Книжная полка Сохранить
Размер шрифта:
А
А
А
|  Шрифт:
Arial
Times
|  Интервал:
Стандартный
Средний
Большой
|  Цвет сайта:
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц

Uncoupling Language and Religion: An Exploration into the Margins of Turkish Literature

Покупка
Артикул: 872311.01.99
Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину
This book is an invitation to rethink our understanding of Turkish literature as a tale of two "others.” The first part of the book examines the contributions of non-Muslim authors, the "others” of modern Turkey, to the development of Turkish literature during the late Ottoman and early republican period, focusing on the works of largely forgotten authors. The second part discusses Turkey as the "other” of the West and the way authors writing in Turkish challenged orientalist representations. Thus this book prepares the ground for a history of literature which uncouples language and religion and recreates the spaces of dialogue and exchange that have existed in late Ottoman Turkey between members of various ethno-religious communities.
Mignon, L. Uncoupling Language and Religion: An Exploration into the Margins of Turkish Literature : монография / L. Mignon. - Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2021. - 251 с. - ISBN 978-1-64469-580-7. - Текст : электронный. - URL: https://znanium.ru/catalog/product/2239389 (дата обращения: 18.11.2026). – Режим доступа: по подписке.
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Uncoupling 
Language 
and Religion
An Exploration 
into the Margins 
of Turkish Literature


Ottoman and Turkish Studies
Series Editor 
Hakan T. Karateke (University of Chicago)
Other Titles in this Series
Excavating Memory: Bilge Karasu’s Istanbul and Walter Benjamin’s Berlin 
Ülker Gökberk
The Ottoman Twilight in the Arab Lands: Turkish Memoirs and Testimonies of the 
Great War
Selim Deringil 
Disliking Others: Loathing, Hostility, and Distrust in Premodern Ottoman Lands 
Edited by Hakan T. Karateke, H. Erdem Çıpa and Helga Anetshofer
Waiting for Müteferrika: Glimpses of Ottoman Print Culture
Orlin Sabev
Investigating Turkey: Detective Fiction and Turkish Nationalism, 1928–1945
David Mason
For more information on this series, please visit: 
academicstudiespress.com/ottomanandturkishstudies


B O S T O N
2 0 2 1
Uncoupling 
Language 
and Religion
An Exploration 
into the Margins 
of Turkish Literature
Laurent Mignon


Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Mignon, Laurent, 1971- author.  
Title: Uncoupling language and religion: an exploration into the margins of Turkish 
literature / Laurent Mignon.
Description: Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2021. | Series: Ottoman and Turkish 
studies | Includes bibliographical references and index. 
Identifiers: LCCN 2020058688 (print) | LCCN 2020058689 (ebook) | ISBN  
9781644695791 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644695807 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 
9781644695814 (epub)
Subjects: LCSH: Turkish literature--Minority authors--History and criticism. | 
Turkish 
literature--19th 
century--History 
and 
criticism. 
| 
Turkish 
literature--20th  century--History and criticism. | Literature and society--Turkey. | 
Religion and lit-erature--Turkey. | Orientalism. | Baha Tevfik, -1914--Crtiticism 
and interpretation. 
Classification: LCC PL209.5.M56 M54 2021  (print) | LCC PL209.5.M56 
(ebook) 
| DDC 894/.35--dc23 
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020058688
LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020058689
Copyright © 2021 Academic Studies Press
All rights reserved.
Book design by PHi Business Solutions.
Cover design by Ivan Grave.
On the cover: Bedri Rahmi Eyüboğlu, Man Carrying a Goat, 1956
Silkscreen on paper, 18 1/4 × 15 in. (46.4 × 38.1 cm). 
Grey Art Gallery, New York University Art Collection, Gift of Abby Weed 
Grey, G1975.243
Courtesy Grey Art Gallery, New York University Art Collection.
Academic Studies Press
1577 Beacon St.
Brookline, MA 02446, USA
press@ academicstudiespress.com
www .academicstudiespress.com


Contents
Preface
vi
Acknowledgements
ix
A Note on Conventions
xi
Introduction: In the Footsteps of Baha Tevfik
xiii
PART ONE
Rethinking Literature in Turkish
1
1. The Revolution of the Letters
3
2. The Roses of the Anatolian Garden
27
3. The “Refuse and Ruins” of Literary History
51
4.	 Beyond Atala: Vartan Pasha, Zafer Hanım, and the
Romantic Rebellion
71
5. 	“La lengua ke se avla aki”: Jewish Literature in the
“Language Spoken Here”
93
PART TWO
Challenging Orientalism
113
6. Samuel Hirsch, Namık Kemal, and Orientalism
115
7. Ali Kemal’s Forgotten Adventure in the Desert
142
8. Nâzım Hikmet and the Demystification of the East
161
Conclusion: To Do or Not To Do God: On Transgression, 
Literature, and Religion
176
Bibliography
189
Index
209


