Philo’s Heirs: Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas
Покупка
Тематика:
Общая история философии
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Cortest Luis
Год издания: 2017
Кол-во страниц: 135
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-631-4
Артикул: 872351.01.99
The central claim of this book is that Philo of Alexandria’s philosophical method served as the model for the philosophical works of Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas. Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas stand as two pillars in the history of religious philosophy. In their respective religious communities each philosopher is considered the great master who expressed the doctrine of the religious tradition in philosophical terms. One of the most important points established in this book is that both of these thinkers inherited a set of standard philosophical topics (divine attributes, creation ex nihilo, divine providence, etc.) which were first developed as philosophical/religious questions by Philo. In effect, Philo’s philosophical method shaped the history of Western philosophy until the late seventeenth century.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Philo’s Heirs: Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Cortest, Luis, author. Title: Philo's heirs : Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas / Luis Cortest, The University of Oklahoma. Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2017. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2017012866 (print) | LCCN 2017027277 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618116314 (e-book) | ISBN 9781618116307 (hardcover) Subjects: LCSH: Philo, of Alexandria—Influence. | Maimonides, Moses, 1135-1204. | Thomas, Aquinas, Saint, 1225?-1274. Classification: LCC B689.Z7 (ebook) | LCC B689.Z7 C675 2017 (print) | DDC 181/.06—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2017012866 © Academic Studies Press, 2017 ISBN 978-1-61811-630-7 (hardcover) ISBN 978-1-61811-631-4 (e-book) Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. www.kryonpublishing.com Published by Academic Studies Press in 2017 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA P: (617)782-6290 F: (857)241-3149 press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Boston Philo’s Heirs: Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas LUIS CORTEST
Acknowledgement of Outside Financial Support I wish to thank the Office of the Senior Vice President and Provost, the College of Arts and Sciences and the Office of the Vice President for Research at the University of Oklahoma for their generous support in the preparation and publication of this book.
For Rachel
Contents Preface vii Chapter 1 The Marriage of Athens and Jerusalem: Philo of Alexandria 01 Chapter 2 Christian Philosophy after Philo 20 Chapter 3 The Rabbi and the Friar at a Glance 33 Chapter 4 The Divine Attributes 40 Chapter 5 In the Beginning 54 Chapter 6 Divine Providence 66 Chapter 7 Natural Law 80 Chapter 8 Prophecy 100 Conclusion 111 Bibliography 113 Index 120
Preface I t was the great Harry Austryn Wolfson who first argued that Philo Judaeus (ca. 20 BC–ca. 50 AD) had established the foundational model that subsequent religious philosophers would imitate in the three monotheistic traditions. In his monumental study of Philo, Wolfson concluded that Philo had added a new dimension to Greek philosophy when he utilized its principles to analyze scripture. In so doing, Philo created a new kind of religious philosophy that would serve as the standard for seventeen centuries: This fundamental departure from pagan Greek philosophy . . . appears first in Hellenistic Judaism, where it attains its systematic formulation in Philo. Philo is the founder of this new school of philosophy, and from him it directly passes on to the Gospel of St. John and the Church Fathers, from whom it passes on to Moslem and hence also to mediaeval Jewish philosophy. Philo is the direct or indirect source of this type of philosophy which continues uninterruptedly in its main assertions for well-nigh seventeen centuries, when at last it is openly challenged by Spinoza.1 This bold claim, though accepted by many scholars in Wolfson’s time, has been challenged by Philo scholars in recent years. David T. Runia, one of the most important contributors to our knowledge of Philo and his legacy, has been very critical of Wolfson’s methodology.2 Runia has also described Wolfson’s view of the history of philosophy as “Judaeo-centric” since Wolfson believed that Philo and Baruch Spinoza served as two “turning-points” in the history of philosophy.3 While it is true that Wolfson 1 Harry Austryn Wolfson, Philo: Foundations of Religious Philosophy in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1948), 2:457. 2 David T. Runia, Philo in Early Christian Literature (Assen, NL: Van Gorcum, 1993), 50–55.
