Sexuality and the Body in the New Religious-Zionist Discourse
Покупка
Тематика:
Иудаизм
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Год издания: 2015
Кол-во страниц: 301
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-453-2
Артикул: 694144.02.99
Religious-Zionism developed in Israel as an attempt to combine halakhic commitment with the values of modernity, two networks of meaning not easily reconciled. This book presents a study of the discourse on the body and sexuality within religious-Zionism as it has developed in recent decades, including in cyberspace, and considers such issues as homosexuality, lesbianism, masturbation, and the relationships between the sexes. It also analyzes the shift to a pastoral discourse and alternative religious perspectives dealing with this discourse together with its far wider social and cultural implications, offering a new paradigm for reading religious cultures.
Тематика:
ББК:
УДК:
ОКСО:
- ВО - Бакалавриат
- 47.03.01: Философия
- 47.03.02: Прикладная этика
- 47.03.03: Религиоведение
ГРНТИ:
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Sexuality and the Body in the New Religious-Zionist Discourse
Isr ael: Societ y, Culture and History Yaacov Yadgar—Political Studies, Bar-Ilan University, Series Editor Editorial Board Alan Dowty— Political Science and Middle Eastern Studies, University of Notre Dame Tamar Katriel—Communication Ethnography, University of Haifa Avi Sagi—Hermeneutics, Cultural studies, and Philosophy, Bar-Ilan University Allan Silver—Sociology, Columbia University Anthony D. Smith—Nationalism and Ethnicity, London School of Economics Yael Zerubavel—Jewish Studies and History, Rutgers University
Boston Sexuality and the Body in the New Religious-Zionist Discourse Yakir Englander and Avi Sagi Tr ansl ated by Batya Stein
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: A bibliographic record for this title is available from the Library of Congress. Copyright © 2015 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN 978-1-61811-452-5 (cloth) ISBN 978-1-61811-453-2 (electronic) Cover design by Ivan Grave with Inbal Pinto. Published by Academic Studies Press in 2015 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
We dedicate this book with love and longing to our teacher and friend, the late David Hartman. David attested in his life to the power of critical ethical commitment, with which he ushered in new philosophical and educational visions. This book, which was inspired by his spirit, continues our dialogue with him and faces up to the challenge of critical loyalty that he set to all of us.
The research for this work and its publication was generously supported by the Shalom Hartman Institute, Jerusalem.
Contents
Acknowledgments
9
Chapter 1. The New Religious-Zionist Halakhah:
18
A Conceptual Outline
Chapter 2. The Shift in the Discourse: Autarchic Male Sexuality
26
Mapping Reactions
34
The Pastoral Discourse
52
A Haredi Alternative
70
Chapter 3. The Shift in the Discourse: Autarchic Female Sexuality
78
Female Sexuality: Masturbation and Lesbianism
79
Mapping Reactions
85
The Effects of the Value Discourse on Halakhic Rulings
93
Chapter 4. Real and Imagined Women
120
Defining Women
123
The Conflict Discourse
135
Excluding Real Women
166
The Female Refusal
180
On Female Sexuality
183
Chapter 5. The Other Voice
193
Attitudes toward Homosexuality
194
and Lesbianism in the New Discourse
The Haredi Responsum
200
The Religious Protest
206
Looking Back
214
Chapter 6. Concluding Reflections:
231
From a Realist Disposition to an Imagined Realm
Appendix. The Discourse on Sexuality, Metaphysics,
243
and Messianism
Bibliography
276
Index
293
Acknowledgements We are grateful to colleagues who commented, corrected mistakes, and showed us what was missing: the late Yosef Ahituv, Iris Brown, Tova Cohen, Jose Gandara, Hugh Grant, Tova Hartman, Ronit Ir-Shai, Nissim Leon, Lee Maman, Ariel Picard, Dov Schwartz, and Gili Zivan. We greatly appreciate the support of the donor who sponsored the English translation of this book, and has chosen to remain anonymous. Special thanks to the editors of the Hebrew version, Dror Yinon and Avinoam Yuval-Naeh, for their valuable contribution. Many thanks to Kira Nemirovsky and to the staff of Academic Studies Press for their professionalism, their patience, and their inspired suggestions. This book was written as part of our research work at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem, which views issues of contemporary Jewish life as the very essence of its existence. We are grateful to the Institute’s founder, the late David Hartman, who taught us to ask questions and reject banal answers, and to the president of the Hartman Institute, Donniel Hartman, for his longstanding support and encouragement and for allowing us to study Torah in material and spiritual comfort. Special thanks to our translator, Batya Stein. Batya was not only a translator but a partner to the conversation about the book’s contents and a critic who refined the text. Her contribution to the English version is invaluable.
This book analyzes the new religious-Zionist discourse about the body and sexuality, and the term “new” refers to the period it covers—the first decade of the twenty-first century. Even a cursory glance reveals that this decade does indeed open up a new era, not only because of the new political questions it considers—withdrawal from the occupied territories, the religion and state relationship, and more—but also, and mainly, because it deals with many questions that had been excluded from the classic religious- Zionist discourse. We have chosen to grapple with the most distinct expression of this shift—the discourse about the body and sexuality. Dealing with change has been a persistent feature in the history of religious-Zionism from its earliest days. As a modern movement, religiousZionism participated in the developments affecting the modern Zionist world. But the pace of its relationship with these developments has at times been slow and contingent on its capacity, as a religious movement, to digest and internalize changes, and on the unique voice that emerges in the encounter between religion and modernity. Hence, a discourse that had long been commonplace in secular Jewish-Israeli society often enters religious-Zionist society at a later stage. The classic ethos of Jewish thought and culture was shaped by the body-spirit antithesis rooted in the Greek and Christian traditions. This antithesis was the basis for a human ideal that enhances the spiritual component and restricts the physical one, which is perceived as a disturbance, an obstacle, or an ordeal one must endeavor to overcome. In the wake of modernity’s social and intellectual processes, this ethos gradually lost ground. Since the 1950s, the body-spirit or body-soul dichotomy has been increasingly eroded in Western culture, following a critique that targeted many redundant presuppositions embedded within it. This critique targets the assumption that sexuality is identified with matter and argues that to be human is to be a concrete entity having physicality and sexuality at its very core. This shift began in the 1950s and 1960s and has since intensified; in time, it became known as the “counterculture.” In its wake, a new un
derstanding struck roots, claiming that the term “human” does not denote an abstract entity identified with a specific attribute, such as rationality, creativity, or some other abstract characteristic. Human beings are physical creatures, and the body is the fundamental anchor of their being.1 Sexuality, therefore, rather than a contingent element in their existence, is what determines it. In secular and liberal Israeli society, the change in the standing of the body and of sexuality and their transformation into the constitutive elements of an alternative identity have been a fait accompli for decades. As we will show in Chapter Five, the shift began at the dawn of Zionism, but the permanence and centrality of this phenomenon have recently gained momentum. The religious world in general and the religious-Zionist world in particular find this approach hard to accept, given the status of the hierarchic body-soul dichotomy at the heart of Jewish tradition. Jewish religion focuses on the body and the norms binding on Jews apply primarily to the body. But this religious concern with the body attests only to its intensive use rather than to the nature of the relationship with it. The body-soul dichotomy remained a pervasive feature of Jewish discourse and an implicit fundamental distinction within religious consciousness. Since this dichotomy was never presented as a Jewish ideal, however, Jewish thought has been less affected by the need to grapple with the changes that have affected Western culture in recent decades, requiring it to address the body-soul split. A tension thus emerged between a normative practice that is distinctly physical and a conscious ideology that upholds the repression of physicality. This built-in tension between practice and ideology erupted in religious-Zionism that, as part of the modern revolution represented by Zionism, rescued the body from the body-spirit dichotomy and from the preference granted to the spirit. In the consciousness of religiousZionist revolutionaries, which was partly summed up in the slogan Torah va-Avodah [Torah and labor], restoring the body’s special standing was 1 The change in the attitude toward the body and the soul in Western culture occurs in philosophy, sociology, and culture studies, parallel to actual changes in the society. Evidence can be found, inter alia, in the significant penetration of Eastern thought and practice into the very heart of Western culture in the United States, in Israel, and, to a somewhat lesser degree, in Europe.