Lev Shestov: The Philosophy and Works of a Tragic Thinker
Покупка
Тематика:
Литературоведение. Фольклористика
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Oppo Andrea
Год издания: 2020
Кол-во страниц: 347
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-64469-468-8
Артикул: 871854.01.99
This study spans the entire life and work of the Russian philosopher Lev Shestov (1866-1938). It offers keys to understanding his thought, while also tracing the historical itinerary of his work. Shestov’s thought is not only interesting in itself, as a "philosophy fighting against philosophy,” but also because it reveals an entire world of cultural connections in its extraordinarily keen exploration of other "souls.” The reader will find in Shestov some of the sharpest analyses of authors such as Shakespeare, Nietzsche, Tolstoi, Dostoevskii, Luther, Plotinus, Pascal, Kierkegaard and many others. This study will better determine the controversial and fascinating philosopher’s place in the history of Russian and Western thought.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
Lev Shestov The Philosophy and Works of a Tragic Thinker
B O S T O N 2 0 2 0 Lev Shestov The Philosophy and Works of a Tragic Thinker A N D R E A O P P O
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Oppo, Andrea, author. Title: Lev Shestov : the philosophy and works of a tragic thinker / Andrea Oppo. Description: Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2020. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2020030063 (print) | LCCN 2020030064 (ebook) | ISBN 9781644694671 (hardback) | ISBN 9781644694688 (adobe pdf) | ISBN 9781644694695 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Shestov, Lev, 1866-1938. Classification: LCC B4259.S54 O67 2020 (print) | LCC B4259.S54 (ebook) | DDC 197--dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020030063 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020030064 Copyright © 2020 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd. Cover design by Ivan Grave. Published by Academic Studies Press 1577 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Contents Acknowledgments vii Editorial Notes ix Introduction x Part One—Shestov in Russia 1 Chapter I The Philosophy Of Tragedy (1898–1905) 2 1.1 Introduction: The Birth of a Tragic Conscience 2 1.2 Shestov before Shestov: Shakespeare and Pushkin 11 1.3 Tolstoi’s Struggle between “Yasnaya Polyana” and “Astapovo” 26 1.4 Friedrich Nietzsche: Truth against Morality 35 1.5 Dostoevskii and Nietzsche as “Philosophers of the Underground” 47 1.6 Apotheosis of “Bespochvennostʹ”: Towards a Philosophy of Tragedy 56 Chapter II Art As Negativity: The Literary Criticism Years (1901–1910) 69 2.1 Introduction: Shestov and the Philosophical Problem of Art 69 2.2 Aestheticism and Ideology: On Merezhkovskii and Turgenev 78 2.3 Creatio ex Nihilo: Chekhov’s Aesthetics 85 2.4 The “Oracular” Gratuity of Sologub’s Prose and Poetry 90 2.5 Ibsen and the Destiny of Art 94 2.6 Retracting Tragedy: Dostoevskii as an Essayist 98 2.7 The “Magnificent” Vyacheslav Ivanov 100 Part Two—Shestov in France 107 Chapter III Wandering Through The Souls (1914–1929) 108 3.1 Introduction: The Events of History—Shestov’s Political Views 108
3.2 The Power of Keys: Faith and Church in Martin Luther 3.3 The Two Histories of Western Philosophy 3.4 The Fight against Self-Evidences: Dostoevskii, Pascal, and Spinoza 134 3.5 Philosophy’s Revolt against Itself: Plotinus’ Ecstasies 147 3.6 Audacities and Submissions: Shestov’s Intellectual World 156 3.7 Shestov and the Russian Philosophers 162 Chapter IV Athens and Jerusalem: The Logic and The Thunder (1930–1938) 171 4.1 Introduction: Shestov as a “Jewish Philosopher” 171 4.2 The Bible and the Original Sin: In Dialogue with Martin Buber 180 4.3 The Last Encounter: Kierkegaard 185 4.4 Étienne Gilson and the Spirit of Medieval Philosophy 196 4.5 Philosophers in Chains: At the Sources of Metaphysics 200 Conclusion 207 1. Reception and Legacy of Shestov’s Philosophy 207 2. The Question of Irrationalism and of “Antiphilosophy” 220 3. The (Neo-)Platonic Paradigm: Shestov’s “Third Sailing” 226 4. Afterword: Reading between the Lines 239 Appendices 242 I. Shestov and Husserl 243 II. Shestov and Berdyaev 262 III. Shestov and Fondane 280 Bibliography and Works Cited 289 A. Shestov’s Works 289 A.1 Books 290 A.2 Articles and Correspondence 294 B. Selected Studies on Shestov 298 B.1 Biographies, Memoirs, Specific Journals, and Bibliographies 300 B.2 Books on Shestov 302 B.3 Articles and Book Chapters on Shestov 303 C. Further References 314 Index 320
Acknowledgments I was a young man when my father gifted me a book by an author whose name I had never heard before—Lev Shestov (the book was In Job’s Balance, in Italian translation). “I thought you might appreciate it,” he said. My appreciation turned immediately into a desire to study Russian philosophy, learn the Russian language, and indeed to explore Shestov’s thought in depth. Suddenly, a whole Russian world I had not been aware of opened up to me—and Shestov was the key to this world. At the same time, I realized that despite the large number of translations of his works in foreign languages, full studies on him were considerably fewer and often incomplete. At that time, Shestov remained to all intents and purposes a mystery: up to the mid-1990s, for instance, his first work on Shakespeare had been read by only a few scholars and his prerevolutionary life in Russia was still largely unknown, especially outside the country. From that point on, I began my long and productive quest: my first trip to Saint Petersburg in the early 1990s to find materials in libraries; my studies at The Lev Shestov Archive at the Bibliothèque de la Sorbonne in Paris; and many conversations with scholars who versed me in the complex and variegated context of Russian religious philosophy (in particular, I remember with gratitude an email exchange with James Scanlan). This work is the result of my long research on Shestov and of a “journey” extending over nearly thirty years. I should thank many people for this, but I will narrow down the list to some essential names: first of all, my father Bachisio, to whose memory I dedicate this work. Then, Ettore Marino, for our decisive conversations during long walks in Florence more than twenty years ago; Daniele Vinci and Massimiliano Spano, for their constant support; Anna Maiorova, for her precious help and for her wonderful generosity; and last, but not quite least, Karen Turnbull who revised my English throughout this book and, as always, was attentive and careful in helping me with this. I would also like to thank Igor Nemirovsky, the director of Academic Studies Press, for believing in this project from
viii Acknowledgments the very beginning, Irene Masing-Delic who always encouraged my studies, Kseniya Vorozhikhina and Sergei Polikin for their kindness and support, and the staff of the Bibliothèque de la Sorbonne in Paris for their kind help in my research in The Lev Shestov Archive.
Editorial Notes With few exceptions, all the quotations throughout this book have been made from the original Russian texts. All the translations from Russian and French are mine. Since Shestov loved to quote texts in the original language (mostly from German, Latin, and Greek) further translations from these languages, which are also mine, were sometimes required. For reasons of convenience and accessibility for readers, I decided to refer to the French edition of Natalʹya Baranova’s biography, while a smaller number of Shestovian texts have been quoted from the English translations made by Bernard Martin. Since the entire context of this book is set against the historical backdrop of emigration from Russia to Europe, the spelling of names may differ depending on the original language of the quoted book: for example, Shestov/Chestov, Baranova/Baranoff, Shlëtser/Schloezer, Zenʹkovskii/Zenkovsky, and so forth. But, luckily, these situations are limited. For the transliteration of Russian language into the Latin script, I adopted the BGN/ PCGN system, with the sole exception of names that are quoted from books that employed another system. For citations, I used the author-date system with some integration. Since the final bibliography is divided in three sections (A, B, C) and a number of subsections (A1, A2; B1, B2, B3), the quotation sequence will be the following: author (surname), year of the book/article (when needed), and section with subsection (e.g., B1) in which the author’s surname must be looked up. In sections A1 and A2, Shestov’s publications are listed in chronological order, for each a list number will precede the year of publication of the book (or article) that is indicated: for example, Shestov 8/1993 (A1) (in this case, one must consult the eighth entry on the list in section A1 and within that, among the various indicated editions or translations, the item published in 1993). I have faith this system will be intuitive enough to be easily followed: it has, in my view, the significant advantage of providing a final bibliography list that, since it is divided into thematic sections, is undoubtedly clearer and easier to consult than one single alphabetic list.
Introduction One of the most eminent Russian historians of the arts, Dmitrii Likhachëv, once wrote that Russian painting is above all a painting of faces (see Likhachëv [C], 23). The same could perhaps be said about Russian philosophy as a philosophy that portrays the human soul: not mere objects of knowledge or “landscapes” of reason but living human problems. Shestov would fit such a definition perfectly. Many—if not all—of his writings concern “people”: they are works that indicate in their own titles the name of a personality (philosopher, writer, artist, intellectual). Shestov is primarily interested in people just as Russian painters were interested in faces. At the same time, he draws constant comparisons with the tradition of classic Western philosophy (Socrates, Plato, Plotinus, Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, Descartes, Pascal, Kant, Hegel, Spinoza, Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, Husserl) in a way that few other Russian philosophers do. In this regard, he is undoubtedly a philosopher. But he is also a deep scrutinizer of people, that is, of “philosophical souls” in the way just described. Lev Shestov (Lev Isaakovich Shvartsman), a Russian born in Kiev into a Jewish family, is mostly known in the Western world as a religious existential philosopher and also as one of the first philosophical interpreters of Dostoevskii, offering a fundamentally tragic reading of the author’s late oeuvre. Following Vasilii Rozanov’s lead, he identified Notes from the Underground as the turning point of, and key to, Dostoevskii’s works. Although he always retained a clearly philosophical approach, at the beginning of his career Shestov worked as a literary critic in the circle of Russian artists and intellectuals that gravitated toward Sergei Dyagilev and his journal Mir iskusstva [The World of Art]. During those years (1901–1910), he wrote a number of essays on Tolstoi, Dostoevskii, Shakespeare, Turgenev, Chekhov, Sologub, Ibsen, and others. After leaving Russia in 1920 to escape the Bolshevik takeover and finally settling in France, Shestov’s interests increasingly turned away from moral philosophy and literature to focus on religion and theoretical philosophy instead. In the most