"Our Native Antiquity". Archaeology and Aesthetics in the Culture of Russian Modernism
Покупка
Тематика:
Искусствоведение
Издательство:
Academic Studies Press
Автор:
Kunichika Michael
Год издания: 2015
Кол-во страниц: 349
Дополнительно
Вид издания:
Монография
Уровень образования:
Дополнительное профессиональное образование
ISBN: 978-1-61811-442-6
Артикул: 694115.02.99
For Russian modernists in search of a past, there were many antiquities of different provenances and varying degrees of prestige from which to choose: Greece or Rome; Byzantium or Egypt. The modernists central to "Our Native Antiquity" located their antiquity in the Eurasian steppes, where they found objects and sites long denigrated as archaeological curiosities. The book follows the exemplary careers of two objects—the so-called "Stone Women” and the kurgan, or burial mound — and the attention paid to them by Russian and Soviet archaeologists, writers, artists, and filmmakers, for whom these artifacts served as resources for modernist art and letters and as arenas for a contest between vying conceptions of Russian art, culture, and history.
Скопировать запись
Фрагмент текстового слоя документа размещен для индексирующих роботов
“Our Native Antiquity” A r c h a e o l o g y a n d A e s t h e t i c s in the Culture of Russian Modernism
Studies in Russian and Slavic Literatures, Cultures, and History Series Editor Lazar fleishman (Stanford University, Palo Alto, California)
“Our Native Antiquity” A r c h a e o l o g y a n d A e s t h e t i c s in the Culture of Russian Modernism M i c h a e l K u n i c h i k a Boston / 2015
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: A bibliographic record for this title is available from the Library of Congress. Copyright © 2015 Academic Studies Press All rights reserved. ISBN (cloth) 978-1-61811-441-9 ISBN (electronic) 978-1-61811-442-6 Cover design by Ivan Grave On the cover: Detail of A. S. Uvarov, “Svedeniia o kamennykh babakh,” Trudy pervogo akheologicheskogo s’’ezda v Moskve (Moscow: V Sinodal’noi tipografii, 1871), 501-20. Title page: Vignette from A. P. Bogdanov, ed., Antropologicheskaia vystavka (Moscow: Tipografiia M. N. Lavrova, 1878-), 4:2:54. Published by Academic Studies Press in 2015 28 Montfern Avenue Brighton, MA 02135, USA press@academicstudiespress.com www.academicstudiespress.com
This book is dedicated to my teachers, my parents first among them.
T a b l e o f C o n t e n t s Acknowledgments Note on Translation and Transliteration 11 Introduction 12 i. Archaic Mirrors 15 ii. Elective Antiquities 19 Chapter One 27 The Archaeology of the Stone Babas and the Modernist Inheritance i. “Rough Hewn Statues” 34 ii. Idols Destroyed, Idols Displaced, 49 and the Steppe Denuded iii. The Modernist Peregrinations of the Stone Babas 57 Chapter Two 62 A Cultural Poetics of the Kurgan i. How to Excavate a Kurgan 62 ii. Gnedich, Iliada 69 iii. Vantage Points, ca. 1850 80 iv. 1876—The Grave Becomes a Cradle: 90 Zabelin contra Chaadaev v. Archaeological Defamiliarization 96 vi. Steppe Archaism and the Stratification of Time 100 Chapter Three 107 Ancient Statues, Ancient Terrors i. Archaic Simplicity 110 ii. Primitive Rudeness 120 iii. “No Ordinary Stone Woman” 128 Chapter Four 139 How a Modernist Artifact Is Made: The “Native Antiquity” of the Stone Babas and the Indigenization of Cubism i. The Stone Baba and the Bronze Horseman 147 ii. Indigenous Cubism 162
Chapter Five Velimir Khlebnikov, Poet of the Stone Babas i. “The Stone Woman” (1919): Modernist Metamorphosis 178 ii. The Steppes of Time: “A Night in a Trench” 190 iii. The Grave of Khlebnikov 201 Chapter Six 204 The Landmarks of Time: Burial Mounds, Eurasian Necropolises, and Modernist Form in Boris Pil’niak’s The Naked Year i. Volga “Pompeiis” 211 ii. Scythianism, 1918 217 iii. Modernist Stratigraphy: Uvek, Site of Time 222 iv. Modernist Topography: “Loop Station Mar” and the Poetics of Adjacency 234 Chapter Seven 243 Areas of Deformation Part One: Dziga Vertov and the Scythian 243 i. Areas of Deformation 247 ii. The Shooting Log 261 iii. The Archaeology of the Superimpositions 271 iv. Archaeology with a Hammer 275 Part Two: Boris Pil’niak’s The Volga Falls 280 to the Caspian Sea and the Courage of Farewell i. All That Was Solid Did Not Melt into Air: 287 Persisting Things ii. The Fluids of History: 291 Archaeology and Antiquarianism iii. The Courage of Farewell: 297 The Return of the Stone Women iv. Coda 307 Bibliography 312 Index 326