Preface
A
s storm Mortimer was battering the island of Wangerooge, one of the East 
 Frisian islands on the North Sea, where I was spending a few days and 
cherishing the opportunity to delve into my manuscript, I started to question 
the necessity of a chapter devoted to the poet Nâzım Hikmet. Was my book not 
meant to focus on writers who had been written out of the history of literature? 
While Nâzım, who was stripped of his Turkish citizenship in 1951, might once 
have had the status of a pariah in Turkey half a century ago, this is far from being 
true today. It is undeniable that for decades his works were banned and could 
only be circulated clandestinely. To be found in possession of one his books 
could even be used as evidence for far-left political sympathies in court cases 
against progressive militants in Turkey. But this was long ago and, since the 
1990s, people from all spectrums of political life have been appropriating the 
poet. Indeed, in October 1994, Alpaslan Türkeş, the leader of the religious ultranationalist Milliyetçi Hareket Partisi (National Action Party) referred in positive 
terms to Nâzım Hikmet and read out one of his most popular poems, namely 
“Bu Memleket Bizim” (This Country is Ours), during the party’s congress, in an 
attempt to achieve a Turkish version of a Querfront uniting left and right-wing 
nationalists. In May 2007, the Ankara-based literary monthly Hece, with roots 
in Islamist literary circles, published a special issue devoted to the poet with the 
title “Türkçenin Sürgün Şairi: Nâzım Hikmet” (The Exiled Poet of the Turkish 
Language: Nâzım Hikmet), putting emphasis on his contributions to Turkish 
poetry beyond ideological differences. In those years, the poet was also included 
in the curriculum for Turkish literature classes in secondary education, which 
was equivalent to his canonization. In 2009, his citizenship was restored posthumously after much back and forth. So, had he not become too much part of the 
mainstream? 
Another problem was that I had already written on him on various 
occasions—mainly in French and Turkish, but also in English—addressing 
some of the issues at the heart of the chapter that was tormenting me. Somehow 


vii
Preface
the chapter seemed increasingly redundant. And now I was also starting to have 
doubts about the previous chapter on Namık Kemal and Samuel Hirsch. It 
was as if the seams of the whole book were starting to unravel. Meanwhile, the 
storm had cut off the island from the mainland. 
And yet, I could not let it go. The very first novel written by a Turkish 
author that I read, more than thirty years ago, had been a German translation of 
Nâzım Hikmet’s Yaşamak Güzel Be Kardeşim (Life’s Good, Brother), so I had an 
emotional attachment to his presence in the book, as well as—I won’t deny it—
political sympathies for his lifelong struggle. Furthermore, I tried to convince 
myself that the aspects of his works which I had chosen to focus on were perhaps not so well known—his critical engagement with orientalist representation and his exploration of themes and topics that made sense in the context 
of post-colonial theory—and that they fitted the problematics discussed in the 
second part of the book. In other words, the chapter had to stay.
This momentary crisis was an opportunity to rethink the purpose of the 
book. I was struck, more than when I originally conceived it, that the book’s 
two parts represented the two “great” themes that had marked my teaching of 
and writing on Turkish literature over the last two decades in Ankara at Bilkent 
University and at the University of Oxford. These two themes were, on the one 
hand, what I had called in an earlier book “the footnotes of literary history”1—
authors and works that had been kept out of the great narrative of literary history; and, on the other, the problematization of the idea that the history of 
modern Turkish literature was a history of its Westernization—a questioning 
that occurred in that book through a focus on some authors’ (among whom 
was Nâzım Hikmet) critical engagement with what is today known as orientalist representation. In other words, the two problematics were the question 
of the “others” within the late Ottoman Turkish literary field, that is to say 
non-Muslim authors, women writers, and political undesirables, as well as the 
problem of Turkey as the “other” of the West. This sensitivity to the problem 
of othering and Western supremacism stems from my discovery, back in my 
teenage years, of the absolute horror of the Shoah and of how the history of 
antisemitism is a continuous call for vigilance and a constant reminder of the 
dangers of othering and its consequences. This made, at least in my eyes, the 
chapter on Kemal and Hirsch an absolute necessity. 
	 1	 See Laurent Mignon, Ana Metne Taşınan Dipnotlar: Türk Edebiyatı ve Kültürlerarasılık Üzerine Yazılar [Footnotes Moving to the Main Text: Writings on Turkish Literature and Intercultultutalism] (Istanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 2009).


