers consider how particular composers and schools of composers 
used various modalities to perform history. Inge van Rij shows how Berlioz’s 
Roméo et Juliette responds to the physical gestures that so inspired Berlioz, in 
the sonic imitations of narrative detail, and in the gestures of the players and 
conductor on the stage. She draws on Berlioz’s writings, accounts of the performance he witnessed, and nineteenth-century theories of gesture, exploring 
the relationship between musical performance and gesture in historical terms. 
Jennifer Rumbell examines how for the Italian Futurist movement, listening to 
music—and often also performing it—went beyond the ear to entail a multisensory experience. She, too, draws on diverse sources, ranging from theoretical texts to Futurist venues.
Other ways of “performing” history than those of the traditional Western 
music historian—who emphasises published documents—allow us easier 
access to other histories outside the mainstream. The final two chapters emphasise this point. Aleisha Ward discusses the significance of New Zealand’s first 
jazz recording, a one-minute musical featurette film of Epi Shalfoon and His 
Melody Boys, performing a jazzed arrangement of a popular Māori song E 
Puritai Tama E (or He Pūru Taitama). The featurette, and its fascinating history, 
speak to the developing jazz culture and music industry in New Zealand, and 
the local conceptualization and recontextualization of jazz circa 1930. Rosemary Richards shows how Australian colonial domestic manuscript music 
collections aided music-making and were also forms of life writing and artistic 


Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину