Palestine to Israel. Mandate to State, 1945-1948. Volume 1
Покупка
Тематика:
Внешняя политика зарубежных государств
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Penkower Monty Noam
Год издания: 2019
Кол-во страниц: 358
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-875-2
Артикул: 872385.01.99
Seventy years after the creation of the State of Israel, Palestine to Israel: Mandate to State, 1945-1948 offers the definitive narrative of the achievement of Jewish sovereignty in the beleaguered Promised Land. Professor Monty Noam Penkower explores developments in Palestine and in the Arab states, including how the Palestine quagmire became a pawn in inter-Arab feuds; British and American responses both official and public; the role of Holocaust survivors; the context of the Cold War; and the saga as it unfolded in the corridors of the United Nations. Joining extensive archival research to a lucid prose, the two volumes offer a riveting conclusion to his Palestine in Turmoil and Decision on Palestine Deferred.
Тематика:
ББК:
УДК:
ОКСО:
- ВО - Бакалавриат
- 41.03.04: Политология
- 41.03.05: Международные отношения
- 46.03.01: История
ГРНТИ:
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
PALESTINE TO ISRAEL Mandate to State, 1945-1948
Touro University Press Books Series Editors Michael A. Shmidman, PhD (Touro College, New York) Simcha Fishbane, PhD (Touro College, New York)
PALESTINE TO ISRAEL Mandate to State, 1945-1948 Volume I: Rebellion Launched, 1945-1946 Monty Noam Penkower New York 2019
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Penkower, Monty Noam, 1942- author. Title: Palestine to Israel : mandate to state, 1945-1948 / Monty N. Penkower. Description: New York, NY : Touro University Press, 2019. | Series: Touro University Press books Identifiers: LCCN 2018023261 (print) | LCCN 2018032209 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618118752 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618118738 | ISBN 9781618118738 (volume 1 : hardcover) | ISBN 9781618118745 (volume 1 : pbk.) | ISBN 9781618118769 (volume 2 : hardcover) | ISBN 9781618118776 (volume 2 : paperback) Subjects: LCSH: Palestine—History—1929-1948. | Israel—History—1948-1967. Classification: LCC DS126.4 (ebook) | LCC DS126.4 .P435 2018 (print) | DDC 956.94/04—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018023261 ISBN (hardback) 9781618118738 (vol. I) ISBN (hardback) 9781618118769 (vol. II) ISBN (paperback) 9781618118745 (vol. I) ISBN (paperback) 9781618118776 (vol. II) ISBN (electronic) 9781618118752 Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Cover design by Ivan Grave ©Touro University Press, 2019 Published by Touro University Press and Academic Studies Press. Typeset, printed and distributed by Academic Studies Press. Touro University Press Michael A. Shmidman and Simcha Fishbane, Editors 320 West 31st Street, Fourth Floor, New York, NY 10001, USA touropress.admin@touro.edu Academic Studies Press 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
To the Cherished Memory of Yael Goodman Penkower (1945–2016) “Most blessed of women be Yael” (Judges 5:24)
Table of Contents vii 1. The 100,000 1 2. Tenuat HaMeri HaIvri 72 3. The Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry 141 4. “Black Sabbath” to the Hotel Royal Monceau 210 5. Truman, Bevin, and the World Zionist Congress 275 Volume II: Into the International Arena, 1947–1948 6. To the United Nations 341 7. UNSCOP, Two Sergeants, and the Exodus 1947 405 8. Partition 472 9. Civil War 546 10. Statehood at Long Last 619 Conclusion 696 Bibliography 741 Appendix 772 Index 773
— vii — “A large problem in a small place.” Palestine, Martin Charteris later recalled of his service there as head of Military Intelligence in 1945–1946 for the local British authorities, had long been a worrisome conundrum for His Majesty’s Government.1 Ever since the 1917 Balfour Declaration pledging David Lloyd George’s World War I cabinet to facilitate “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people,” to be followed by receipt of the Palestine Mandate from the League of Nations in 1922, different ministers wrestled with Jewish and Arab competing claims to the biblical Promised Land. The struggle between these two communities for political sovereignty, emerging with force in the nineteen thirties then put on hold during World War II, surfaced again after the Allied victory in Europe of May 1945. Traumatized by the Holocaust, the hitherto unimaginable, ultimate confirmation of