Preface
viii
As I have noted above, some of the material that served as a basis to the 
chapters of this book has been previously published and my thanks go here 
to the journals, publishers, and editors that have given me the opportunity to 
explore these ideas, publish them, and then make use of them in this book. 
Details of these works can be found in the footnotes and bibliography. Further, 
there is no doubt that many of the ideas here were first tested on students. I will 
be always extremely thankful to my students at Bilkent University in Ankara 
and at the University of Oxford, with whom I so often had engaging discussions. Giving a list of all the colleagues and friends to whom I am also deeply 
indebted for sharing their insights would be too long. They know who they are. 
However, I cannot help but mention by name my daughters İdil and Leyla, 
who, more than once, had to tolerate the grumpiness of their father and my 
partner Katja, without whom I would never have been able to finish this book. 
In the end, as she knows, not all was bad with Mortimer. 


Acknowledgements
A
s I mentioned in the preface, this book engages with some of the themes 
 that have marked my teaching and writing over the years, including in 
my Turkish-language essays. They have been collected in five volumes, namely 
Çağdaş Türk Şiirinde Aşk, Âşıklar, Mekânlar (Love, Lovers, Spaces in Modern 
Turkish Poetry, 2002), Elifbalar Sevdası (The Passion for Alphabets, 2003), 
Ana Metne Taşınan Dipnotlar (Footnotes Moving to the Main Text, 2009), 
Hüzünlü Özgürlük (A Sad Freedom, 2014), and Edebiyatın Sınırlarında (In the 
Borderlands of Literature, 2016), where early traces of my elucubrations can be 
observed.
Chapter 1 develops material first discussed in “The Literati and the 
Letters: A Few Words on the Turkish Alphabet Reform” (Journal of the Royal 
Asiatic Society 20, no. 1 [2010]: 11–24). 
Chapters 2, 3 and, 4 integrate material from “A Pilgrim’s Progress: Armenian and Kurdish Literatures in Turkish and the Rewriting of Literary History” 
(Patterns of Prejudice 48, no. 2 [2014]: 182–200); “Lost in Transliteration: A 
Few Remarks on the Armeno-Turkish Novel and Turkish Literary Historiography” (in Between Religion and Language: Turkish-Speaking Christians, Jews and 
Greek-Speaking Muslims and Catholics in the Ottoman Empire, ed. Evangelia Balta 
and Mehmet Ölmez [Istanbul: Eren, 2011], 111–123); “Minor Literatures and 
their Challenge to ‘National Literature’: The Turkish Case” (in Turkey and the 
Politics of National Identity: Social, Economic and Cultural Transformation, ed. 
Shane Brennan and Marc Herzog [London: I. B. Tauris, 2014], 194–214); 
and “Πάτερ bizim: Notes on the Nature of Karamanlı Literature” (in Cultural 
Encounters in the Turkish Speaking Communities of the Late Ottoman Empire, ed. 
Evangelia Balta and Mehmet Ölmez [Istanbul: The Isis Press, 2014], 137–148). 
Chapter 5 develops ideas first investigated in “Avram, İsak and the Others: Notes on the Genesis of Judeo-Turkish Literature” (in Between Religion and 
Language, ed. Evangelia Balta and Mehmet Sönmez [Istanbul: Eren, 2011], 
71–83); “From İshak to İsak: The Birth Pangs of Jewish Turkish Literature” 


Acknowledgements
x
(in Turkish Jews in Contemporary Turkey, ed. R. Bali and Laurent-Olivier Mallet 
[Istanbul: Libra Books, 2015], 257–282; and “Ringen mit Dämonen: Gibt es 
eine jüdisch-türkische Literatur?” (in Ni kaza en Turkiya: Erzählungen jüdischer 
Autoren aus Istanbul, ed. and trans. by Wolfgang Riemann [Engelschoff: Auf 
dem Ruffel, 2018], 125–144). 
Chapter 6 develops material from “Of Moors, Jews and Gentiles” (Journal 
of Turkish Studies 35, no. 1 [June 2011]: 65–83). 
Chapter 7 explores material from “Venger Aziyadé,” in Regards sur la poésie du 20ème siècle, ed. Laurent Fels [Namur: Les éditions namuroises, 2009], 
251–270). 


Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину