Anti-Shechita Prosecutions in the Anglo-American World, 1855-1913: "A major attack on Jewish freedoms”
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Fraser David
Год издания: 2018
Кол-во страниц: 259
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-743-4
Артикул: 872356.01.99
This is the first study of historical attempts by animal welfare groups to ban the Jewish method of slaughter (shechita). It details cases from Australia, Canada, England, Scotland, and the United States, many for the first time, in which anti-animal cruelty groups prosecuted those engaged in shechita as part of their attempts to introduce compulsory stunning of animals before slaughter. Despite claims to the contrary, this study offers clear evidence of underlying, unrelenting antisemitic motivations in the prosecutions, and highlights the ways in which a basic idea of innate Jewish cruelty was always juxtaposed with an overtly Christian ideal of humane treatment of animals across time and borders.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Anti-Shechita Prosecutions in the Anglo-American World, 1855–1913 “A major attack on Jewish freedoms…”
North American Jewish Studies Series Editor IRA ROBINSON (Concordia University)
Boston Anti-Shechita Prosecutions in the Anglo-American World, 1855–1913 “A major attack on Jewish freedoms…”1 DAVID FRASER 1 David Rome, The Jewish Biography of Henri Bourassa, Part 1 (Montreal: National Archives of the Canadian Jewish Congress, 1988), 94.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Fraser, David, 1953-, author. Title: Anti-shechita prosecutions in the Anglo-American world, 1855-1913: a major attack on Jewish freedoms / David Fraser. Description: Brighton, MA : Academic Studies Press, [2018] | Series: North American Jewish studies Identifiers: LCCN 2018006489 (print) | LCCN 2018006683 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618117434 (e-book) | ISBN 9781618117427 (hardback) Subjects: LCSH: Shehitah—Case studies. | Livestock—Stunning—Case studies. | Animal rights movement—Case studies. | Meat industry and trade—Law and legislation—Case studies. | Religious discrimination—Law and legislation—Case studies. | BISAC: NATURE / Animal Rights. | RELIGION / Judaism / Rituals & Practice. | COOKING / Regional & Ethnic / Jewish & Kosher. Classification: LCC BM720.S62 (ebook) | LCC BM720.S62 F73 2018 (print) | DDC 296.7/3—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018006489 ISBN (hardback) 978-1-61811-742-7 ISBN (electronic) 978-1-61811-743-4 © 2018 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Cover design by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press in 2018 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Table of Contents Acknowledgments vi Introduction: Jews, Shechita, and the Law viii 1. Criminalizing Shechita: The Halifax Prosecution of Abraham Levitt, 1913 1 2. The Aberdeen Shechita Case of 1893: Criminalizing the Jewish Method in Scotland 28 3. The Mansion House Case: Anti-Shechita in London, 1855 56 4. Manchester Shechita: Criminalizing Orthodox Judaism 1878 and Beyond 74 5. The Birkenhead Shechita Cases 85 6. Criminalizing Shechita Down Under: The Sydney Case 103 7. Outlawing Shechita in America 134 8. The Massachusetts Anti-Shechita Story 168 9. The End (or Not) of the Story: Shechita and the Law in the Anglo-American World, 1855–1913 199 Bibliography 215 Index 230
Acknowledgments T hanks to the many archivists and librarians who made this book possible. Staff at the Boston Public Library, the British Library, the Halifax Public Library, the London Metropolitan Archives, the Liverpool Record Office, the Manchester Central Library Archives Service, the New York Public Library, the Nova Scotia Archives, and the Wirral Archives Service assisted. Colin Spanjar granted access to the files of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, and Charles Tucker, Record Keeper of the London Beth Din, allowed consultation of the files of the Office the Chief Rabbi. Judi Garner at the American Jewish Historical Society (AJHS) in Boston granted access to the Friedman Family papers. The AJHS in New York provided important information. Rachel Reddick of the Stephen H. Hart Library and Research Center, History Colorado, made available historic Colorado newspaper coverage. Archivist Heather Perez at the Atlantic City Free Public Library assisted in finding local newspaper files, as did staff at the Attleboro and Providence Public Libraries. Robert Thornton, Senior Archivist, Adelaide City Archives, provided valuable information. Emily Hanna of State Records New South Wales helped with information concerning Sydney. Emily Chapin, Collections Access Archivist at the Museum of the City of New York, assisted with the Henry Bergh correspondence. David Allen responded with kindness to inquiries on the archival holdings of the RSPCA. Jan Holmquist of the Massachusetts Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals answered my questions, and Debra A. Gardella of the Massachusetts Superior Court, Fall River and James P. Perkoski, First Assistant Clerk-Magistrate, Attleboro District Court, generously assisted in tracking down the remaining information on the 1910–1911 case from Attleboro. Gina Y. Hodges, Administrator of the Atlantic City Municipal Court searched for files on the Kaplowitz case. Josh Jasper, Librarian and Archivist at the Rhode Island Jewish Historical Association was invaluable in finding information on the relationship between the Jewish community in Providence
vii Acknowledgments and the Jews of rural Massachusetts and identifying Rabbi Katznelson. Kevin Luy of the Colorado State Archives provided the records of the Wolf Heller case. Vaughan Black and Sheila Wildman shared insights into the history of law and animals in Halifax. This project started in the files of the Alex Dworkin Canadian Jewish Archives in Montreal. Janice Rosen and Hélène Lavallée are an inspiration and to them this is yet another expression of my gratitude. My sincere gratitude to Professor Ira Robinson and the Concordia Institute for Canadian Jewish Studies for their support in publishing this book. The opinions expressed herein are my own. As always, this is for Kathryn.