Jewry’s historical status as the consummate victim, Jews worldwide nailed their colors to the Zionist mast in demanding independence for Eretz Israel and thus end the curse of exile. With a thread that spooled back 3,000 years to an unbroken connection with the land which had seen their birth as a people, they noted that the Jewish foothold had never been broken when Palestine passed under many conquerors: Babylonians, Romans, Arabs, Seljuks, Crusaders, Mamelukes, Ottoman Turks, and Great Britain. The neighboring Arab states, for their part, rallied with implacable steadfastness to have what they called Falastin granted freedom. The country’s Arabs, they observed, outnumbered the Jews by more than 2:1. The remnant who survived European Jewry’s destruction, facing the anguish of irreparable loss, should be settled elsewhere, their welfare the responsibility of other powers. Democracy, whose cause had triumphed against Adolf Hitler and his comrades-inarms, demanded that the principle of national self-determination be honored and implemented for the Arab majority without further delay.
— viii — Caught in the vortex of these conflicting appeals at a time when the Empire’s finances had been impoverished by the global war, the Labour Party chieftains who took over the reins of government in July 1945 sought to temporize. The unexpected, singular response of the new occupant of the White House, Harry S. Truman, to the grim plight of the officially designated Jewish “Displaced Persons” led London and Washington to join hands in an Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry on Palestine. The yishuv (Jewish community of Eretz Israel), viewing this step as a further delay in realizing its dream of statehood, and furious that co-religionists fleeing the graveyard of Europe were denied immediate entry into the one haven of hope prepared to receive them, launched a united resistance against the mandatory. Its continued determination, along with constant attacks by underground insurgents and a firm aliya bet immigration movement for Holocaust survivors that won widespread sympathy in light of the appalling revelations of the death camps, escalated into what Winston Churchill would call in the House of Commons on March 12, 1947, the “senseless, squalid war” of 100,000 British troops (including 20,000 policemen) stationed in Palestine against the native Jewish population.2 Eminent voices on both sides of the aisle joined the leader of the Conservative opposition in calling for HMG’s prompt withdrawal. When both the Arabs and the Jews rejected provisional autonomy schemes advanced by Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin, the cabinet decided on February 14, 1947, to turn to the United Nations for advice. This internationalization of the Palestine imbroglio, coinciding with the British exit from India and elsewhere, would prove decisive in the long run. Still, with strong backing from Prime Minister Clement Attlee, Bevin persisted in his preference for a binational state that would not jeopardize British military bases and oil interests in the Middle East. The Chiefs of Staff, like their American counterparts, championed this course, all the while concerned about possible Soviet incursion into the Mediterranean and Persian Gulf. In February 1948 they suggested the incorporation of the southern and eastern parts of Palestine into Jordan and the northern part into Syria/Lebanon, effectively leaving a Jewish enclave around Tel Aviv. The U.S. State Department accepted Whitehall’s assessment, but one man’s decision against what he contemptuously labeled the “striped-pants boys” in Foggy Bottom, coupled with his deep resentment against Bevin’s casting aspersions about this Chief Executive catering to the Jewish vote, weighed heaviest in the
— ix — balance. Truman, joining his humanitarian impulses to electoral needs, bi-partisan Congressional support, a desire to forestall the Soviets in recognizing a new state that had already proven itself on the battlefield, and a wish to strengthen the UN’s future, was ultimately persuaded by an intimate circle of friends and advisors to lend his crucial support for the Jewish dream of national revival. In 1949, Simha Asaf, then rector of the Hebrew University and a member of Israel’s first Supreme Court, had to choose an awardee for the prize given by one American Jew to the individual having rendered the greatest service to Israel during the previous two years. Not surprisingly, David Ben-Gurion, who had