viii Preface was especially interested in describing the philosophical contributions of these two Jewish thinkers, his general claim concerning Philo’s method and its impact on religious philosophers, as well as his thesis that Spinoza’s philosophy represents a radical break with the past, are views that many contemporary scholars still accept. Indeed, it would be hard to argue that Philo and Spinoza are not “turning-points” in the history of philosophy if one understands Philo’s role in the transformation of religious philosophy and is willing to acknowledge the fact that Spinoza must be regarded as one of the most important thinkers in the cultural shift from the early modern period to the Enlightenment.4 Even if one disagrees with Runia, however, it is clear that Runia and others have provided much-needed clarification on the question of Philo’s influence on subsequent philosophers and theologians. In some ways the work of these scholars helps fill in the gaps left by the broad strokes painted by Wolfson. While Wolfson was firmly convinced that Philo’s philosophical approach would guide philosophers up to the time of Spinoza, he spent less time tracking down the indirect and often obscure references to Philo found throughout the Middle Ages. If we examine Runia’s careful remarks about Philo’s medieval legacy, we get a good idea of the difference between the scholarly approaches of Runia and Wolfson: Throughout this period Philo was considered the author of one of the semi-canonical books of the Bible. As we saw in our account of the survival of Philo’s writings, during the Middle Ages a slender liber Philonis was in circulation, containing the notice on Philo from Jerome’s De viris illustribus, the Pseudo-Philonic Liber antiquitatum, and the Old Latin translation of Quaestiones in Genesim IV and De vita contemplativa. The history of this manuscript tradition has been traced with a fair degree of probability to the Abbey of St. Riquier in Western France, where it is mentioned in a catalogue dated 831. No doubt it was brought there by the founder of the Abbey 4 In fact, a number of important studies have appeared in recent years in which this claim is made; one of the most important is that of Jonathan Israel, Radical Enlightenment: Philosophy and the Making of Modernity 1650–1750 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001). Although his work has an entirely different focus than that of Jonathan Israel, Carlos Fraenkel’s Philosophical Religions from Plato to Spinoza (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012) must also be mentioned. Fraenkel studies the history of philosophical religions from the time of Plato and includes a careful examination of the contribution of Philo. Once again, his study shows quite convincingly that the philosophy of Spinoza represents an important break with the religious philosophy produced before his time.
ix Preface in 790, Angilbert, who made three journeys to Italy and gave 200 mss. to the Library of the Abbey.5 Obviously, from the evidence presented here by Runia, it is clear that Philo, as an author, was known by at least some writers in the Middle Ages. If Wolfson was known as a bold scholar, who sought most of all a comprehensive and convincing interpretation of the history of philosophy, Runia must be considered a very meticulous and careful scholar by modern standards. Runia finds the records and connects authors by time and place. Wolfson was especially concerned with the survival of ideas. The central claim of this book is that Philo’s philosophical method survived at least into the High Middle Ages. I argue that Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas were both intellectual heirs of Philo. Although Philo is almost never mentioned by name by either philosopher, both follow a path that was first cleared by Philo in Alexandria. Thomas Aquinas and Moses Maimonides stand as two giants in the history of religious philosophy. In their respective religious communities, both are considered great masters who expressed the doctrine of their religious tradition in philosophical terms. Though both of these teachers lived in different places at different times, their philosophical projects were in some ways quite similar. Indeed, both thinkers were convinced that the most profound religious truths could be expressed philosophically without compromising the content. The philosophical vocabularies of both masters are strikingly similar since both utilize principles derived from medieval forms of Aristotelianism. Moses Maimonides, who died in 1204, wrote his most important philosophical text, the Guide for the Perplexed, in Arabic because, even though he was a Jew, he was born and lived in a cultural world shaped by the great Islamic thinkers. That tradition itself had inherited many of the most important ideas from Greek, Roman, and Hellenistic philosophy. Thomas Aquinas, who died in 1274, adopted a Christianized form of Aristotelian philosophy shaped by Neoplatonic incursions.6 Aquinas developed his system within the context of the medieval European university curriculum, where, long before his time, philosophy had been studied by the masters of theology. Although many important sources can be identified in his works, his own 5 Runia, Philo in Early Christian Literature, 331. 6 For a discussion of these same “Neoplatonic incursions,” see Luis Cortest, “Was St. Thomas Aquinas a Platonist?” The Thomist, 52, no. 2 (April 1988): 209–19.
x Preface teacher, Albertus Magnus (ca. 1200–1280), a key figure in the reception of the works of Aristotle in the Christian West, should be considered of primary importance. Thomas wrote his works in Latin, the language of philosophy in those same universities. His readership included students and masters of theology from the religious orders of his day. The subject of the present book, the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas and Moses Maimonides as understood within the tradition first established by Philo, must also include a very brief examination of the history of philosophy in Jewish, Christian, and Islamic thought before the time of these two great teachers. This is so because neither Maimonides nor Aquinas created their respective philosophical systems ex nihilo. One of the most important points I wish to show in this book is that both of these thinkers, even though they belonged to different traditions, inherited a list of standard philosophical topics. I argue that these topics (divine attributes, creation ex nihilo, divine providence, etc.) were first developed as philosophical/religious questions by Philo. Philo was the first major philosopher to utilize the language and methods of philosophy to examine the truths established by revealed religion. Even though Philo was a Jew, his philosophical approach was quickly adopted by Christian writers in Alexandria. These same writers (in particular, Clement of Alexandria and Origen) would become the first great philosophical theologians in the history of the Christian church. Whether it is true that Philo had little impact on subsequent Jewish thinkers (as so many scholars believe), his influence on Christian thought was vast. In effect, he taught Christian writers how to read allegorically and how to use the language and methods of philosophy to explicate Christian doctrine. In this book, I have called both Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas “heirs of Philo.” It would be overstating the case to call these two thinkers direct heirs since neither quotes directly from any of Philo’s works. What both philosophers inherit from Philo indirectly is a method, a way of doing philosophy, and a list of the most important questions that religious philosophers must address. Maimonides inherited this method and these questions from his Islamic predecessors; Aquinas inherited the same method and questions from the Christian philosophers who came before him and from Maimonides.