Visions of the Future: Malthusian Thought Experiments in Russian Literature (1840-1960)
Покупка
Тематика:
История литературы
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Grigorian Natasha
Год издания: 2023
Кол-во страниц: 135
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 979-8-88719-056-3
Артикул: 871878.01.99
This book is inspired by the author’s work as part of a major international and interdisciplinary research group at the University of Konstanz, Germany: "What If — On the Meaning, Relevance, and Epistemology of Counterfactual Claims and Thought Experiments.” Having contributed to great discoveries, such as those by Galileo and Einstein, thought experiments are especially topical in the twenty-first century, since this is a concept that bridges the gap between the arts and the sciences, promoting interdisciplinary innovation. To study thought experiments in literature, it is imperative to examine relevant texts closely: this has rarely been done to date and this is precisely what this book does as a pilot study focusing on selected works of philosophy and literature. Specifically, thought experiments by Thomas Malthus are analyzed side by side with short stories and novels by Vladimir Odoevsky and Nikolai Chernyshevsky, Alexander Bogdanov and Aleksei Tolstoy, Alexander Chaianov and Nina Berberova.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
VISIONS OF THE FUTURE M A LT H US I A N T H OUGH T E X P E R I M E N T S I N RUS S I A N L I T E R A T U R E (1 8 4 0 – 1 9 6 0)
Series Studies in Comparative Literature and Intellectual History Series Editor Galin Tihanov (Queen Mary, University of London)
B O S T O N 2 0 2 3 VISIONS OF THE FUTURE M A LT H US I A N T H OUGH T E X P E R I M E N T S I N RUS S I A N L I T E R A T U R E (1 8 4 0 – 1 9 6 0) Natasha Grigorian
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Grigorian, Natasha, author. Title: Visions of the future: Malthusian thought experiments in Russian literature (1840-1960) / Natasha Grigorian. Description: Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2023. | Series: Studies in comparative literature and intellectual history | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2022041568 (print) | LCCN 2022041569 (ebook) | ISBN 9798887190556 (hardback) | ISBN 9798887190563 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9798887190570 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Future, The, in literature. | Utopias in literature. | Dystopias in literature. | Russian literature--19th century--History and criticism. | Russian literature--20th century--History and criticism. | Malthus, T. R. (Thomas Robert), 1766-1834--Influence. | Thought experiments. | LCGFT: Literary criticism. Classification: LCC PG2987.F88 G75 2023 (print) | LCC PG2987.F88 (ebook) | DDC 891.709/003--dc23/eng/20221101 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2022041568 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2022041569 Сopyright © 2023, Academic Studies Press All rights reserved ISBN 9798887190556 (hardback) ISBN 9798887190563 (Adobe PDF) ISBN 9798887190570 (ePub) Cover design by Ivan Grave Book design by PHi Business Solutions Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Acknowledgments vii Introduction 1 1. Thomas Malthus, the Problem of Population, and Counterfactual Thought Experiments: A Concise Overview 21 2. Vladimir Odoevsky’s Russian Nights (1844): Thought Experiments Inspired by Malthus and Bentham 33 3. Thomas Malthus and Nikolai Chernyshevsky: Utopian Dreams in What Is to Be Done? (1863) 55 4. Revolution on Earth and Mars: Alexander Bogdanov’s Red Star (1908) and Aleksei Tolstoy’s Aelita (1923) 69 5. A Peasant Utopia: Alexander Chaianov’s My Brother Aleksei’s Journey (1920) 83 6. Overpopulation in Nina Berberova’s Short Story “In Memory of Schliemann” (1958), in the Context of Malthusian Theory 94 Conclusion 105 Bibliography 113 Index 123
So go ahead and tell everyone: this is what the future holds, the future is radiant and wonderful. You should all love it, yearn for it, work for it, accelerate its approach, and transfer as much from it into the present as you possibly can: your present life will be radiant and good, rich in joy and pleasure exactly in proportion to your ability to infuse some future into it while you still have time. —Nikolai Chernyshevsky, What Is to Be Done?; Vera Pavlovna’s fourth dream, chapter 4.16 Говори же всем: вот что в будущем, будущее светло и прекрасно. Любите его, стремитесь к нему, работайте для него, приближайте его, переносите из него в настоящее, сколько можете перенести: настолько будет светла и добра, богата радостью и наслаждением ваша жизнь, насколько вы успеете перенести в неё из будущего. —Николай Чернышевский, Что делать?
Acknowledgments This book project arose from my participation in an interdisciplinary DFG research group based at the University of Konstanz (2012-2014): “What If – On the Meaning, Relevance, and Epistemology of Counterfactual Claims and Thought Experiments.” I would like to extend my warmest thanks to those colleagues who have provided thought-provoking discussions, perceptive insights, and criticism while this book was being researched and written: first of all, Riccardo Nicolosi; Jurij Murašov; Wolfgang Spohn; Julian Reiss; John Beatty; Mirja Lecke; Maria Mikhailova; Fedor Poljakov; Muireann Maguire; Natalia Mikhalenko; Eliane Fitzé; the anonymous peer reviewers of the book manuscript; and many others. Some of the chapters of this book develop the argumentation of my articles listed in the Bibliography. My deepest gratitude is reserved for my family and friends, for their love, moral support, and unwavering faith in me throughout my research.