spearheaded the crusade for statehood as chairman of the Jewish Agency for Palestine executive, received the honor. The other serious candidate, Asaf indicated on that occasion with a touch of sarcasm, was Ernest Bevin. This Britisher’s obstinacy and arrogance, best reflected in his order to send the Exodus 1947’s 4,554 refugee passengers back to Germany, dominated HMG’s policy. The Foreign Secretary believed that the Jewish state would eventually become Communist, and on another occasion used the phrase “international Jewry” with its connotation of conspiracy. While focusing on forging a strong postwar alliance with Washington, he confessed to Ambassador Halifax in October 1945 that he viewed the United States as “the untried devil.” In early 1949, Bevin summed up his exasperation as well as what Wm. Roger Louis terms the final “British perspective” on the Palestine problem with a tempestuous response. The American attitude appeared to be not only “let there be an Israel and to hell with the consequences,” he wrote on a draft to Ambassador Oliver Franks in Washington, but also “peace at any price, and Jewish expansion whatever the consequences.” Every Israeli city and settlement should erect a statue to Bevin, Abba Eban mused years later.3 The creation of Medinat Yisrael on May 14, 1948, celebrating Jewry’s heritage and restoration, was based on the fundamental premise that lay behind the Zionist revolution—lack of an independent state had accounted for endless persecution, dehumanization, and martyrdom at the hand of host countries. Imminent doom had been a feature of Jewish life ever since the Assyrian conquest of the Israelite Northern Kingdom in the year 722 BCE. The wandering Jew, cast out for millennia from Eretz Israel and subsequent, temporary places of refuge, validated Isaac Deutscher’s epithet “Trees have roots, Jews have legs.” “The Jews have taught me how to wait,” wrote an admiring Henrik Ibsen
— x — in the play Peer Gynt (1867). Keepers of the faith, praying “Next year in Jerusalem!,” waited for the Messiah to return them home. Writing to his friend Max Brod, Franz Kafka described Jews “with their hind legs fastened to the Jewish traditions of their fathers and with their forelegs getting no ground under their feet. The despair thus ensuing translates into inspiration.” In February 1942, Stefan Zweig, with fond memories of Vienna’s glamour and grace depicted in his subsequently published The World of Yesterday, thanked Brazil for giving him and his wife Elizabet shelter from the Nazi obsession to kill every Jew. He added that with his spiritual home, Europe, “having destroyed itself,” “unusual powers are needed in order to make another wholly new beginning. Those that I possess have been exhausted by long years of homeless wandering.” He and his wife, holding hands, then took their own lives.4 “Homelessness and hopelessness, that is the lot of our brethren!” observed U.S. Army Chaplain Abraham J. Klausner in Munich to a fellow rabbi in the United States while trying to meet the basic needs of 34,000 of the 45,000 survivors living in the American occupied zone of Germany in February 1946. Rejecting any further delay, the heralds of Zionism sought to bring an end to their people’s homelessness, the “pariah condition” which Nahum Goldmann told United Nations Special Committee on Palestine chairman Emil Sandström could no longer obtain after the Holocaust.5 The belief in education and assimilation, which sustained so many European Jews and to which Bevin and colleagues sedulously adhered, had foundered catastrophically on the shoals of the Shoah. Before it was too late, Zionist champions insisted, Auschwitz obliged Jews to summon a future of national identity and purpose into being. Theodor Herzl, the founder of political Zionism, had concluded his manifesto Der Judenstaat (The State of the Jews) in February 1896 with a conviction: “If you will it, it is no dream.” The time had come to transform this assertion into reality, ground a distinct people to roots in their ancestral soil, give them sanctuary, and lighten the darkness. To achieve this objective, the new beginning of which Zweig had despaired, appeared nothing short of fantasy after the Holocaust. The Zionists’ task would be Herculean. Arab intractable animosity, both in Palestine and beyond its borders, became quickly manifest. Consistent British opposition turned into a dialogue of the deaf. The stance of the Kremlin, long averse to Jewish nationalism and, consequently, that of