Introduction: Jews, Shechita, and the Law The Historical and Linguistic Stakes I n the spring of 1913, Abraham Levitt, rabbi of the small Jewish community in Halifax, Nova Scotia was charged on the information of an inspector of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty, with inflicting ill-treatment on, and causing unnecessary suffering to, a heifer. According to the local newspaper coverage of the case, this was “the first time in American history that a rabbi has been haled before the courts in a case of this kind.”1 After a hearing lasting several days, Levitt was convicted and fined six dollars plus seven dollars and sixty-five cents in costs. For the first time in the history of the American continent a Jewish rabbi had been fined for killing an animal according to the Jewish belief, namely by cutting its throat without prior stunning.2 The historian of Montreal and Canadian Jewry, David Rome, later wrote that, “because Halifax is so distant from the centres of Canadian Jewry a very important anti-Semitic case in that city, classic in its form, received very little attention and has since been virtually lost to memory.”3 This book remedies the gap identified by Rome by returning the Halifax case to our collective legal and historical memory. It interrogates the often-competing discourses of the anti-cruelty movement in the early twentieth century, narrow positivistic renderings of legal texts, and ideas of religious 1 “The Halifax Hebrew Rabbi Is Before Stipendiary Magistrate’s Court,” Halifax Herald, April 2, 1903. 2 “Jewish Rabbi Fined by the Stipendiary,” Halifax Herald, April 22, 1913. 3 The Jewish Biography of Henri Bourassa, 94.
ix freedom and practice that circulated around, and informed the context of, the prosecution of Rabbi Levitt. It is necessary to place events in Halifax in 1913 in broader social, political, and socio-legal historical contexts that surrounded local, national, and international debates about animal welfare and about the place of growing Jewish communities in North America. At first blush, the singular prosecution of Abraham Levitt, apparently the only recorded instance of an animal cruelty case and conviction of a Jew engaged in the religiously ordained killing of an animal in North American legal history, might seem to be a minor historical event at the geographical and demographic margins of Canada, North America, and the British Empire. This study highlights the ways in which this singular instance of legal prosecution embodied matters of historical, social, and cultural significance that went far beyond the fate of Abraham Levitt and the small Jewish community of Halifax. It brings to light other instances of attempts to criminalize Jewish religious slaughter in the common-law world, demonstrating how and why the singular instance of the Halifax case was, contrary to coverage at the time, not at all singular. Instead it fits into a pattern of actions by animal welfare groups targeting the Jewish method of slaughtering animals for food over a significant period of time and in a variety of jurisdictions. I seek to recover for historical memory the vital role of these anti-shechita prosecutions in the legal and social history of Jewry in the different places they occurred. By bringing to light these other attempts to criminalize and abolish shechita, the process of interrogating the hermeneutic and narrative similarities that informed each of these now somewhat obscured legal instances, in which observant Jews were prosecuted for practices central to their religious identity in the name of humane values, can begin. The prosecution of Abraham Levitt in Halifax on the eve of the First World War was not as singular or isolated as David Rome believed. An important goal of this study is to begin to trace a socio-legal history of attempts in the English-speaking world to criminalize the practice of the Jewish mode of killing animals in the name of the competing value of animal welfare and to interrogate the hows and whys of legal processes that contrast in a negative and harmful way, humane values and Jewish religious observance. Each instance highlights the common conflicts that occurred in the legal regulatory realm as a public good, animal welfare, encountered another public good, the need to recognize and accommodate religious practice. While each clearly occurred at different times and in distinct geographical spaces, neither Jewish communities nor animal welfare groups acted in complete isolation from their fellows, nor did they always operate in ignorance of the
x real legal history of attempts to criminalize the Jewish method of slaughter. Networks of knowledge, shared values and history, and group solidarity operated on both sides of these struggles. The Halifax case of 1913 underscores the ways in which discourses of solidarity among Canadian Jewish communities were at play, as were national and transnational practices and networks of knowledge relating to the anti-cruelty movement in Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom. The Halifax legal action must be understood not just in relation to the specificities of the case itself, but in these contexts and discourses that went well beyond a single conviction of a solitary Jew in a small Jewish community at the geographic and social fringes of the Canadian federation, the British Empire, and Canadian Jewry. The patterns that emerge in these cases will elucidate the fashion in which Jewish communities have been forced to struggle for recognition and equality in the midst of social, cultural, political (and legal) contexts that invoked a fundamental distinction between the normal and Christian human spirit and a Jewish world tainted by an equally Christian imaginary around the central trope of blood.4 Societies for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or Humane Societies did not hesitate to claim that their sole aim was the protection of “God’s dumb animals” and that they acted from this moral and theological imperative. Jewish communities defended shechita in terms of their obligations as observant practitioners of their faith. The anti-shechita prosecutions bring to the light the difficult, if not impossible, task involved in the historical articulation of a broadly acceptable and accepted social, political, moral, and juridical position in cases where each claimant invokes holy writ in demanding the legal recognition and embodiment of its claims. When Abraham Levitt killed the heifer in a slaughterhouse in Halifax in the spring of 1913, he did so as part of his duties as shochet, an individual trained in the killing of animals according to the methods prescribed by Jewish law. For observant Jews, the shochet “is more like a High Priest, for he must be a god-like man, a skillful [sic] man in his profession; a learned man, who chooses this humble and dangerous calling, because he believes it his mission to so serve not only his generation; but the generations to come.”5 4 Anthony Bale and David Feldman, eds., Blood: Reflections on What Unites and Divides Us (Oxford: Shire, 2016). 5 Friedman Family / Friedman, Aaron / Aaron’s Life as Shochet / n.d. Friedman Family Papers; P-948; Box 1, Folder 1, American Jewish Historical Society, New York and Boston.