The Rhetorical Rise and Demise of "Democracy” in Russian Political Discourse
Покупка
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Год издания: 2021
Кол-во страниц: 505
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-733-7
Артикул: 871871.01.99
The essays in this book examine the arguments and rhetoric used by the United States and the USSR following two catastrophes that impacted both countries, as blame is cast and consequences are debated. In this environment, it was perhaps inevitable that conspiracy theories would arise, especially about the downing of Korean Air Lines Flight 007 over the Sea of Japan. Those theories are examined, resulting in at least one method for addressing conspiracy arguments. In the case of Chernobyl, the disaster ruptured the "social compact” between the Soviet government and the people; efforts to overcome the resulting disillusionment quickly became the focus of state efforts.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
The Rhetorical Rise and Demise of “Democracy” in Russian Political Discourse
B O S T O N 2 0 2 1 The Rhetorical Rise and Demise of “Democracy” in Russian Political Discourse David Cratis Williams, Marilyn J. Young, and Michael K. Launer The Path from Disaster toward Russian “Democracy” Vo l u m e 1
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Williams, David Cratis, 1955- editor. | Young, Marilyn J., 1942- editor. | Launer, Michael K., editor. Title: The rhetorical rise and demise of “democracy” in Russian political discourse. volume 1, The path from disaster toward Russian “democracy” / David Cratis Williams, Marilyn J. Young, and Michael K. Launer. Description: Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2021. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2021037729 (print) | LCCN 2021037730 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644697320 (v. 1; hardback) | ISBN 9781644697337 (v. 1; adobe pdf) | ISBN 9781644697344 (v. 1; epub) Subjects: LCSH: Rhetoric--Political aspects--Russia (Federation) | Democracy--Russia (Federation) | Conspiracy theories--Russia (Federation) | Korean Air Lines Incident, 1983. | Chernobyl Nuclear Accident, Chornobyl’, Ukraine, 1986. Classification: LCC P301.5.P67 R4947 2021 (print) | LCC P301.5.P67 (ebook) | DDC 808--dc23 LC record available at https: //lccn.loc.gov/2021037729 LC ebook record available at https: //lccn.loc.gov/2021037730 Copyright © Academic Studies Press ISBN 9781644697320 (hardback) ISBN 9781644697337 (adobe pdf) ISBN 9781644697344 (epub) Book design by PHi Business Solutions Cover design by Ivan Grave Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@ academicstudiespress.com www .academicstudiespress.com
Contents Acknowledgements vii List of Interviews ix Note to Readers xiii Preface xv Introduction to Volume One. Image and Reality: The Declining Role of Evidence in Public Discourse xxxi Part One: KAL and Cracks in the Rhetorical Wall 1 Route R-20—Terry Graves Illustration 2 Takahashi—Novosti Satellite Map 3 Ogarkov Double Loop Map—The New York Times 4 1. Did the United States Suppress Ground-to-Air Communications? 5 2. KAL 007 and the Superpowers: An International Argument 23 3. The KAL Tapes 58 4. BCAS Correspondence: “Flight 007: Was There Foul Play?” 74 5. The Need for Evaluative Criteria: Conspiracy Argument Revisited 83 6. Soviet Media Tactics and the Body Politic: Prevention and Treatment of Communicable Diseases 109 7. When the Shoe Is on the Other Foot: Comparative Treatments of the KAL 007 and Iran Air Shootdowns 136 8. Of Mighty Mice and Meek Men: Contextual Reconstruction of the Iranian Airbus Shootdown 163 9. “007”—Conspiracy or Accident? 183 10. Flight 007 188 11. Carlos the Jackal Attacks RFE/RL! 195
Part Two: Chernobyl, Eco-Nationalism, and Loss of Rhetorical Control Plaque at the entrance to the Chernobyl AES administration building (1989) 200 The Original Sarcophagus (1989) 201 Interior access door to the sarcophagus at Chernobyl (1989) 202 A Billboard at the Rovno Nuclear Station (1996) 203 The New Secure Confinement (2019) 204 12. Chernobyl in the Soviet Media: Unintentional Ironies, Unprecedented Events 205 13. Redefining Glasnost in the Soviet Media: The Recontextualization of Chernobyl 208 14. Chernobyl: From the Ashes a New Society? 234 15. Nuclear Power in the USSR 236 16. Civilian Nuclear Power in the Commonwealth of Independent States: A Case of Cognitive Dissonance 248 17. Soviet News Media: Uncertainty in the Throes of Change 261 18. Nuclear Power and Ecological Debates in the Soviet Press, Mid-1988 to Mid-1989 265 19. The Final Days: The Development of Argumentative Discourse in the Soviet Union 286 20. Ukraine Nuclear Power Struggles for Survival 303 21. Nonrational Assessment of Risk and the Development of Civilian Nuclear Power 311 22. Ukraine, Russia, and the Question of Nuclear Safety 327 23. Soviet Bureaucracy and Nuclear Safety 366 24. Review of Two Books by David R. Marples 375 25. Review of Plutopia 380 26. Review of Plokhy, Chernobyl 384 27. Pseudo-Science and Potemkin-History 393 28. Confronting Climate Change: Assessing the Role of Nuclear Power 410 Afterword 413 Bibliography 415 Index 443