A c k n o w l e d g m e n t s I did not know upon entering the Russian Department at Reed College and, later, the Slavic Department at the University of California, Berkeley, how fortunate I would be, then and thankfully still now, in my teachers there. Justin Weir and Elena Bogdanovich at Reed College encouraged the first steps. So, too, did Lena Lencek, mentor and friend, who gave me a language to think about literature, and certainly about life, and she has watched over everything since with grace. And then at Berkeley, Robert Hughes, Liza Knapp, Lisa Little, Olga Matich, Hugh McLean, Anna Muza, Eric Naiman, Anne Nesbet, Irina Paperno, Harsha Ram, Alan Timberlake, the late Viktor Zhivov, and the visitors with whom I was also lucky to study while there— Katerina Clark, Gregory Freidin, and Andrew Kahn—scholarteachers all, I hope these pages reflect—Eric would probably say “pervert”—what they continue to teach me. At Berkeley, it seemed that everyone helped with the dissertation from which this book partially draws, but I thank especially Harsha, Eric, Anne, and Yuri Slezkine for advising it. With Harsha, I poured over every sentence and idea of the dissertation; with Anne, who taught me how to watch silent Soviet film, I saw Dziga Vertov’s “Scythian” in a theater in Sacile and the idea for the dissertation was born; with Yuri, at Ned’s, I realized the dissertation was actually about the steppe. And it was at the Neues Museum with Irina and Joachim Klein where I saw the kamennye baby for the first time and was encouraged that the book could actually become a book. Without Irina this book would never have found a home. I thank her and especially Lazar Fleishman for his editing and support, and for accepting it into his series. Penelope Burt and Jane Friedman edited the manuscript and improved it in every
way. Irene Masing-Delic, the manuscript’s “anonymous” reader, reviewed it with remarkable care and expert counsel. I thank Kira Nemirovsky, Sharona Vedol, and Meghan Vicks, the editors at Academic Studies Press, for their meticulous oversight of the entire publication process. Many friends and colleagues commented on early versions of these chapters, and I thank them for their tremendous help and suggestions: Richard Anderson, Polina Barskova, Evgenii Bershtein, Molly Brunson, Catherine Ciepiela, Anne Dwyer, Devin Fore, Victoria Frede, Toral Gajarwala, Sergey Glebov, Luba Golburt, Lilya Kaganovsky, Edward Kasinec, John MacKay— whose help with the chapter on Vertov was an extraordinary act of scholarly generosity—Boris Maslov, Miriam Neirick, Tatiana Nikitina, Dale Peterson, Jennifer Presto, Stanley Rabinowitz, Tom Roberts, Gabriella Safran, Jane Sharp—whose work on Natal’ia Goncharova and the kamennye baby helped me to realize what the literary side of the story could involve—Irina Shevelenko, Jon Stone, Jane Taubman, and Jane Tylus. Serguei Oushakine, Marina Mogilner, and Ilya Kukulin commented on an early version of chapter six that transformed and sharpened the claims of that chapter. And throughout, Robert Hughes and Olga Matich read, reread, and improved many of these chapters. My colleagues in the Department of Russian and Slavic Studies at New York University deserve a special word of thanks. The department has been a great place to teach these past seven years, and I thank Eliot Borenstein, Jane Burbank, Yanni Kotsonis, and, in particular, Anne Lounsbery, for her encouragement on an early version of the manuscript, and Ilya Kliger, the best office neighbor and interlocutor on deep time, among much else. All the mistakes that remain are mine. I am grateful to Jane Tylus and the Humanities Initiative, NYU (2008-09), for a year spent in the urban pastoral Jane creates there every year, during which I reconceived the book. And to Terry Martin and Stephanie Sandler, co-directors of the Seminar on Eurasian Subjectivities (2013-14), I am especially indebted for a Senior Fellowship at the Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies, Harvard University, which allowed me to complete the
revisions of the manuscript. I thank Joy Connolly, Dean for the Humanities at NYU, for supporting that leave. Portions of the book have benefitted from audiences at various institutions. I thank for their invitations and their comments the departments and audiences at: Amherst College; the Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies; the Five College Slavic Seminar; the New Scholars Series at Reed College; the NEH Seminar on Russian Modernism at the New York Public Library; the NYU Slavic Colloquium; the Poetics Workshop and Slavic Department of the University of Chicago; the Slavic Colloquium at Stanford University; the Slavic Seminar and the Slavic Department of Columbia University; and the Slavic departments at the University of California, Berkeley, the University of Wisconsin-Madison, the University of Oregon, Eugene, and Yale University. Along with these many debts, I thank friends and family who’ve provided support and distraction in tandem and in equal measure these past several years: Michael Allan; David Alsdorf; Kaveh Askari; Sylvan Brackett; Caroline Byfield; Bryan Cook; Judy Goldstein; Sarah Hamill; Louise Hornby; Joost Keizer; John Kunichika; Chris Lakey; Amnon Lev; Heather Lord; Anne Lorraine-Bujon; Grant, Lexi, and Jasper Mainland; Jeremy Melius; Kelly Miyata; Ricardo Montez; Maya Portner; Paull Randt; Sally and Moxie Rudoy; Sam Schaeffer; Eva Schuss; Mariko Silver; Lizbet Simmons; Meghan Sutherland; Lisa Wakamiya; Amanda Walling; Jenny Wapner; Patrick Weil; and Boris and Benjamin Wolfson. Then, again, there’s Boris Maslov and Devin Fore to thank for their many acts of friendship and faith. And, lastly, I thank my parents, Kenneth and Janice Kunichika, whose support has sustained me throughout the writing of this book.