Salem on the Thames. Moral Panic, Anti-Zionism, and the Triumph of Hate Speech at Connecticut College
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Под ред.:
Landes Richard
Год издания: 2020
Кол-во страниц: 217
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-100-7
Артикул: 872400.01.99
This compelling volume focuses on the story of Andrew Pessin, a tenured philosophy professor at Connecticut College, who was accused by students and faculty of having "directly condoned the extermination of a people” based on a deliberate misreading of his 2015 Facebook post on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Salem on the Thames captures the events as they unfolded and discusses topics such as Western sentiments concerning Israeli-Palestinian relations, academics and free speech, antisemitism and diversity on the college campus, and social media and politics. The Pessin affair offers us a case study in a tendency towards "public shaming” reminiscent of the Salem witch trials that deeply compromises the integrity of academia.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
SALEM ON THE THAMES Moral Panic, Anti-Zionism, and the Triumph of Hate Speech at Connecticut College
Antisemitism in America Series Editor Eunice Pollack (University of North Texas, Denton, Texas)
BOSTON E d i t e d b y R I C H A R D L A N D E S SALEM ON THE THAMES Moral Panic, Anti-Zionism, and the Triumph of Hate Speech at Connecticut College
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Landes, Richard, 1949- editor. Title: Salem on the Thames : moral panic, anti-zionism, and the triumph of hate speech at Connecticut College / edited by Richard Landes. Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2020. | Series: Antisemitism in America | Includes bibliographical references. Identifiers: LCCN 2019039413 (print) | LCCN 2019039414 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644690987 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644690994 (paperback) | ISBN 9781644691007 (adobe pdf) Subjects: LCSH: Connecticut College. | Education, Higher--Political aspects-United States. | Zionism--United States--Public opinion. | Hate speech-United States. Classification: LCC LC89 .S25 2020 (print) | LCC LC89 (ebook) | DDC 378.746/5--dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019039413 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019039414 Copyright © 2020 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN 978-1-64469-098-7 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-64469-099-4 (paperback) ISBN 978-1-64469-100-7 (adobe pdf) Book design by PHi Business Solutions Limited. Cover design by Ivan Grave. Published by Academic Studies Press. 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress. com w w w. academics tudiespress. com
Credit: Elisheva Horowitz
Contents Preface ix Richard Landes Introduction 1 Asaf Romirowsky Andrew Pessin’s Facebook Post during Operation Protective Edge 5 Condensed Timeline 8 PART ONE When Criticizing Hamas Became a Campus Hate Crime 17 Richard Landes 1 The Post: On Truth and Metaphor 19 2 The Shameful Dishonesty of It All: An Annotated Chronology from the Perspective of the Victim 34 3 The People: McCarthyism, New London Style 72 PART TWO Studies in Pessinology 97 4 Connecticut College Acts Out a Staged Emergency 99 Ashley Thorne 5 “I Was Rude, You Were Evil”: Reflections on Academia, Liberalism, and the Betrayal of Andrew Pessin 114 John Gordon 6 The Pessin Case: The Response of Jewish Colleagues 138 Fred Baumann
viii PART THREE Reflections: Salem on the Thames—Stampeding a Herd of Cats Richard Landes 7 What Connecticut College’s Andrew Pessin Affair Teaches Us 173 8 Reflections on Academia and Freedom: The Case of Connecticut College, Spring 2015 186 9 Pessin, Ironic Prophet: The Liberal Emperor’s New Clothes of Humanitarian Racism 195 Bibliography 201 Contents
Preface RICHARD LANDES I first met Andrew Pessin as a result of his ordeal at Connecticut College in the Spring of 2015. As soon as I heard about it in the national media, it struck me as ominous: Professor with Zionist sympathies ridden out of his community on an ideological rail, tarred and feathered with accusations of hate speech, by a coalition of “progressives” with a Muslim student and Muslim professor leading the attack. After speaking with him and reading the material I made available at my blog, and analyze here, it became clear this was a major study in the failure of what one might call the cultural Maginot Line against fascism.1 At the same time, it’s been important for me to imagine Andrew before I met him, before his colleagues threw him under the social-justice juggernaut, back in the good old days when he was still riding high. Here one finds a remarkably gifted and versatile individual, a great teacher and colleague, a sharp thinker with a finely tuned sense of the sound and the absurd, and a talented, insightful, novelist. He was in every sense, a local star, who appeared on David Letterman, the author, among other things of The 60-Second Philosopher: Expand Your Mind on a Minute or so a Day!, and Uncommon Sense: The Strangest Ideas from the Smartest Philosophers. Just in sheer intellectual terms, Connecticut College, in their rush to judgment, trashed a rare resource, and deprived the larger community of an important, creative voice. Who knows, for some that may have been the point. I wrote this based on materials given to me by Pessin and others, in order to represent what was not made available. It describes what happened, in detail, from his perspective. Given that his perspective was precisely what no 1 For further examples specifically documenting attacks on Israel-supporters, see Anti-Zionism on Campus: The University, Free Speech and BDS, ed. Andrew Pessin and Doron Ben-Atar (Bloomington ID: Indiana University Press, 2018). There are, of course, wide ranging examples of non-Israel related incidents. See chapter by Ashley Thorne in this volume.
x one of consequence allowed to become known at the time, even as his college community was putting Pessin through a terrifying ordeal, it seemed most valuable—and fair—to expose the Connecticut College community to what they had done, viewed through the eyes of its victim. It is my fervent hope that this book will be available at the ConnColl bookstore, and widely read on campus. How often do we get the opportunity to read the voice of our unjust victim? At a certain point, Andrew and I stopped talking about these matters in any detail. I assumed he signed an agreement with his university that forbade him, some kind of non-disclosure agreement. Given that he was simultaneously dealing with deeply troubling personal and family matters (to be identified in what follows), I could hardly begrudge him having given up the right to talk about what had happened in order to have the breathing room to recover. So as the detailed conversations we had previously had ceased, I realized I was on my own. Naturally when I began to work on this book I invited him to contribute to it. I was not entirely surprised when he politely declined. As I wrote, I tried to avoid getting too close to the players. I don’t, for example, know who is who, between A, B, C, and D, in the Philosophy department. After initially trying to reach the Dean and the President without success, I have not sought to turn this into a piece of investigative journalism. Consider these the reflections of a medievalist, who pieces together a picture from fragmentary evidence. In this case, the evidence (see Pessin Archive) seems overwhelming in favor of Pessin’s reading, with very few anomalies from the “other side” to challenge this plain meaning. Any closer, more personal investigation would mean fieldwork in pervasive cognitive dissonance and “self-justifying retrospective narratives” that proliferate as a result (e.g., p. 59f.). Enough and too much. By the standards of moral and intellectual integrity that have, over the past five centuries, created the modern social miracle of academia, i.e. an institutional framework built around speaking freely, this was a shameful episode. No one behaved well, not even Pessin. Bluntly put, the Connecticut College community was put to a major moral test in the Spring of 2015, and it failed miserably. It’s not often one can make a case study of such a “cross-the-boards” failure, a kind of “Emperor’s New Clothes” scenario. They certainly deserve close examination. But rather than revel in the moral degradation of people we criticize, we need to reflect on the larger, more specific but less personal themes: whence the cowardice—individual and, so astonishingly, collective? Why the failures? What the rationalizations? Granted, when I first spoke to Pessin back in April of Preface