The Russian-Jewish tradition: intellectuals, historians, revolutionaries
Покупка
Тематика:
Общие работы по всемирной истории
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Horowitz Brian
Год издания: 2017
Кол-во страниц: 291
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-557-7
Артикул: 871812.01.99
This book argues that Jews were not a people apart but were culturally integrated in Russian society. In their diasporic cultural creations Russia’s Jews employed the general themes of artists under tsars and Soviets, but they modified these themes to fit their own needs. The result was a hybrid, Russian-Jewish culture, unique and dynamic. Few today consider that Jewish Eastern Europe, the "old world”, was in fact a power incubator of modern Jewish consciousness. Brian Horowitz, a well-known scholar of Russian Jewry, presents essays on Jewish education (the heder), historiography, literature and Jewish philosophy that intersect with contemporary interests on the big questions of Jewish life. The book lets us grasp the meaning of secular Judaism and gives models from the past in order to stimulate ideas for the present.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
The Russian-Jewish Tradition Intellectuals, Historians, Revolutionaries
Jews of Russia & Eastern Europe and Their Legacy Series Editor: Maxim D. Shrayer (Boston College) Editorial Board Ilya Altman (Russian Holocaust Center and Russian State University for the Humanities) Karel Berkhoff (NIOD Institute for War, Holocaust and Genocide Studies) Jeremy Hicks (Queen Mary University of London) Brian Horowitz (Tulane University) Luba Jurgenson (Universite Paris IV—Sorbonne) Roman Katsman (Bar-Ilan University) Dov-Ber Kerler (Indiana University) Vladimir Khazan (Hebrew University of Jerusalem) Mikhail Krutikov (University of Michigan) Joanna Beata Michlic (Bristol University) Alice Nakhimovsky (Colgate University) Antony Polonsky (Brandeis University) Jonathan D. Sarna (Brandeis University) David Shneer (University of Colorado at Boulder) Anna Shternshis (University of Toronto) Leona Toker (Hebrew University of Jerusalem) Mark Tolts (Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
Boston The Russian-Jewish Tradition Intellectuals Historians Revolutionaries Brian Horowitz Introduction by William Craft Brumfield
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Horowitz, Brian, author. Title: The Russian-Jewish tradition: intellectuals, historians, revolutionaries / Brian Horowitz. Description: Brighton, MA: Academic Studies Press, 2017. Series: Jews of Russia & Eastern Europe and their legacy Identifiers: LCCN 2016042038 (print) LCCN 2016042920 (ebook) ISBN 9781618115560 (hardcover) ISBN 9781618115577 (e-book) Subjects: LCSH: Jews—Russia—Intellectual life—19th century. | Jews—Russia—Intellectual life—20th century. | Jews—Russia— History—19th century. | Jews—Russia—History—20th century. | Jewish scholars—Russia—Biography. Classification: LCC DS134.84. H685 2017 (print) LCC DS134.84 (ebook) DDC 947/.004924—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016042038 ISBN 978-1-61811-556-0 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-61811-557-7 (electronic) Copyright © 2017 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved Book design by Kryon Publishing www.kryonpublishing.com On the cover: Jewish house and store in Nerchinsk, Russia. Photograph by ©William C. Brumfield. Reproduced by the author's permission. Published by Academic Studies Press in 2017 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
Table of Contents Introduction: William Craft Brumfield vi PART I: Russian-Jewish Historians and Historiography 1 Chapter 1 The Return of the Ḥeder among Russian-Jewish Education Experts, 1840–1917 2 Chapter 2 ‘Building a Fragile Edifice’: A History of Russian-Jewish Historical Institutions, 1860–1914 19 Chapter 3 Myths and Counter-Myths about Odessa’s Jewish Intelligentsia during the Late Tsarist Period 38 Chapter 4 Saul Borovoi’s Survival: An Odessa Tale about a Jewish Historian in Soviet Times 53 Chapter 5 The Ideological Challenges of S. M. Dubnov in Emigration: Autonomism and Zionism, Europe and Palestine 70 PART II: Russian–Jewish Intelligentsia’s Cultural Vibrancy 85 Chapter 6 Semyon An-sky—Dialogic Writer 86 Chapter 7 Russian-Jewish Writers Face Pogroms, 1880–1914 111 Chapter 8 M. O. Gershenzon, Alexander Pushkin, the Bible, and the Flaws of Jewish Nationalism 123 Chapter 9 Battling for Self-Definition in Soviet Literature: Boris Eikhenbaum’s Jewish Question 139 Chapter 10 Vladimir Jabotinsky and the Mystique of 1905 156 Chapter 11 Vladimir Jabotinsky and Violence 177 PART III: Jewish Heritage in Russian Perception 197 Chapter 12 Vladimir Solov’ev and the Jews: A View from Today 198 Chapter 13 Fear and Stereotyping: Vasily Rozanov and Jewish Menace 215 Bibliography 233 Index 275
Introduction Brian Horowitz’s work over the past two decades has provided us with a multifaceted examination of the Jewish intelligentsia in its quest for a proper place in Russian society. This quest was fraught with ambiguity, particularly in a tsarist regime that frequently attempted to delegitimize the Jewish presence. In these circumstances the discipline of history has assumed an urgent role in defining and claiming Jewish legitimacy in Russia. The pursuance of historical narrative has involved no less than an existential meaning. The three parts of this book bring together various aspects of an enormously rich and complex enterprise. The efforts of Jewish historians and political activists to define as well as implement strategies for Jewish existence in Russia form a unifying element in this astute collection of essays. The essay form seems to play to Horowitz’s eclectic strengths as a scholar, who in the midst of gathering significant archival material has not been limited by a narrowness of vision and interpretation. In the first part Horowitz gives us a history of institutions, the ḥeder, newspapers, and works of history to show how a historiography developed—a self-consciousness of Jews in Russia. The pinnacle of that effort was richly embodied in the seventeen-volume Evreiskaia entsiklopediia, published by Brakgauz-Efron in St. Petersburg from 1907–1913. Concurrently, he offers studies of two historians: Semyon Dubnov, the doyen of the East European school of Jewish historiography, and Saul Borovoi, a less-known figure, but critical for understanding the Soviet Jewish experience. They not only embody the writer’s craft and the emotional dimension of a professional choice but also view their own experience through a socio-cultural lens that allows them to express the philosophical depth of interpretation in the twentieth century. (Dubnov perished during the Holocaust and Borovoi barely escaped).
Introduction vii In the second part Horowitz illuminates the writings of such pivotal figures as the folklorist Semyon An-sky, the Zionist and writer Vladimir Jabotinsky, the philosopher and historian Mikhail Gershenzon, and the eminent critic, Boris Eikhenbaum. The central point is not the conventional life and works, but an insight into the intellectual within a concrete historical context, an intellectual fashioning of a worldview at pivotal historical moments. For Jabotinsky it is 1923, the year he writes “The Iron Wall,” for Gershenzon it is 1921 and 1922, when he returns to the origins of culture in order to make sense of Russia after 1917. For Eikhenbaum the shock comes in the early 1930s, when he must face Stalinist literary politics. What should he do? How will he preserve his place or create a new role? The last part is devoted to studies of two Russians, Vladimir Solov’ev and Vasily Rozanov, and the role of Jews in the construction of a Russian idea. Despite his reputation as a philosemite, Solov’ev perhaps was not aware of his acceptance of the Enlightenment premise of Jewish conversion to Christianity. Rozanov acknowledged his disdain for Jews, yet they were essential to him in his reexamination of Christianity. The last essay deals with the little known topic of Jewish writing on the pogroms in the Russian language. Horowitz shows that deeply engaged writers despaired of the evanescence of integration that they saw vanish in their lifetimes. Horowitz has combined studies of institutions and individuals in order to play both sides, so to speak, on the question of historical agency. Was the earnestly dedicated Society for the Promotion of Enlightenment an indication of the future for modern Jewish intellectual life in Russia? Equally compelling, it seems, are the personalities and complex experiences of those who did not participate in the organized Jewish collective. They all make their appearance in this stimulating and amply researched collection. The book concludes with a telling counter-narrative advanced by Solov’ev and Rozanov. William Craft Brumfield, New Orleans, 2016
PART I Russian-Jewish Historians and Historiography
CHAPTER 1 The Return of the H. eder among Russian-Jewish Education Experts, 1840–1917 The role of the ḥeder in the modernization of Jewish education in the tsarist empire is a fascinating, albeit little-known, story. Most laymen and even scholars view the ḥeder monochromatically. They repeat the criticisms of the maskilim1 of the 1840s and later decades: the ḥeder was the obstacle to successful integration; nothing was learned there, the melamed beat the children, it was one of the vilest of religious institutions. However, there was a change in attitude toward the ḥeder at the beginning of the twentieth century among some of the most important specialists in the field of Jewish education in Russia. Some of these experts discovered in the ḥeder previously unnoticed dimensions that could be salvaged in future schools, while others saw parallels between the values of the ḥeder and the new national-leaning Jewish institutions. Still others were impressed by the ḥeder’s longevity, its success with the public, and its low costs. The School Commission of the Society for the Promotion of Enlightenment among the Jews of Russia (Obshchestvo dlia rasprostraneniia prosveshcheniia mezhdu evreiami v Rossii, or, OPE) along with Zionists and Bundists were involved with these questions. Research into the ḥeder and modern schools in the tsarist empire is largely divided between those who studied the question during tsarist times and those who approached these issues starting in the 1960s in Israeli and American universities. The kinds of questions each group posed were different because each group had its own political and cultural agendas. 1 A maskil was a Jew who was educated in a secular institution and strove for Jewish integration.