From antisemitism to anti-Zionism: the past & present of a lethal ideology
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Под ред.:
Pollack Eunice G.
Год издания: 2017
Кол-во страниц: 456
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-566-9
Артикул: 872346.01.99
Leading scholars use the lenses of history, sociology, political science, psychology, philosophy, religion, and literature to examine, disentangle, and remove the disguises of the many forms of antisemitism and anti-Zionism that have inhabited or targeted the English-speaking world in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. Although in principle one can be anti-Zionist without being antisemitic, authors document and trace the numerous parallels and continuities between the hoary tropes attached for centuries to the Jewish people and the more recent vilifications of the Jewish state. They evaluate — and discredit — many of the central claims anti-Zionists have promoted in their relentless effort to delegitimize the Jewish state. They show how mainstream anti-racist communities, courses and texts have ignored — or denied — the antisemitic hatred that pervades much of the Muslim world.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
From Antisemitism To Anti-Zionism THE PAST & PRESENT OF A LETHAL IDEOLOGY
Antisemitism in America Series Editor Eunice G. Pollack (University of North Texas)
Boston From Antisemitism To Anti-Zionism THE PAST & PRESENT OF A LETHAL IDEOLOGY edited by EUNICE G. POLLACK
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Pollack, Eunice G., editor. Title: From antisemitism to anti-Zionism : the past & present of a lethal ideology / editor Eunice G. Pollack. Description: Brighton, MA : Academic Studies Press, [2017] Series: Antisemitism in America | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2016052711 (print) | LCCN 2016053248 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618115652 (hardback) | ISBN 9781618115669 (e-book) Subjects: LCSH: Antisemitism—United States. | Antisemitism—Europe. | Antisemitism—History—21st century. | Zionism—United States. | Arab-Israeli conflict—1993—Influence. Classification: LCC DS146.U6 F76 2017 (print) | LCC DS146.U6 (ebook) | DDC 305.892/4—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016052711 Copyright© 2017, Academic Studies Press ISBN 978-1-61811-565-2 (hardcover) ISBN 978-1-61811-566-9 (electronic) Book design by Kryon Publishing www.kryonpublishing.com Academic Studies Press 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA www.academicstudiespress.com press@academicstudiespress.com
Preface: From a Pariah People to a Pariah State Eunice G. Pollack vii PART I Denying Antisemitism 1 CHAPTER 1 How Raising the Issue of Antisemitism Puts You Outside the Community of the Progressive: The Livingstone Formulation David Hirsh 2 CHAPTER 2 The Great Failure of the Anti-Racist Community: The Neglect of Muslim Antisemitism in English-Language Courses, Textbooks, and Research Neil J. Kressel 29 PART II Antisemitism in America Before—and After— The Founding of the Jewish State: The Elites and the Masses 69 CHAPTER 3 Antisemitism in the White House Rafael Medoff 70 CHAPTER 4 Antisemitic Terror, Defeatism, and Anti-Zionism: Coughlinism and the Christian Front, 1934–1955 Stephen H. Norwood 113 CHAPTER 5 Entertaining Nazi Warriors in America, 1934–1936 Stephen H. Norwood 148 Contents
Contents vi PART III Anti-Zionism: Antisemitism Since the Holocaust CHAPTER 6 The Wages of Moral Schadenfreude in the Press: Anti-Zionism and European Jihad Richard Landes 186 CHAPTER 7 Palestinian Identity Theft and the Delegitimization of Israel: Jerold S. Auerbach 215 CHAPTER 8 Foundation Myths of Anti-Zionism Eunice G. Pollack 227 CHAPTER 9 Past and Present: Plus Ça Change, Plus C’est la Me me Chose Edward Alexander 265 PART IV Zionist and Anti-Zionist Theologies: Christian Zionists, Islamic Jihadists, and the Jewish State 279 CHAPTER 10 Christian Zionism: Is It Good for the Jews? Benjamin Ginsberg 280 CHAPTER 11 Holy Land, Sacred History, and Anti-Zionism David Patterson 311 PART V Contemporary Antisemitism: The Unending Threat 333 CHAPTER 12 Zionism through the Internet’s Looking Glass Andre Oboler 334 CHAPTER 13 Perspectives on Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism in Contemporary Canada Ira Robinson 361 CHAPTER 14 The Delegitimization—and Relegitimization— of Israel Joel Fishman 387 Contributors 405 Index 408