Introduction A suffocating smell of sulphur flooded the room. The hands of the large wall clock began to move faster and faster and soon disappeared out of sight in their frenzied rotating motion. The pages of the loose-leaf calendar were being noisily torn off on their own and were flying up to the ceiling, filling the room with a whirlwind of paper. The walls got somehow distorted and started to tremble. […] Exhausted by his effort, Aleksei collapsed onto some sofa, which had never been there before, and lost consciousness.1 This is the way in which Alexander Chaianov’s protagonist Aleksei ends up in the future land of peasant utopia, as an unknown force transports him from the year 1921 to 1984. While spending a quiet evening in his Moscow apartment at the end of a long day, Aleksei, a civil servant in the newly established Soviet Russia, is musing over a volume of Herzen. He then asks aloud, presumably with the volume’s author in mind, if liberal thinkers can come up with a viable alternative to socialism. No sooner has he uttered these words that time and space become displaced as described above. The point is that sometimes a rhetorical question addressed to a utopian writer can bring about dramatic life changes and propel us along a completely unexpected path, lined with inspiring new insights and acute disillusionment alike. The questions that this book is about to examine all start with “What if”: What if Aleksei were sent to the ideal future? What if the ideal future of humanity turned out to be a less than ideal disaster? And what if such experimentation in thoughts, conveyed via literary fiction, could give us new knowledge and instruct us about the best future choices? 1 “В комнaте удушливо зaпaхло серой. Стрелки больших стенных чaсов зaвертелись всё быстрее и быстрее и в неистовом врaщении скрылись из глaз. Листки отрывного кaлендaря с шумом отрывaлись сaми собой и взвивaлись кверху, вихрями бумaги нaполняя комнaту. Стены кaк-то искaзились и дрожaли. […] Истощённый усилиями, Алексей опустился нa кaкой-то дивaн, никогдa не бывший здесь рaньше, и сознaние его покинуло.” Aleksandr Chaianov, Puteshestvie moego brata Alekseia v stranu krest′ianskoi utopii (Moscow: Kniga po trebovaniiu, 2012), 5. Unless otherwise indicated, all translations are mine. See also the discussion of this passage in chapter 5 below.
The future of civilization has always held an irresistible fascination for the human mind. One of the aims of this book is to find out to what extent literary thought experiments can enable us to explore both future prospects and their roots in the present and the past. Modern Russian literature has produced a particularly rich and revealing array of forecasts dealing with the future evolution of society, as many generations of Russian intellectuals, especially writers, have addressed their country’s complex history in this way. The resulting literary evocations of the future are sometimes radiantly optimistic utopias, sometimes nightmarishly pessimistic dystopias, and occasionally a mixture of both: typically, a utopia that has gone wrong and turned into its antithesis. Within this broad class of visions of the future, the present study focuses on selected utopian and/or dystopian works of Russian prose fiction written between 1840 and 1960. These include both under-researched and well-known short stories and novels by Vladimir Odoevsky, Nikolai Chernyshevsky, Alexander Bogdanov, Aleksei Tolstoy, Alexander Chaianov, and Nina Berberova. Most of the chosen texts can be considered to contain a counterfactual thought experiment: in other words, a systematic and intrinsically plausible narrative based on unreal assumptions and attempting to prove or disprove a particular hypothesis or to argue a specific point. In the works in question, a characteristic starting point for such a counterfactual scenario is as follows: “X is an event or a series of events that has never taken place and probably never will. For purely experimental purposes, let us suppose that X happened. Now, if X were the case, then Y would occur…” This is a specific variety of the more general category of thought experiments, which can be concisely defined as mental constructs, expressed in language and giving a possible detailed narrative answer to the question “What if X occurred?,” where X is an event that may or may not take place, including any impossible events. Thought experiments and counterfactual reasoning play an important cognitive role both in the social and in the natural sciences,2 having contributed to great discoveries such as those by Galileo and Einstein, to name but a few. And yet the significance of (counterfactual) thought experiments in literary fiction has rarely been analyzed to date, especially with close attention to specific texts and their stylistic features. This is precisely what this book does: by connecting literary fiction and those great achievements of science that have been brought 2 For more detail, see, for example, Dorothee Birke, Michael Butter, and Tilmann Köppe, eds., Counterfactual Thinking—Counterfactual Writing (Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter, 2011); and Thomas Macho and Annette Wunschel, eds., Science and Fiction. Über Gedankenexperimente in Wissenschaft, Philosophie und Literatur (Frankfurt/M: Fischer, 2004).