Книжная полка Сохранить
Размер шрифта:
А
А
А
|  Шрифт:
Arial
Times
|  Интервал:
Стандартный
Средний
Большой
|  Цвет сайта:
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц
Ц

Writing the Time of Troubles. False Dmitry in Russian Literature

Покупка
Артикул: 871825.01.99
Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину
Is each moment in history unique, or do essential situations repeat themselves? The traumatic events associated with the man who reigned as Tsar Dmitry have haunted the Russian imagination for four hundred years. Was Dmitry legitimate, the last scion of the House of Rurik, or was he an upstart pretender? A harbinger of Russia’s doom or a herald of progress? Writing the Time of Troubles traces the proliferation of fictional representations of Dmitry in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Russia, showing how playwrights and novelists reshaped and appropriated his brief and equivocal career as a means of drawing attention to and negotiating the social anxieties of their own times.
Morris, M. Writing the Time of Troubles. False Dmitry in Russian Literature : монография / M. Morris. - Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2018. - 191 с. - ISBN 978-1-61811-864-6. - Текст : электронный. - URL: https://znanium.ru/catalog/product/2238568 (дата обращения: 19.11.2026). – Режим доступа: по подписке.
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
WRITING
THE TIME
OF TROUBLES
False Dmitry
in Russian Literature


The Unknown Nineteenth Century
Series Editor
JOE PESCHIO (University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee)
Editorial Board 
ANGELA BRINTLINGER
(Ohio State University, Columbus)
ALYSSA GILLESPIE
(University of Notre Dame, South Bend, Indiana)
MIKHAIL GRONAS
(Dartmouth College, Hanover, New Hampshire)
IGOR PILSHCHIKOV
(Tallinn University, Moscow State University)
DAVID POWELSTOCK
(Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts)
ILYA VINITSKY
(University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia)


Boston 
WRITING
THE TIME
OF TROUBLES
False Dmitry
in Russian Literature
MARCIA A. MORRIS


Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Morris, Marcia A., 1952- author.
Title: Writing the Time of Troubles : False Dmitry in Russian literature /  
Marcia Morris.
Description: Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2018. | 
Series: Unknown nineteenth century | Includes bibliographical references. 
Identifiers: LCCN 2018023375 (print) | LCCN 2018034102 (ebook) |
ISBN  9781618118646 (ebook) | ISBN 9781618118639 (hardcover)
Subjects: LCSH: Kings and rulers in literature. | Boris Fyodorovich Godunov, 
Czar of Russia, 1551 or 1552-1605—In literature. | Lzhedmitrii I, Czar of 
Russia, -1606—In literature. | Russian literature—18th century—History and 
criticism. | Russian literature—19th century—History and criticism.
Classification: LCC PG3015.5.K56 (ebook) | 
LCC PG3015.5.K56 M67 2018 (print) | DDC 891.709/35847045—dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018023375
© Academic Studies Press, 2018.
ISBN 9781618118639 (hardcover)
ISBN 9781618118646 (ebook)
Book design by Kryon Publishing Services (P) Ltd.
www.kryonpublishing.com 
Cover design by Ivan Grave
On the cover: False Dmitry I in Coronation Robes, by Szymon Boguszowicz 
(oil on canvas, ca. 1606).
Academic Studies Press
28 Montfern Avenue
Brighton, MA 02135, USA
press@academicstudiespress.com
www.academicstudiespress.com


In memoriam
William E. Harkins,
Scholar, Teacher, Mentor


Table of Contents
Acknowledgments
vii
A Note on Translation, Transliteration, Names, and Abbreviations
viii
Introduction: Recurrence, Transference, and Dmitry
ix
Chapter 1. Prelude
1
Chapter 2. Two Visions of Tyranny: The Late Eighteenth Century
18
Chapter 3. Verbal Self-Fashioning: The Early Nineteenth Century
50
Chapter 4. Two Visions of Reform: 1866
85
Chapter 5. Contingent Self-Fashioning: The Fin de Siècle
105
Dmitry: Re-resurrection and Conclusions
133
Sources Cited
142
Index
156


Acknowledgments
T
he longer one works on a project the greater the obligations one accrues. 
I owe a deep debt of gratitude to Deborah Martinsen for reading two 
versions of Writing the Time of Troubles and gently pointing out unwarranted 
moments of prolixity—also for helping me locate the text of Nikolay Chaev’s 
Dmitry the Pretender. I am likewise beholden to Milla Fedorova for drawing my 
attention to Boris Akunin’s Children’s Book and to Olga Meerson for introducing me to Lyudmila Taymasova and her Tragedy in Uglich. Deborah Martinsen, 
Robin Miller, and Amy Ronner have been boon companions and unfailing 
interlocutors as I worked through the final stages of the manuscript. Thank you 
for inspiring me by your work and for having so much patience with mine! 
Over the past several years, I have presented parts of Writing the Time of 
Troubles to Georgetown University’s Slavic Research Seminar; I am deeply 
grateful to my department colleagues for their comments and suggestions. 
I also read an early version of the Boris Akunin material at the University of 
Helsinki’s Aleksanteri Institut and am indebted to its members for the feedback 
I received from them. The staff at the Library of Congress’s European Reading 
Room have gone the extra mile in helping me locate obscure texts—many 
thanks! It’s been a privilege to work with Faith Wilson Stein, Oleh Kotsyuba, 
Carolyn Pouncy, Ekaterina Yanduganova, and Kira Nemirovsky at Academic 
Studies Press: thank you for your forbearance and guidance. I am also grateful 
to the press’s anonymous readers who made numerous suggestions that greatly 
improved the final book.
My work on Writing the Time of Troubles has consumed nearly as many 
years as did the Troubles themselves. I owe my greatest debt of appreciation to 
my husband, Martin O’Mara, for his unfailing patience and support.


A Note on Translation, 
Transliteration, Names, 
and Abbreviations
T
ranslations are mine unless otherwise indicated. I have used conventional 
spellings for the names of well-known authors but adopted J. Thomas 
Shaw’s System I for transliterating other personal and place names in the text 
as well as in the discursive parts of the endnotes. For quoting from and citing 
primary as well as secondary Russian sources, I use Shaw’s System II (Library 
of Congress without diacritics). When quoting from secondary literature in 
English, I have retained the system used by the author.
The spelling of many Russian personal names has varied from one era (and 
one text) to the next. I have regularized all names to one standard usage (i.e., 
“Dmitry” over “Dimitry”). The author of each work I examine made an onomastic choice regarding the man who followed Boris Godunov on the throne. 
Some referred to him as “False Dmitry,” others as “Dmitry the Pretender,” still 
others as “Grishka Otrepev,” and yet others as “Dmitry,” pure and simple. As a 
rule, I follow each individual author’s usage when discussing that author’s text, 
but in so doing I make no judgments regarding “Dmitry’s” “real” identity.
I have used the following abbreviations:
ChOIDR Chteniia v Imperatorskom obshchestve istorii i drevnostei rossiiskikh pri Moskovskom universitete
LOII Trudy Leningradskogo otdeleniia instituta istorii
MERSH Modern Encyclopedia of Russian and Soviet History
RIB Russkaia istoricheskaia biblioteka
SGGD Sobranie gosudarstvennykh gramot i dogovorov khraniashchikhsia 
v gosudarstvennoi kollegii inostrannykh del
TODRL Trudy otdela drevnerusskoi literatury
ZhMNP Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosveshcheniia


Introduction: Recurrence, 
Transference, and Dmitry 
If history were taught in the form of stories, it would never be forgotten. 
—Rudyard Kipling
I 
n the spring of 1605, a young man purporting to be Dmitry, Ivan IV’s sole 
surviving son, ascended Moscow’s throne. Eleven months later, he was 
dead—the victim of a murderous conspiracy. A brutal, eight-year struggle for 
sovereignty erupted. 
News of Dmitry’s precipitous rise and fall spread rapidly across Russia and 
into western Europe,1 but his true identity and aspirations are disputed to this 
day. Was he indeed the last son of Russia’s “Terrible” tsar, miraculously rescued 
from an assassination attempt in 1591? Or was he a pretender, as his detractors alleged? Did he rule the Russian lands wisely, or was he little more than an 
adventurer? Unfortunately, history offers few definitive answers: the evidence 
is limited and flawed. Yet the man who would be tsar has provided a perennial 
source of fascination—precisely because of the mystery that surrounds him. 
Dozens of dramas, novels, and monographs—written across centuries as well 
as national borders—have offered riveting accounts of Dmitry and his deeds, 
sparking as much as slaking the curiosity of successive generations of readers. 
We might easily imagine that the enigma of Dmitry—his debatable origins, his uncertain allegiances, the conflicting passions he inspired among 
supporters and disparagers—would titillate sensation seekers. What is somewhat less expected, however, is the abiding attraction he has exercised over 
successive generations of Russian novelists and dramatists. Writer after writer 
adapted selected aspects of his story as narrative scaffoldings for their own 
fictional works, often drawing explicit attention to their acts of appropriation 
  1	 For a list of plays written about Dmitry, see Erwin C. Brody, The Demetrius Legend and Its 
Literary Treatment in the Age of the Baroque (Rutherford, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University 
Press, 1972). See also his “Pushkin’s ‘Boris Godunov’: The First Modern Russian Historical 
Drama,” Modern Language Review 72 (1977): 858–59.


x
by choosing the same familiar titles for their plays and novels (most frequently, 
Dmitry the Pretender). Why were so many belletrists drawn to Dmitry? 
Writing the Time of Troubles identifies four successive waves of eighteenth- 
and nineteenth-century Russian writers who coopted the equivocal person of 
Dmitry not just as a thrilling protagonist for historical plays and novels but also 
as a vehicle for addressing and contesting identity—Dmitry’s own, to be sure, 
but also modern Russia’s. In their works, politics—past and present—seeped 
into and mixed with fiction, compelling these playwrights and novelists to ask 
the following: was Dmitry (or Russia) unique, the product of providential 
exceptionalism? Or was he (and, by extension, Russia) a fabricated construct, 
an alloy of east and west? Was Dmitry (or Russia) true to Orthodoxy, or had 
he (and Russia) yielded to apostasy? Was the unhappy turn that Russian history made after Dmitry’s downfall his fault or the boyars’? Put differently, could 
early seventeenth-century Russia’s trauma be traced to a single “great man”? 
To a congeries of boyars? To “the people”? What were the implications of past 
trauma for the present? The dual focus of these questions—on the premodern 
Dmitry and on modern society—tied Russian writers’ present ineluctably to 
their medieval past, revealing their intuition that vital aspects of Old Russia’s 
legacy remained intact and relevant even after Peter the Great’s reforms.
Of course, all human societies experience trauma at some point in their 
histories. The aspects that differentiate one society from another in this regard 
are the shape and scope of its trauma as well as the means that it adopts to 
come to terms with it. Russia underwent a crisis in the opening years of the 
seventeenth century that shook it to its core and that has never been fully 
overcome.2 Later writers would tie the period’s conundrums to similar 
dilemmas in their own times, asking whether time-honored traditions were 
necessarily sacrosanct and whether true rulers must be born or could be chosen. 
It is characteristic of Russian culture that several generations of intellectuals 
repeatedly interrogated these issues through works of belles lettres. It is also 
characteristic that subsequent experiences of trauma were assimilated to the 
seventeenth century’s ur-trauma: the earlier period’s uncertainties remained 
both foundational and, to a great extent, unresolved. Imperial Russia’s 
historical fiction about Dmitry fell into two main subtypes: static texts that 
  2	 In Daniel Rowland’s words, “The events of the Troubles, including the virtual disappearance 
of the God-established tsardom, violent social strife, and massive foreign intervention, were 
so traumatic that they forced writers to search deeply in their stock of received ideas for 
some sort of explanation” (“Did Muscovite Literary Ideology Place Limits on the Power of 
the Tsar [1540s–1660s]?” Russian Review 49 [1990]: 131).


Доступ онлайн
1 800 ₽
В корзину