Preface Eunice G. Pollack Since the Holocaust, in much of the Western world, the expression or acknowledgment of antisemitic views came to be considered unacceptable. Over the last half century, however, even febrile anti-Zionist pronouncements increasingly elicit no censure—are routinely applauded—no matter how readily recognizable they are as updated versions of the world’s oldest hatred. The overlap has become so substantial, so frequent, that Benjamin Ginsberg finds that although “it is . . . possible to be anti-Zionist without being antisemitic . . ., what is true in principle is often not so true in practice.” United by their anti-Zionism, “‘green/brown’ alliances . . . between progressives and neo-Nazis [now] find common ground on the Jewish question.” Similarly, Jerold Auerbach identifies anti-Zionism as “the currently fashionable expression of antisemitism.” Anti-Zionism and antisemitism have often become so intertwined, he observes, that “gullible students claiming to be ‘progressive’ (while failing to understand their own antisemitism) have flocked to the cause [of Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions—BDS].” He concludes that “a generation of students . . . brainwashed by their professors into believing the worst about Israel . . . have unknowingly endorsed the final solution to the Jewish problem embraced by every maniacal dictator from Titus to Hitler.” Not infrequently, however, the anti-Zionist veil is fully lifted, and the old familiar features of antisemitism cannot be gainsaid. Exposed by David Patterson, the glaring countenance is unmistakable in
viii Nobel laureate José Saramago’s 2002 depiction of Israel as “a racist state by virtue of Judaism’s monstrous doctrines—racist not just against the Palestinians, but against the entire world, which it seeks to manipulate and abuse.” Similarly, the declamation of the anti-Zionist Salafist Sheikh Muhammad Hussein Yaqoub, broadcast in 2009, reveals his naked, artless antisemitism: “If the Jews left Palestine to us, would we start loving them? Of course not. . .. Our fighting with the Jews is eternal, and it will not end . . ., until not a single Jew remains on the face of the Earth.” Thus the contributors to From Antisemitism to Anti-Zionism— utilizing the lenses of history, sociology, political science, psychology, philosophy, religion, and literature—examine, disentangle, and remove the disguises from the many forms of antisemitism and anti-Zionism inhabiting the English-speaking world, past and present. One of the major themes of this study—a phenomenon the authors encountered again and again—is the widespread refusal to acknowledge even blatant antisemitism—the elephant in the middle of the room. Alternatively, antisemitism is evaded by recrafting it— defending it—as only a rational response to alleged execrable actions—no longer attributed to Jews, but to the Jewish state. The accusation of the modern antisemite is not the hoary deicide charge, but one more potent in an increasingly secular age—that of genocide committed by the Jewish state. Still, in an era in which the enlightened scrutinize themselves and all others for traces of racism, sexism, homophobia—and recently, Islamophobia—and condemn putative microaggressions against those identified as minority groups, the mandatory diversity curricula and training rarely devote any attention to antisemitism, anti-Zionism, or Jews. Thus Part I exposes and analyzes the many facets of “antisemitism denial.” In Chapter 1, David Hirsh finds among a number of prominent political, academic, and media figures in England not only “a recurrent pattern of refusal even to try” to recognize one’s antisemitism, but also the ready disclaimer of bigotry that all “I am doing is criticizing Israel.” Their response to any accusation of
ix antisemitism is the counteraccusation that the accuser’s “real concern” can only be “to silence . . . criticisms of Israeli human rights abuses.” Hirsh is led to conclude that “hostility to Israel is becoming more and more a marker of belonging on the contemporary Left.” The deflection and denial of any accusation of antisemitism have, however, “inoculated the progressive movement not against antisemitism itself, but against having to take the issue of antisemitism seriously.” In Chapter 2, Neil Kressel approaches the issue from another angle, but he too finds that antisemitism—if not denied—is simply ignored. After showing that there exists a “cauldron of antisemitic hatred in much of the Muslim world,” which is “widespread, intense, and deeply ingrained, dangerous, and growing,” he finds it “jolting” that the “mainstream anti-racist community in the United States”— or in the West—rarely acknowledges it—and even those who do, try “to attribute this bigotry to sources remote from Islam per se.” When Kressel turns to social scientists’ study of antisemitism, once again, his findings are “startling,” for “the social sciences, which once built major theoretical advances upon research into the origins of Jew-hatred, have all but abandoned the topic.” His review of the massive PSYCHINFO index of peer-reviewed social scientific studies finds that only a minuscule percentage of the entries (1990– 2009) that “examined racism, prejudice, or discrimination . . . focused on antisemitism,” and “most of those items . . . dealt with the Holocaust.” Similarly, his survey of “standard textbooks” and syllabi of courses on “prejudice, racism, or diversity” reveals only minimal attention to antisemitism, and the complete neglect of Muslims’ “anti-Jewish bigotry.” Indeed, “anti-Islamic bigotry and anti-Arab bigotry are covered more heavily.” Part II focuses on the historical dimensions of antisemitism in the United States, shining new light on the bigotry of both elites and the masses. Here it is not only the efforts to ignore antisemitism that are exposed, but the determination to erase it from the historical record. Rafael Medoff, in Chapter 3, systematically examines the frequent, profoundly antisemitic comments and analyses of
x presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry S Truman, and Richard M. Nixon. There is President Nixon speaking of “Jew boys,” a “kike,” imagining a “Jewish cabal,” and denouncing his attorney—“Goddamn his Jewish soul!” There is Truman writing (in 1945!): “The Jews claim God Almighty picked ’em out for special privilege. Well I’m sure he had better judgment.” And FDR, boasting to a senator that “there is no Jewish blood in our veins,” and rationalizing “German antisemitism as an ‘understandable’ response to Jewish behavior.” Medoff points out, however, that despite holding antisemitic views, Truman extended “de facto recognition [to] the newborn State of Israel” and Nixon provided “the massive American airlift of arms to Israel in the 1973 Yom Kippur War.” By contrast, FDR’s antisemitism shaped his deleterious policies toward Jewish refugees during the years of the Third Reich, infecting “his otherwise inexplicable policy of suppressing Jewish immigration far below the legal limits” of the time. Here too the antisemitism is literally blotted out. Medoff recounts that, for the most part, the public did not learn of the presidents’ bigotry until long after they had left office. The extent and depth of Nixon’s antisemitism became evident only upon the release of Oval Office tapes in the 1990s and from 2009 to 2013, though he died in 1994. Medoff observes that Truman “long enjoyed near-heroic status in the Jewish community,” because his highly antisemitic characterizations of Jews remained largely unknown until 1983 and 2003, though he left office in 1953 and died in 1972. The public was “shocked” by the revelations, because noted historians had watered down—and had even chosen “to withhold evidence” of—Truman’s “private expressions about Jews.” Indeed, Medoff explains that the classic studies of America’s response to the Holocaust, published in the 1960s and 70s, attributed FDR’s actions “entirely . . . [to] political and military considerations,” because the evidence of his “private attitudes toward Jews” remained buried. Here too eminent scholars chose to omit any mention of Roosevelt’s disturbing antisemitic exchanges and refrained from publishing documentation of his antisemitic statements. Notably, Medoff contends that even in a 2013