Acknowledgements M any individuals have participated in making this project a reality. Igor Nemirovsky, Director of the Academic Studies Press, first conceived the idea of collecting our studies and making them available to a new generation of Slavists and rhetorical scholars. His letter to Marilyn Young in 2019 initiated this process. Ekaterina (Kate) Yanduganova, the ASP acquisitions editor for Slavic, East European, and Central Asian studies, has shepherded the publication process for this volume tirelessly and efficiently, as have the members of her copy editing team. Michele Pedro has been indispensable on our end proofreading and formatting the elements that have made up our manuscript. It is impossible to overemphasize the valuable assistance provided by staff members at Voice of America (Washington) and Radio Free Europe/ Radio Liberty (Munich), as well as the research librarians who worked at ABC, CBS, and NBC (New York)—sadly no longer functioning. We also wish to thank Daisy Sindelar and Martins Zvaners (RFE/RL) and Dr. Tiffany Cabrera (State Department Office of the Historian). We appreciate the support of Karin Beesley, Wendy Fernando, Annabel Flude, Sean Ray, Rachel Twombly, and especially Mary Ann Muller—as well as the organizations they represent—for facilitating the process of receiving permission to re-publish articles that appeared in the books and journals they curate. We also thank others who read draft versions, provided research support, or participated in the writing of individual studies presented here, including Curtis Austin, Scott Elliott, Maksim Fetissenko, Svitlana Jaroszynski, Jim Kuypers, Debbie Launer, and Aleksandr Yuriev. Unless otherwise indicated, translations from Russian into English were provided by Michael Launer. In addition, we express our deep gratitude to all of the people around the world who sat for interviews, responded to inquiries, or spent time
viii assisting us in our research—and who are identified on the following pages. The studies in this volume are more complete, more authoritative, and simply more correct because of their assistance. That said, we take full responsibility for any errors of commission or omission that may still exist.
List of Interviews Anonymous. Pripyat, Ukrainian SSR, May 1989. Anonymous. Deputy Chief Engineer for Operations. Chernobyl, Ukrainian SSR, August 1989. Anonymous. Ventilation Specialist. Chernobyl, Ukrainian SSR, August 1989. Anonymous. Leningrad, USSR, August 1989. Anonymous. Moscow, USSR, June 1990. Anonymous. Pismo Beach CA. July 1992. Anonymous. State Committee for Radiation Safety. Kiev, Ukraine, July 1994. Beguchev, Oleg P. Russian Academy of Sciences. Moscow, Russia, April 1995. Brochman, Philip G. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Energodar, Ukrainian SSR, August 1989. Bronnikov, Vladimir K. Chicago IL. November 1992. Brutain, G. St. Petersburg, Russia, January 1992. Callan, L. Joseph. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Energodar, Ukrainian SSR, August 1989. Cayia, Alfred J. Point Beach Nuclear Plant. Two Creeks WI. September 1995. Clarkson, Natalie. Chief of the Russian Division at Voice of America. July 1985. Congdon, Mike. PNNL. September 2016, June 2019. Dodd, Laurin. PNNL. June 2018, November 2019. Ewing, Harold. Boeing 747 pilot. September 20, 1986. Faris, Kent. PNNL. May/June 2018. Feaver, Douglas. The Washington Post reporter. May 27, 1986. Gal′berg, Valery. Kursk RBMK Reactor Physicist. Salem Township PA. June 1990. Glukhov, Andrei. Chernobyl. October 2018.
x Gurshtein, Aleksandr. Russian Academy of Sciences. Tallahassee FL. November 1994. Haynes, Philip. VOA. September 1985. Hersh, Seymour. Author. July 1985. Jernigan, Lisa. Physician. Tallahassee FL. June/September 2018, October 2019. Jett, Brandon. Builder. Tallahassee FL. June 2018. Kambulov, I. N. USSR Academy of Sciences. Moscow, USSR, May 1989. Kang, Sugwon. Author. December 1984. Kessler, Carol. PNNL. November 2019. Kolomtsev, Yuri V. Kola Nuclear Power Station. Polyarnye zori, Russia, July 1995. Koltunov, Viktor. Zaporozhe Nuclear Power Station. Energodar, Ukrainian SSR, July, August 1989. Kontsevoi, A. USSR Ministry of Atomic Energy and Industry. Moscow, July 1989, June 1990. Lodeesen, Jon. Director of US Operations for RFE/RL. Washington DC. July 1985. Lystsov, Vitaly N. Russian Federation Ministry for the Protection of the Environment and Natural Resources. Moscow, Russia, April 1995. Marcelli, Dave. Nuclear engineer. November 2018. Maertens, Tom. US Department of State. June 1984. Martin, Tim. INPO. October/November 2018. Miltenberger, James. Pennsylvania Power & Light Company. Salem Township PA. June 1990. Moffitt, Bob. PNNL. September 16, 2020. Navasky, Victor. Editor of The Nation. October 1995. Oberg, James. Author. February 13, 2000. Parsons, R. M. American Society of Civil Engineers. April 1996. Pasedag, Walt. United States Department of Energy. St. Petersburg, Russia. April/May 1996. Pearson, David. Author. December 1984. Ponomarev-Stepnoi, Nikolai N. Deputy Director, Kurchatov Institute. Moscow, USSR, June/July 1990. Reynolds, Jack. NBC News correspondent. June 18, 1986. Richardson, James. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Rockville MD. July 1990.